Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 2;80(3):544–560. doi: 10.1093/nutrit/nuab041

Table 3.

Quality assessment of included interventionsa

Reference Selection bias Study design Confounders Blinding Data collection methods Withdrawals and drop-outs Overall rating Funding COI
Ceballos-Gurrola 202020 Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Strong Moderate Moderate NR NR
Diáz 201021 Weak Strong Strong Strong Strong Weak Weak Funded by an international agency Nothing to declare
Elizondo-Montemayor 201322 Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak No funding received Nothing to declare
Elizondo-Montemayor 201423 Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Strong Weak Funded by a private university Nothing to declare
Escalante-Izeta 2013 (abstract)24 Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Weak Weak Weak NR NR
García-Morales 200625 Moderate Strong Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Abbott Laboratories NR
Garibay-Nieto 201726 Weak Strong Strong Moderate Strong Weak Weak Science Mexican Council NR
González-Heredia 201427 Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak NR Nothing to declare
Hall-López 201728 Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak Funded by a public university Nothing to declare
Huang 201029–31 Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Strong Strong Funded by a public pediatric hospital Nothing to declare
Jimenez 2017 (abstract)32 Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Weak Weak Weak NR NR
Laguna-Alcaraz 201733 Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak No funding received Nothing to declare
López-Alarcon 201934 Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong Funded by public health institute and National Council of Education and Science Mexican Council Nothing to declare
López-Alarcon 202035 Moderate Strong Strong Weak Strong Strong Moderate Funded by public health institute Nothing to declare
Luna-Ruiz 200736 Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Strong Moderate NR NR
Martin-Mosqueda 201237 Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak NR NR
Moran 201738 Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Strong Moderate NR NR
Pompa-Guajardo 201839 Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Moderate Weak NR NR
Rodríguez-Morán 201440 Moderate Strong Strong Moderate Strong Moderate Strong Partially funded by public health institute Nothing to declare
Romero-Pérez 202041 Moderate Strong Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak No funding received Nothing to declare
Rosado 200842 Strong Strong Strong Moderate Strong Moderate Strong Funded by industry (Kellogg’s) Nothing to declare
Rosas-Nexticapa 201743 Weak Strong Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak Funded by the National Council of Education and Science Mexican Council NR
Sáenz-Soto 200444 Weak Moderate Strong Moderate Strong Moderate Moderate NR NR
Santiago-Lagunes 2018 (Abstract)45 Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak NR NR
de Sanchez 200446 Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Strong Weak NR NR
Velázquez-López 200947 Moderate Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak Unclear if funded by public health institute Nothing to declare
Velázquez-López 201448 Moderate Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong Strong Funded by public health institute Nothing to declare
Violante-Ortíz 200549 Weak Moderate Strong Moderate Strong Weak Weak NR NR
Virgen-Ortíz 2007 (letter to the editor)50 Weak Moderate Weak Moderate Strong Weak Weak NR NR

Abbreviations: COI, conflict of interest; NR, not reported.

a

Quality assessed using the Effective Public Health Practice Project Quality Assessment Tool12 for quantitative studies.