Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 16;12:2632. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-06529-5

Table 2.

Performance scores at FPR = 0.20 for 21 prediction models by 5-fold CV with the training dataset that was consisted of 1:2 ratio of positive and negative samples.

Predictors classifier (encoding) TPR TNR FNR ACC MCC MCR AUC pAUC
ADA (CKSAAP) 0.676 (0.32) 0.800 (0.00) 0.323 (0.32) 0.689 (0.01) 0.378 (0.16) 0.311 (0.01) 0.737 (0.04) 0.12 (0.06)
ADA (binary) 0.613 (0.03) 0.800 (0.01) 0.386 (0.03) 0.657 (0.01) 0.315 (0.03) 0.343 (0.01) 0.718 (0.03) 0.11 (0.07)
ADA (AAC) 0.644 (0.31) 0.801 (0.00) 0.355 (0.31) 0.692 (0.03) 0.383 (0.02) 0.291 (0.09) 0.747 (0.05) 0.133 (0.04)
ADA (CKSAAP, binary) 0.650 (0.24) 0.800 (0.01) 0.349 (0.24) 0.702 (0.12) 0.407 (0.24) 0.297 (0.12) 0.771 (0.10) 0.136 (0.05)
ADA (CKSAAP, AAC) 0.661 (0.09) 0.800 (0.00) 0.339 (0.09) 0.712 (0.10) 0.417 (0.21) 0.289 (0.10) 0.783 (0.09) 0.139 (0.03)
ADA (binary, AAC) 0.653 (0.12) 0.800 (0.00) 0.347 (0.12) 0.710 (0.13) 0.412 (0.11) 0.292 (0.13) 0.778 (0.10) 0.137 (0.09)
ADA (CKSAAP, binary, AAC) 0.654 (0.08) 0.801 (0.00) 0.346 (0.08) 0.721 (0.01) 0.456 (0.15) 0.287 (0.07) 0.799 (0.02) 0.140 (0.06)
SVM (CKSAAP) 0.677 (0.16) 0.800 (0.00) 0.323 (0.03) 0.712 (0.12) 0.425 (0.07) 0.287 (0.02) 0.788 (0.06) 0.143 (0.07)
SVM (binary) 0.683 (0.02) 0.800 (0.00) 0.317 (0.03) 0.718 (0.01) 0.438 (0.15) 0.281 (0.09) 0.787 (0.08) 0.138 (0.04)
SVM (AAC) 0.681 (0.12) 0.801 (0.00) 0.316 (0.12) 0.704 (0.13) 0.382 (0.06) 0.325 (0.01) 0.785 (0.03) 0.134 (0.05)
SVM (CKSAAP, binary) 0.711 (0.08) 0.800 (0.00) 0.293 (0.29) 0.728 (0.11) 0.445 (0.26) 0.256 (0.11) 0.799 (0.23) 0.146 (0.09)
SVM (CKSAAP, AAC) 0.543 (0.13) 0.802 (0.00) 0.456 (0.09) 0.667 (0.23) 0.376 (0.12) 0.356 (0.04) 0.800 (0.03) 0.154 (0.11)
SVM (binary, AAC) 0.567 (0.12) 0.801 (0.00) 0.432 (0.11) 0.684 (0.13) 0.382 (0.21) 0.324 (0.12) 0.803 (0.05) 0.169 (0.10)
SVM (CKSAAP, binary, AAC) 0.598 (0.08) 0.802 (0.00) 0.401 (0.13) 0.700 (0.12) 0.422 (0.09) 0.312 (0.02) 0.812 (0.07) 0.170 (0.08)
RF (CKSAAP) 0.798 (0.15) 0.800 (0.00) 0.201 (0.15) 0.749 (0.26) 0.500 (0.20) 0.251 (0.11) 0.803 (0.16) 0.145 (0.08)
RF (binary) 0.735 (0.09) 0.800 (0.00) 0.264 (0.09) 0.721 (0.14) 0.443 (0.01) 0.278 (0.02) 0.793 (0.13) 0.143 (0.06)
RF (AAC) 0.691 (0.15) 0.801 (0.00) 0.308 (0.15) 0.786 (0.26) 0.584 (0.20) 0.213 (0.11) 0.791 (0.16) 0.141 (0.08)
RF (CKSAAP, binary) 0.806 (0.02) 0.800 (0.00) 0.193 (0.01) 0.754 (0.02) 0.510 (0.06) 0.246 (0.10) 0.823 (0.03) 0.158 (0.02)
RF (CKSAAP, AAC) 0.681 (0.13) 0.800 (0.00) 0.319 (0.13) 0.659 (0.23) 0.502 (0.18) 0.182 (0.09) 0.797 (0.14) 0.151 (0.08)
RF (binary, AAC) 0.725 (0.09) 0.802 (0.00) 0.275 (0.09) 0.671 (0.14) 0.588 (0.01) 0.185 (0.02) 0.826 (0.13) 0.159 (0.06)
RF (CKSAAP, binary, AAC) 0.810 (0.02) 0.802 (0.00) 0.190 (0.01) 0.778 (0.02) 0.666 (0.06) 0.141 (0.10) 0.832 (0.03) 0.168 (0.02)

Better results with each of ADA, SVM and RF were highlighted by bold values.

The values within the first bracket indicate the standard error (SE).