Table 3.
Effects | Randomized controlled trials | Observational studies | Systematic reviews |
---|---|---|---|
Decrease of disease severity | Prospective study, 25 patients
95
Prospective LUMINA Cohort, 256 patients 84 Cross-sectional study, 57 patients 96 Longitudinal study, LUMINA cohort, 35 patients 85 Prospective study, 41 SLE patients 97 Observational study, 28 SLE pregnant women 98 Retrospective study, 165 SLE patients 99 Retrospective study, 101 SLE patients 100 Prospective Hopkins Lupus Cohort, 916 patients 101 |
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 | |
Prevent of disease flare | RCT, NCT03122431: 73 stable LN patients
73
RCT, NCT00413361: 573 patients 72 RCT, 24 SLE patients stable disease 14 RCT, 47 clinically stable SLE patients 66 RCT, 20 patients lupus pregnancy 71 |
Retrospective, matched with themselves, 43/209 patients
102
Retrospective, matched with themselves, 43 patients, 76 matched years 103 Prospective, Padua Lupus Cohort, 319 SLE patients 104 Retrospective study, 101 SLE patients 100 Prospective, Hopkins Lupus Cohort, 2512 patients 78 Longitudinal, 143 SLE patients 105 |
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 |
Cutaneous lupus | RCT, NCT01551069: 103 patients Cutaneous Lupus
75
RCT, 20 patients lupus pregnancy 71 |
Retrospective, matched with themselves, 43/209 patients
102
Prospective, 17/27 patients SLE 106 Prospective, 300 patients subacute or chronic CLE 107 Retrospective cohort, 200 patients DLE 108 Cross-sectional study, 1002 patients CLE 109 Prospective cohort, 218 CLE and SLE patients 110 Retrospective, 36 LE tumidus 111 Retrospective, 61 DLE and SCLE patients 112 Prospective, 34 CLE patients 113 |
Databases: Medline, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane 114 |
Adjuvant for lupus nephritis remission | Prospective, Hopkins Lupus Cohort, 29 patients
79
Retrospective study, 35 patients 115 Retrospective study, 206 patients lupus nephritis 116 Prospective LUMINA Cohort, 256 patients 84 Retrospective study, 90 patients with lupus nephritis 117 |
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 | |
Improvement of articular complaints | RCT, 71 SLE patients mild SLE
68
RCT, 24 SLE patients stable disease 14 |
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 | |
Decrease disease activity/prevent flare during pregnancy | RCT, 20 patients lupus pregnancy 71 | Prospective study, 60 patients – 103 pregnancies
118
Prospective, Hopkins Lupus Pregnancy Cohort, 282 (163 + 56 + 68) pregnancies 80 Retrospective study, 176 patients – 396 pregnancies 119 Retrospective study, 179 pregnancies 120 |
Databases: Medline and Embase
3
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 |
Protection against preeclampsia | Retrospective cohort, 151 pregnancies
121
Prospective cohort, 316 pregnancies 122 114 HCQ-exposed pregnancies 123 |
||
Prevention of fetal growth restriction and prematurity | Observational study, 28 SLE pregnant women 98 | ||
Reducing antiphospholipid antibodies persistence | Retrospective study, 90 patients – 17 patients with persistent LA 124 | ||
Reduce the risk of thrombosis | Prospective cohort, 92 patients
125
Retrospective study, 272 patients 126 Prospective cohort, 232 patients 127 Prospective cohort, 67 SLE-aPL patients 128 Retrospective study, 206 patients lupus nephritis 116 Longitudinal, cross-sectional, 144 patients 129 Prospective, Tromso Lupus cohort, 158 patients 130 Retrospective study, 1930 patients 131 Nested case–control study, 54 SLE cases versus 108 controls 132 Prospective Hopkins Cohort, 1795 SLE patients, 193 thrombotic events, 10,508 person-years 133 Prospective study, 189 SLE patients 134 Prospective Hopkins Cohort, 739 patients 135 |
Databases: Medline and Embase
3
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 |
|
Lower fasting glucose/diabetes mellitus protection | Cross-sectional study, 149 SLE patients
136
Population-based cohort study, 221 with diabetes mellitus out of 8628 SLE patients 137 |
||
Improving lipidic profile | RCT, 72 SLE patients
69
RCT, 17/19 SLE female patients 70 |
Cross-sectional, 155 patients (SLE + AR)
138
Case-control, 18 SLE patients 139 Longitudinal Cohort – John Hopkins, 264 patients 81 Retrospective study, 382 patients 140 Cross-sectional study, 123 patients 141 Cross-sectional study, 90 subjects – 60 SLE patients 142 Cross-sectional study, 86 patients 143 Prospective study, 30 subjects – 20 SLE patients 144 Cross-sectional study, 185 outpatients 145 Prospective – Toronto Lupus Cohort – 1260 patients 90 Case-control, 100 lupus nephritis patients 146 Cross-sectional study, 24 patients 147 Prospective Hopkins Cohort, 51 patients, over 229 visits 82 Cross-sectional study, 48 patients 148 |
Databases: PubMed, Embase, Cochrane
149
Databases: PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, Medline/Ovid, Google Scholar, CINAHL, Cochrane 150 Databases: Medline and Embase 3 Databases: Medline and Embase 13 |
Reduction of atherosclerosis | Pittsburgh Lupus Registry, 220 women
151
Prospective study, 41 SLE patients and 96 controls 152 |
Databases: Medline and Embase 153 | |
Decrease the risk of infections | Retrospective study, 206 patients lupus nephritis
116
A nested case–control study, Lupus-Cruces cohort, 83/166 patients 154 Prospective cohort, Northern California, 3030 patients 155 Retrospective study, Spanish Rheumatology Society Lupus Registry (RELESSER), 3658 patients 156 Case–control study, 65 SLE patients versus 130 controls 157 Prospective RELES Cohort, 282 SLE patients 158 Retrospective study, 339 patients 159 Inception cohort study GLADEL, 1243 patients 92 Population-based study, 24343 SLE patients 160 |
Databases: PubMed, Embase, Cochrane 161 | |
Improvement of bone mineral density | Prospective study, 92 patients
162
Prospective study, 34 SLE patients 163 |
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 | |
Protection against osteonecrosis | Nested matched case–control study, LUMINA cohort 86 | Databases: Medline and Embase 13 | |
Decrease the corticosteroids need | RCT, 20 patients lupus pregnancy 71 | Retrospective, matched with themselves, 43 patients, 76 matched years
103
Prospective LUMINA Cohort, 256 patients 84 Prospective study, 257 pregnancies 80 |
|
Protection against accrual damage | Prospective Israeli Cohort, 151 patients
164
Prospective LUMINA Cohort, 632 patients 88 Prospective LUMINA Cohort, 256 lupus nephritis 84 Prospective LUMINA Cohort, 580 patients 89 Prospective Hopkins Cohort, 2054 patients 83 Nested case-control, Inception cohort – Toronto Lupus Cohort, 685 patients: 174/307 patients 3 SLICC Inception Cohort Study, 1722 patients 165 Retrospective inception cohort, 476 subjects, 26 years 166 Early Lupus Project, Prospective Inception Cohort, 230 patients 167 |
Databases: Medline and Embase 3 | |
Protection against neoplasia | Prospective cohort, 235 patients 168 | ||
Reducing SLE-related hospitalization | Retrospective study, 339 patients
159
Retrospective study, 526 patients 169 Retrospective registry-based, 40,381 patients 170 |
||
Improvement of survival | Case-control, 76 matched pairs
171
Prospective cohort, 232 patients 127 Case-control study – LUMINA L cohort, 608 patients 87 Retrospective study, 206 patients lupus nephritis 116 Prospective University of Toronto Lupus Clinic, 1241 patients 91 Prospective GLADEL cohort, 1480 patients 93 Retrospective, 1956 SLE inpatients 172 Retrospective, 42 patients lupus nephritis 173 Retrospective study, 491 patients with lupus nephritis 174 Prospective cohort, 803 SLE patients 175 Longitudinal cohort, 345 lupus nephritis patients 176 Prospective cohort, 914 SLE patients 177 Retrospective study, 6241 patients 178 |
Databases: Medline and Embase
3
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 |
|
Delays the evolution to SLE | Retrospective study, 130 military personal
179
Nested case–control study, GLADEL cohort, 265/530 patients 94 |
Databases: Medline and Embase 13 |
CC, case-control; CLE, cutaneous lupus erythematosus; CS, cross-sectional; DLE, discoid lupus erythematosus; DS, descriptive studies; GLADEL, Grupo Latino Americano de Estudio del Lupus; HCQ, hydroxychloroquine; LAC, lupus anticoagulant; LN, lupus nephritis; LUMINA, Lupus in Minorities: Nature vs Nurture; PC, prospective cohort; RA, retrospective analysis; RC, retrospective cohort; RCT, randomized controlled trial; SCLE, subacute cutaneous lupus erythematosus; SLICC, Systemic Lupus International Collaborating Clinics.