Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 6;22(3):1228. doi: 10.3390/s22031228

Table 9.

MLP-based DSD cross-validation performance vs. feature subsets–RLDD and RODeCAR.

Feature Subset Subset Size RLDD RODeCAR
UA [%] WA [%] UA [%] WA [%]
all 2260 54.0 54.0 51.0 53.4
APF 26 53.0 53.0 52.4 53.4
FDF 1842 55.3 55.3 52.4 52.9
MFCC 78 52.0 52.0 52.5 52.9
MBF 312 58.6 58.6 53.8 54.8
UPF 2 49.8 49.7 51.4 59.6
APF + FDF 1868 55.5 55.5 52.7 52.8
APF + MFCC 104 52.5 52.5 53.6 54.2
APF + MBF 338 57.5 57.5 53.9 54.2
APF + UPF 28 51.8 51.8 52.6 53.0
FDF + MFCC 1920 54.9 54.9 52.6 53.2
FDF + MBF 2154 56.5 56.5 52.8 52.1
FDF + UPF 1844 55.1 55.2 51.9 52.5
MFCC + MBF 390 57.9 57.9 52.7 55.0
MFCC + UPF 80 53.4 53.4 52.0 53.6
MBF + UPF 314 56.8 56.8 53.4 55.5
APF + FDF + MFCC 1946 55.7 55.7 53.1 54.7
APF + FDF + MBF 2180 56.0 56.0 51.6 51.3
APF + FDF + UPF 1870 57.4 57.5 52.4 53.5
APF + MFCC + MBF 416 57.4 57.5 53.8 54.6
APF + MFCC + UPF 106 54.8 54.8 52.4 53.4
APF + MBF + UPF 340 58.1 58.1 54.9 55.0
FDF + MFCC + MBF 2232 57.2 57.2 51.6 52.4
FDF + MFCC + UPF 1922 54.9 55.0 52.4 54.0
FDF + MBF + UPF 2156 55.5 55.5 52.7 53.8
MFCC + MBF + UPF 392 55.4 55.4 53.1 55.1
APF + FDF + MFCC + MBF 2258 56.8 56.8 52.1 54.7
APF + FDF + MFCC + UPF 1948 55.7 55.7 52.0 54.2
APF + FDF + MBF + UPF 2182 55.5 55.5 52.1 53.6
APF + MFCC + MBF + UPF 418 56.0 56.0 53.0 55.6
FDF + MFCC + MBF + UPF 2234 56.2 56.2 52.3 51.7
top-10 selected by the KS-based algorithm 10 59.3 59.2 51.6 53.6
top-20 selected by the KS-based algorithm 20 58.1 58.2 52.3 56.5
top-50 selected by the KS-based algorithm 50 58.3 58.3 52.5 53.3
top-100 selected by the KS-based algorithm 100 58.0 58.0 52.0 53.4
top-200 selected by the KS-based algorithm 200 55.0 55.1 52.3 51.5