Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 17;205:114101. doi: 10.1016/j.bios.2022.114101

Table 2.

Advantages and drawbacks of isothermal amplification techniques.

Advantages Drawbacks
Rt-qPCR Specific
Sensitive
Simultaneous detection and quantification
High cost
Specific machine required
Absolute quantification relies on standard curve
Temperature of reaction
LAMP Highly specific
Can be detected by a cheap turbidimeter
No initial heating step
Speed (within 1 h)
Complex primers design
High temperature (60–65 °C)
Possible primer-primer annealing
Detection limit
RCA Simple mechanism
Easy primer design
Temperature of reaction (30–37 °C)
Easily detectable
Numerous rounds of amplifications
RNA amplification is complex
Works only with circular templates
Occurs only linearly over time
NASBA Specifically designed to detect RNA and in turn RNA viruses
Temperature of reaction (41 °C)
Fast
Denaturation step
Less efficient in amplifying RNA targets out of the range 120–250 bp
RNA integrity
Pre-heating step
MCDA Fastest method
No initial heating step
Speed (40 min)
Sensitivity, specificity
Low cost
Complex primers design
High temperature (60–67 °C)
RPA High sensitivity
Temperature of reaction (37 °C)
Simple primers design
Extremely quick (20 min)
No initial heating step
Non-specific background
Possible primer-primer annealing
Inhibition by high genomic DNA concentrations
Detection limit