Table 4.
Model | Features | Advantages | Applications | Challenges | Directions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Single-cell Systems (2D) | Seeding only one cell type in a tissue culture plate (TCP) | - High availability - Easy to make - Cost-effective - High reproducibility - High throughput |
- Evaluation of drug and drug delivery system - Mechanistic studies |
- Fail to mimic the native plaque composition and vascular structure | - Creating a co-culture system |
Direct Co-culture (2D) | Direct cell-to-cell seeding of multicell types in a TCP | - Study of cell-cell interaction and adhesion | - Difficulty mimicking native physiological structures and proper development of cellular interactions with ECM | - Using ECM - mimicking scaffold |
|
In-direct Transwell Co-culture (2D) | Cells seeded in a TCP and trans-well inserts | - Study of cellular responses via secretory pathways and cytokine production | - Improving cell attachment - Using ECM mimicking scaffold |
||
Cell Sheet (2D) | Layered structure seeded on the 2D scaffolds or no scaffolds | - Better mimicking the vascular wall structure than other 2D systems - Relatively easy to fabricate |
- Potential for therapeutic evaluation - Potential for studying cell-cell interaction |
- Prone to spontaneous shrinkage or contraction - Lacking adequate mechanical properties - More expensive than TCP based systems |
- Increasing mechanical property through other types of scaffolds - Exploration of applications of such systems |
Microfluidic Chip (2D) | Endothelium seeded on a chip with a flow | - Micro-analysis - Providing continuous monitoring and medium supply - Enhanced sensitivity - Dynamic culture - Relatively easy to make |
- Mechanistic studies - Nanomedicine evaluation - Allowing real-time imaging |
- Require additional types of equipment, such as pumps, tubing, and connectors - Not adequately model 3D native environments - Costly |
- Using ECM mimicking scaffold - Using multiple vascular cells observed in the plaque |
Spheroid (3D) | Cellular aggregates to provide 3D structures | - Providing spherical structures - Advanced plaque |
- Mechanistic studies | - Limited capability or function in comparison to native tissue - Failing to provide the layered vascular structure - Low quantity of spheroids |
- Large production of this model |
Cell-laden Hydrogel Construct (3D) | Cells embedded within hydrogel scaffolds | - Ability to provide an ECM mimicking environment provided by the scaffold - relatively easy to make |
- Mechanistic studies | - Difficult to reproduce - Poor mechanical properties |
- Increase mechanical properties and reproducibility - Controlling the properties of hydrogels - Using these systems for various applications |
Tissue-engineered Blood Vessel (3D) | Models reproducing native vessel structure and size with or without disease features | - Allowing controlled stimuli - Providing partially vessel-like structure - Dynamic culture - Providing similar size to that of native vessels |
- Drug evaluation - Mechanistic studies - Potential for medical device evaluation - Allowing real-time imaging |
- Majority are not developed using arterial cells - Lacking the fibroblast layer - Challenging to have a monolayer of endothelium - Failing to induce advanced atherosclerotic plaques - Expensive and difficult to reproduce - Time-consuming |
- Producing three-layered vessel - Using arterial cells or stem cells - Incorporating T and B cells in the system - Large scale production for pharmaceutical use - Improving reproducibility - Providing advanced plaque |
Vessel-on-a-chip (3D) | Models reproducing vessel structures with or without disease feature on a micro-sized chip | - Allowing controlled stimuli and real-time imaging - Providing partially vessel-like structure - Dynamic culture |
- Applicable for drug screening - Mechanistic studies - Allowing real-time imaging |
- Expensive and difficult to reproduce - Additional equipment to create a dynamic microenvironment - Lacking three-layered structures - Time-consuming - Inability to provide actual size vessel for medical device evaluation - Limited to drug screening |