Table 1.
Stimulus | Responsive moiety | Immunomodulator | Tumor type | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
pH |
pH‐cleavage: Amide bond pH‐sponge: PDEA |
PD‐L1 blockade siRNA and photosensitizer | Melanoma | [ 16 ] |
pH‐cleavage: Amide bond | Isothiocyanate, MEK‐, BRAF‐inhibitor, and anti‐PD‐1 | Metastatic melanoma | [ 17 ] | |
pH‐protonation: PAA | Au and DOX | Hepatoma | [ 18 ] | |
pH‐swelling: Tetraethylenepentamine | RNA interference | Prostatic carcinoma | [ 19 ] | |
pH‐responsive size shrinkage: Di‐tert‐butyl dicarbonate | DOX | Breast carcinoma | [ 20 ] | |
pH‐responsive shell‐cleavage: Boronate ester bond | Bortezomib | Breast carcinoma | [ 21 ] | |
GSH | GSH‐cleavage: Disulfide‐bridge | Photosensitizer Ce6, anti‐CTLA‐4 antibody, and Fe3O4 | Breast carcinoma | [ 22 ] |
GSH‐cleavage: Tetrasulfide bond | DOX and PD‐L1 antibody | Breast carcinoma | [ 23 ] | |
GSH‐cleavage: Disulfide‐bond | Photosensitizer and IDO‐1 | Breast carcinoma and colorectal cancer | [ 24 ] | |
GSH‐cleavage: Disulfide‐bond | Photosensitizer and IDO inhibitor | Breast carcinoma | [ 25 ] | |
Redox‐sensitive linkage: Diselenide bond | PTX | Breast carcinoma | [ 26 ] | |
GSH‐cleavage: Disulfide‐bond | Docetaxel and Chondroitin sulfate | Breast carcinoma | [ 27 ] | |
Enzyme | β‐glucuronidase‐degradation: Glucuronide | Imidazoquinoline TLR7/8 agonist | Raw blue reporter cell line | [ 28 ] |
HAase‐responsive: HA | Cilengitide and TNF‐related apoptosis inducing ligand | Human breast carcinoma | [ 29 ] | |
Enzyme‐degradation: Matrix metalloproteinases peptide | TLR7 agonist 1V209 and Cy 5.5 dye | Breast carcinoma | [ 30 ] | |
Enzyme responsive: Gly‐phe‐leu‐gly tetrapeptide linker | DOX | Breast carcinoma | [ 31 ] | |
Enzyme‐degradation: Matrix metalloproteinases peptide | PD‐L1 inhibitor and DOX | Melanoma | [ 32 ] | |
Enzyme‐responsive: Polytyrosine | DOX | Colorectal carcinoma | [ 33 ] | |
ROS | H2O2‐reaction: MnO2 | Gold‐photosensitizer and MnO2 | Breast carcinoma | [ 34 ] |
ROS‐trigger: Tellurium nanowire | Bovine serum albumin and dextran | Breast carcinoma | [ 35 ] | |
H2O2‐reaction: MnO2 | Glycolysis inhibitor and lactate oxidase | Melanoma | [ 36 ] | |
H2O2‐reaction: MnO2 | Acriflavine | Breast carcinoma | [ 37 ] | |
ROS‐cleavage: Thioketal bond | CPT, photosensitizer, and Pt | Colon cancer | [ 38 ] | |
ROS‐responsive: Thioether | PTX and Ce6 | Breast carcinoma | [ 39 ] | |
Photo | Photo‐responsive: Photosensitizer PpIX | PpIX and immune checkpoint inhibitor 1MT | Colorectal carcinoma | [ 40 ] |
Photo‐cleavage: O‐nitrobenzyl | DOX | Cervical carcinoma | [ 41 ] | |
Photo‐degradation: 9,10‐dialkoxy‐anthracene based precursor |
Graphene quantum dot | Breast carcinoma | [ 42 ] | |
Photothermal decomposition: PPP | Fe/FeO nanocrystal, ICG, and DOX | Oral epithelial carcinoma | [ 43 ] | |
Photo‐responsive: Chloride disulfonic acid | CPT and photosensitizer Al(III) phthalocyanine chloride disulfonic acid | Breast carcinoma | [ 44 ] | |
US | US‐responsive: Methoxyethyl methacrylate | DOX | Cervical carcinoma | [ 45 ] |
US‐responsive: US contrast agent microbubble | Interfering RNA | Cervical carcinoma | [ 46 ] | |
US‐triggered: Ce6 ester | DOX and Ce6 | Fibrosarcoma | [ 47 ] | |
US‐responsive: Erythrocyte membrane | DOX and hermimether | Hepatoma carcinoma | [ 48 ] | |
US‐responsive: 2‐tetrahydropyranyl methacrylate | DOX | Prostatic cancer | [ 49 ] | |
Magnetic field | Magnetic ferrite | Fe3O4 and MnFe2O4 | Breast carcinoma | [ 50 ] |
Mn–Zn ferrite | Mn‐Zn ferrite | Breast carcinoma | [ 51 ] | |
Domain iron oxide | Ferrimagnetic vortex and PD‐L1 blockade | Breast carcinoma | [ 52 ] | |
Magnetization and superparamagnetism | PD‐1 antibody | Breast carcinoma | [ 53 ] | |
Superparamagnetic iron oxide | Fe3O4 and L‐arginine | Breast carcinoma | [ 54 ] | |
Radiation | Radiation‐cleavage: Diselenide bond | DOX and PD‐L1 checkpoint blockade | Breast carcinoma | [ 55 ] |
Radiation splinter: Au nanocarrier | aPD‐L1 | Colorectal carcinoma | [ 56 ] | |
Radiation‐diffusion: Adenine‐modified ZnS | DOX | Glioma | [ 57 ] | |
Radiation‐responsive mesoporous silica shells of Eu3+‐doped NaGdF4 | ICG and s‐nitrosothiol group | Breast carcinoma | [ 58 ] | |
Radiation‐responsive splintery snowflake‐like Au | aPD‐L1, Au, and Ag nanocrystal | Pancreatic carcinoma | [ 56 ] | |
Photo/hypoxia | Light‐triggered/hypoxia‐responsive: 2‐nitroimidazole‐grafted conjugated polymer | DOX | Cervical carcinoma | [ 59 ] |
Photo/pH | pH/light responsive: Poly(N‐isopropylacrylamide‐co‐acrylic acid) | DOX and photosensitizer | Cervical carcinoma | [ 60 ] |
pH/thermal | pH‐responsive: Acrylamide; thermal‐responsive: Poly(acrylamide‐co‐acrylonitrile)‐PEG | Bovine lactoferricin and HA | Melanoma | [ 61 ] |
Photo/pH/hyperthermia |
pH‐cleavage: Amide groups; Photo‐cleavage: Ester bond; Photo hyperthermia: Cypate |
Cypate and DOX | Breast carcinoma | [ 62 ] |
pH/GSH/enzyme | PEG‐peptide‐poly(ω‐pentadecalacto‐ne‐co‐N‐methyldiethyleneamine‐co‐thiodipropionate) block | Ce6 and sorafenib | Lung carcinoma | [ 63 ] |
Abbreviations: aPD‐L1, anti‐programmed death ligand 1; Ce6, chlorin e6; HA, hyaluronic acid; ICG, indocyanine green; IDO‐1, indoleamine 2,3‐dioxygenase 1; PAA, polyacrylic acid; PDEA, poly(2‐(diethylamino) ethyl methacrylate; PPP, PLGA−polyethylene glycol−poly(N‐isopropyl acrylamide); TNF, tumor necrosis factor.