4.1. Analysis.
Comparison 4 UPDRS ADL section (Part II), Outcome 1 UPDRS ADL section (Part II).
UPDRS ADL section (Part II) | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study | Placebo | Entacapone | Tolcapone (50mg) | Tolcapone (100mg) | Tolcapone (200mg) | Tolcapone (400mg) |
Entacapone | ||||||
Brooks UK‐IRISH 2003 | Placebo n = 57 | Entacapone n = 115; not significant | ||||
Myllyla FILOMEN 2001 | 'On' state. Placebo n = 93 | Entacapone n = 182, P<0.001 | ||||
Poewe CELOMEN 2002 | 'On' state. Placebo n = 88 | Entacapone n= 172, P<0.05 (95% CI ‐2.46; ‐0.02) | ||||
PSG SEESAW 1997 | 'On' state. Placebo n= 102 | Entacapone n=103; P=0.03 | ||||
Rinne NOMECOMT 1998 | Placebo n = 86 | Entacapone n = 85; P<0.01 | ||||
Tolcapone (all doses) | ||||||
Adler TFSGIII 1998 | Placebo n=72, least‐squares mean = ‐0.7 (SD 3.4) | Tolcapone 100mg n=69, least squares mean = ‐0.4 (SD 3.3); not significant | Tolcapone 200mg n=74, least‐squares mean =‐0.5 (SD 3.4); not significant | |||
Baas 1997 | Placebo n=58 (no data available) | Tolcapone 100mg n=60 (no data available); not significant | Tolcapone 200mg n=59 (no data available); not significant | |||
Dupont TIPSII 1997 | 'On' state. Placebo least‐squares mean = 0.4 (SD 2.3) | Tolcapone 200mg n=32 least‐squares mean = 1.1 (SD 2.3); p<0.05 | Tolcapone 400mg n=32, least square mean = 0.1 (SD 2.3); not significant | |||
Myllyla TIPS1 1997 | 'On' state. Placebo least‐squares mean = ‐0.8 (SD 3.0) | Tolcapone 50mg n=34, least squares mean = ‐0.6 (SD 2.9); not significant | Tolcapone 200mg n=31 least‐squares mean = ‐1.4 (SD 2.8); not significant | Tolcapone 400mg n=31, least squares mean = ‐1.5 (SD 2.8); not significant | ||
Rajput 1997 | 'On' state. Placebo n=66, mean = ‐0.3 (SD 4.1) | Tolcapone 100mg n=69, mean =‐0.8 (SD 3.3); not significant | Tolcapone 200mg n=67 mean = 0.2 (SD 3.3); not significant |