Table 7.
Reference | Data sources | No. of samples | Model | Performance |
---|---|---|---|---|
Amyar et al. [13] | COVID CT [16], COVID-19 CT segmentation dataset [90], Henri Becquerel Center | Total: 1,044 COVID-19 : 449 Non-COVID-19 : 595 |
Encoder-decoder with multilayer perceptron | Accuracy: 86.0 Recall: 94.0 Specificity: 79.0 |
Elghamrawy and Hassanien. [80] | COVID-19 database [91], COVID CT [16] |
Total: 583 COVID-19 : 432 Non-COVID-19 : 151 |
WOA-CNN | Accuracy: 96.40 Recall: 97.25 Precision: 97.3 |
Farid et al. [78] | Kaggle benchmark dataset [85] | Total: 102 COVID-19 : 51 Non-COVID-19 : 51 |
CNN | Accuracy: 94.11 Precision: 99.4 F1: 94.0 |
Hasan et al. [58] | COVID-19 [92], SPIE-AAPM-NCI lung nodule classification challenge dataset [86] | Total: 321 COVID-19 : 118 Non-COVID-19 : 203 |
QDE–DF | Accuracy: 99.68 |
He et al. [11] | COVID-19 database [91], COVID-19 [92], Eurorad [93], corona cases [94] |
Total: 746 COVID-19 : 349 Non-COVID-19 : 397 |
CRNet | Accuracy: 86.0 F1: 85.0 AUC: 94.0 |
Liu et al. [68] | Ten designated COVID-19 hospitals in China | Total: 1,993 COVID-19 : 920 Non-COVID-19 : 1,073 |
Modified DenseNet-264 | Accuracy: 94.3 Recall: 93.1 Specificity: 95.1 |
Singh et al. [69] | COVID-19 patient chest CT images [95] | Total: 150 COVID-19 : 75 Non-COVID-19 : 75 |
MODE-CNN | Accuracy: 93.25 Recall: 90.70 Specificity: 90.72 |
Wang et al. [77] | Xi'an Jiaotong University, Nanchang University, Xi'an Medical College | Total: 1,065 COVID-19 : 740 Non-COVID-19 : 325 |
Modified inception | Accuracy: 79.3 Recall: 83.0 Specificity: 67.0 |
Song et al. [50] | Hospital of Wuhan University, third affiliated hospital | Total: 1,990 COVID-19 : 777 Non-COVID-19 : 1,213 |
DRE-Net | Accuracy: 94.3 Recall: 93.0 Precision: 96.0 |
Zheng et al. [70] | Union Hospital, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology | Total: 630 | DeCoVNet | Accuracy: 90.1 Recall: 90.7 Specificity: 91.1 |
| ||||
ADA-COVID | SARS-CoV-2 CT scan dataset | Total: 2,482 COVID-19 : 1,252 Non-COVID-19 : 1,229 |
ResNet50 | Accuracy: 99.96 Recall: 99.80 Specificity: 99.80 F1: 99.90 |