Skip to main content
. 2021 Dec 6;36(3):1761–1774. doi: 10.1007/s00464-021-08914-z

Table 3.

Descriptive data of assessment tools

Tool Abb Year Items Versions Score range Original or modified
Global Rating Scale
 1

Sidhu et al. [17]

Self-assessment scale

SAS 2006 11 1 11–55 Previously validated GOALS and OSATS
 2

Wohaibi et al. [18]

OpRate

OpRate 2007 6 1 1–4 (m) Original
 3

Niitsu et al. [32]

OSATS

OSATS 2012 7 1 7–35 Previously validated OSATS
 4

Jenkins et al. [19]

GMAS/DOPS

GMAS 2016 12 1 0–45 Original GMAS and previously validated DOPS
 5

Watanabe et al. [20]

IRT-GOALS

IRT-GOALS 2017 5 1 5–25 Previously validated GOALS
Error-based rating scale
 6

Miskovic et al. [8]

OCHRA

OCHRA 2012 3 1 3–25 Previously validated GAS, and OCHRA
Procedure-specific tool
 7

Dath. et al. [33]

OCRS

OCRS 2003 7 1 1–5(m) Original OCRS and previously validated OSATS
 8

Sarker et al. [21, 22]*

Technical skills assessment tool for laparoscopic colectomy

TSALC 2010–2011 7–9 3% 35–45 Original
 9

Palter et al. [7, 23]*

Procedure-specific evaluation tools

PSET 2011–2012 18 or 18/19 2 & 50–80 or 50–90 Original
 10

Miskovic et al. [2426, 34]*

GAS-tool

GAS 2011 12 1 1–72 Original
 11

Miskovic et al. [1, 27, 28]*

CAT-tool

CAT 2013 16 1 1–4 (m) Original
 12

Glarner et al. [29]

Comprehensive assessment Tool

CT 2013 8 1 1–5 (m) Original CT and modified OSATS and NOTSS
 13

Champagne et al. [2, 30]*

ASCRS Tool

ASCRS 2017 9 1 1–5 (m) Previously validated OSATS and OCHRA
 14

Nakayama et al. [31]

ASLAC score

ASLAC 2020 35 1 NR Original

Abb: Abbreviation Year: year of publication Items: number of statements evaluated on a rating scale. If the tool includes general, non-technical and procedure-specific items, only the procedure-specific items will be considered Versions: number of versions available for laparoscopic colon procedures NR: not reported (m) mean

*Only number from the first validation paper has been reported