Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 16;23:12. doi: 10.1186/s12910-022-00752-5

Table 2.

Experiences regarding end-of-life decision-making and implementation

Questions/statements Answers All Physicians Nurses Male Female
N % N % N % N % N %
Are DNACPR decisions made in your ICU? Frequently 81 18.5 52 38.0 29 9.6 31 30.7 48 14.5
Rarely 217 49.5 64 46.7 153 50.8 49 48.5 165 49.7
Never 84 19.2 14 10.2 70 23.3 12 11.9 72 21.7
Are decisions to withhold LST made in your ICU? Frequently 60 13.7 37 27.0 23 7.6 20 19.8 37 11.1
Rarely 213 48.6 83 60.6 130 43.2 52 51.5 160 48.2
Never 106 24.2 9 6.6 97 32.2 18 17.8 87 26.2
Are decisions to withdraw mechanical ventilation made in your ICU? Frequently 14 3.2 5 3.7 9 3.0 6 5.9 7 2.1
Rarely 120 27.4 36 26.3 84 27.9 25 24.8 92 27.7
Never 243 55.5 87 63.5 156 51.8 60 59.4 183 55.1
Are decisions to withdraw endotracheal tube made in your ICU? Frequently 22 5.0 2 1.5 20 6.6 3 3.0 19 5.7
Rarely 90 20.6 32 23.4 58 19.3 21 20.8 68 20.5
Never 267 61.0 95 69.3 172 57.1 67 66.3 197 59.3
Are decisions to withdraw inotropes made in your ICU? Frequently 98 22.4 52 38.0 46 15.3 34 33.7 60 18.1
Rarely 178 40.6 62 45.3 116 38.5 43 42.6 135 40.7
Never 105 24.0 14 10.2 91 30.2 16 15.8 89 26.8
Are decisions to withdraw antibiotics made in your ICU? Frequently 87 19.9 40 29.2 47 15.6 29 28.7 56 16.9
Rarely 151 34.5 56 40.9 95 31.6 37 36.6 113 34.0
Never 142 32.4 32 23.4 110 36.5 25 24.8 116 34.9
Are decisions to withdraw hydration made in your ICU? Frequently 16 3.7 3 2.2 13 4.3 5 5.0 11 3.3
Rarely 59 13.5 15 11.0 44 14.6 18 17.8 41 12.4
Never 302 69.0 109 79.6 193 64.1 67 66.3 231 69.6
Are DNACPR decisions made and noted in the patient's medical records? Yes. written 36 8.2 3 2.2 33 11.0 4 4.0 32 9.6
Yes. verbal 266 60.7 92 67.2 174 57.8 64 63.4 198 59.6
No 123 28.1 38 27.7 85 28.2 27 26.7 95 28.6
Are decisions to limit LST made and noted in the patient’s medical records? Yes. written 56 12.8 11 8.0 45 15.0 12 11.9 44 13.3
Yes. verbal 259 59.1 92 67.2 167 55.5 66 65.4 189 56.9
No 104 23.7 34 24.8 70 23.3 21 20.8 82 24.7
Do you respect DNACPR decisions? Always 295 67.4 93 67.9 202 67.1 78 77.2 213 64.2
Rarely 85 19.4 26 19.0 59 19.6 14 13.9 70 21.1
Never 33 7.5 8 5.8 25 8.3 4 4.0 29 8.7
Have you been included in LST limitation decision-making? Yes 128 29.2 98 71.5 30 10.0 48 47.5 80 24.1
No 287 65.5 31 22.6 256 85.1 51 50.5 231 69.6
LST limitation decision-making process includes ICU physicians and other physicians included in patient’s treatment Very true 142 32.4 77 56.2 65 21.6 38 37.6 102 30.7
True 131 29.9 46 33.6 85 28.2 38 37.6 92 27.7
I cannot decide 41 9.4 5 3.7 36 12.0 6 5.9 35 10.5
Not true 22 5.0 4 2.9 18 6.0 4 4.0 18 5.4
Not true at all 61 13.9 3 2.2 58 19.3 10 9.9 50 15.1
LST limitation decision-making process includes ICU physicians and nurses Very true 43 9.8 18 13.1 25 8.3 14 13.9 29 8.7
True 60 13.7 21 15.3 39 13.0 18 17.8 42 12.7
I cannot decide 70 16.0 16 11.7 54 17.9 14 13.9 55 16.6
Not true 81 18.5 32 23.4 49 16.3 19 18.8 62 18.7
Not true at all 119 27.2 35 25.6 84 27.9 28 27.7 88 26.5
Who initiates LST limitation discussion? Physicians 292 66.7 106 77.4 186 61.8 69 68.3 220 66.3
Nurses 11 2.5 2 1.5 9 3.0 4 4.0 7 2.1
Family/legal guardians 21 4.8 5 3.7 16 5.3 2 2.0 19 5.7
Family members/legal guardians are included in LST limitation decision-making Very true 90 20.6 17 12.4 73 24.3 16 15.8 74 22.3
True 125 28.5 38 27.7 87 28.9 27 26.7 94 28.3
Not true 127 29.0 51 37.2 76 25.3 37 36.6 90 27.1
Not true at all 74 16.9 27 19.7 47 15.6 18 17.8 55 16.6

ICU Intensive care unit; LST Life-sustaining treatment; DNACPR Do-not-attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation