Table 1. Summary of 17 currently existing muscle classification models, divided between systems based on clinical and imaging findings, systems based on image evaluation, and systems based on clinical presentation 11 .
1. Classifications based on clinical and imaging findings | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author | Description | ||||||
Lopes, A. 1993. |
Classification based on etiology and ultrasound findings
Type I: muscle injury caused by extrinsic factors: muscle contusion Type II: muscle injury caused by intrinsic factors without muscle rupture Type III: muscle injury caused by intrinsic factors with muscle rupture |
||||||
Verrall, J. 2003. | Clinical parameters | Image findings - MRI Classification of the lesion | |||||
Beginning | Insidious | Abrupt | |||||
Circumstance | Playing | Training | Positive | Negative | |||
Pain | (0–10) visual analog scale | ||||||
Malliaropoulos, N. 2010. | Clinical Grade - ROM Deficit | Image findings (US) | |||||
I | < 10 th | Degree 0 to 3 (based on Peetrons) |
Injury area: | ||||
II | 10 th –19 th | < 25% | |||||
III | 20 th –29 th | 25–50% | |||||
IV | > 30 th | > 50% | |||||
Pollock, N. 15 (British athletics muscle injury classification) | Degree of injury | Description | MRI | ||||
Grade 0: referred pain | |||||||
0a | Local pain | Normal | |||||
0b | Generalized muscle pain | normal or with signs of delayed pain | |||||
Grade 1: small muscle injuries (< 5 cm or < 10% of total muscle area) | |||||||
1a | Fascial pain | Intermuscular fluid | |||||
1b | Muscle or JMT pain | Intermuscular fluid | |||||
Grade 2: moderate muscle injuries (5–15 cm or 10–50% of total muscle area) | |||||||
2a | Fascial pain | high perspherical signal | |||||
2b | Muscle or JMT pain | high signal in JMT | |||||
2c | Tendon pain | high sign on tendon | |||||
Grade 3: extensive muscle injuries (> 15 cm or > 50% of total muscle area) | |||||||
3a | Fascial pain | high perspherical signal | |||||
3b | Muscle or JMT pain | high signal in JMT | |||||
3c | Tendon pain | high sign on tendon | |||||
Grade 4: complete muscle injuries | |||||||
4a | Fascial pain | high perspherical signal | |||||
4b | Muscle or JMT pain | high signal in JMT | |||||
4c | Tendon pain | high sign on tendon | |||||
Mueller-Wohlfahrt, H. 8 (The Munich consensus statment) | A. Indirect muscle injury | ||||||
Functional muscle injury
Type 1: Overload-related muscle disorder Type 1A: Fatigue-induced muscle disorder Type 1B: Late-onset muscle pain (DMIT) Type 2: Neuromuscular disorder Type 2A: Related to the spine Type 2B: Related to muscles | |||||||
Structural muscle injury
Type 3: Partial muscle injury Type 3A: Minimal partial muscle injury Type 3B: Moderate partial muscle injury Type 4: Injury (sub)total Subtotal or complete muscle injury Tendinous avulsion | |||||||
B. Direct muscle injury
Bruise Laceration | |||||||
Maffulli, N. 16 |
- Direct muscle injury
Bruise Laceration |
||||||
- Indirect muscle injury
Nonstructural muscle injury Type 1: Fatigue muscle injury Type 1A: Fatigue-induced muscle disorder Type 1B: Late-onset muscle pain (DMIT) Type 2: Neuromuscular disorder Type 2A: Related to the spine Type 2B: Related to muscles | |||||||
- Indirect muscle injury
Structural muscle injury Type 3: Partial muscle injury Type 3A: Minimal partial muscle injury Type 3B: Moderate partial muscle injury (< 50%) Type 4: Injury (sub)total Subtotal or complete muscle injury Tendinous avulsion Structural lesions can be proximal (P), middle (M), and distal (D) | |||||||
Valle, X. 7 | Clinical findings | ||||||
Injury mechanism (M) | Location of the lesion (L) | Degree of injury (G) | Rescan number (R) | ||||
T - Direct lesion of the hamstrings | P Lesion located in the proximal third of the muscle belly M Lesion located in the middle third of the muscular belly D Lesion located in the third of the muscular belly |
0–3 |
0: 1
st
episode
1 s t reinjury 2: 2 nd reinjury |
||||
I - Indirect injury of the hamstrings, plus index s if it is by stretching (stretching), or index p if it is run. | P Lesion located in the proximal third of the muscle belly. The second letter is index p or d, describing whether the lesion is proximal or distal to JMT, respectively M Lesion located in the middle third of the muscle belly, plus the corresponding index D Lesion located in the middle third of the muscle belly, plus the corresponding index |
0–3 | |||||
N - Negative MRI injury | N p Lesion in the proximal third N m Injury in the middle third N d Lesion in the distal third |
0–3 | |||||
Magnetic resonance findings | |||||||
Grade 0 | Negative MRI | ||||||
Grade 1 | Hyperintense muscle fiber edema without intramuscular hemorrhage or change in architecture | ||||||
Grade 2 | Hyperintense edema of muscle fiber and/or paratendon with minimal intramuscular hemorrhage without gaps or minimal alteration in muscle architecture. | ||||||
Grade 3 | Any gap between muscle fibers in the craniocaudal or axial plane. Hyperintense focal defect with partial retraction of muscle fibers ± intermuscular hemorrhage. | ||||||
(r) code overwrite | Used when there is intratendinous injury or affecting JMT or intramuscular injury with retraction or loss of normal tension. | ||||||
2. Classifications based on image findings | |||||||
Pomeranz, S. 1993. | MRI assessment | ||||||
Muscle group involved | Injury area | Location | Superficial Involvement | ||||
Semimembranosus | < 50% | Tendineous | Yes | ||||
Semitendinosus | > 50% | JMT | No | ||||
Femoris biceps | Total | ||||||
Femoris square | |||||||
Takebayashi, S. 12 | US findings | ||||||
Type 1 | Normal | ||||||
Type 2 | Hyperecoic infiltration | ||||||
Type 3 | Mass | ||||||
Type 4 | Complete lesion (Infiltration + mass) | ||||||
Peetrons, P. 13 | US findings | ||||||
Grade 0 | Normal | ||||||
Grade 1 | Hyperecoic area, < 15 mm on the longest axis; < 5% of muscle. | ||||||
Grade 2 | 5–50% of muscle. Partial muscle rupture. | ||||||
Grade 3 | Complete muscle or fascia injury, with collection extravasation from the injured muscle. | ||||||
Slavotinek, J. 2002. | MRI image of hamstring injury | ||||||
Affected muscle | Location | Total area of the lesion | |||||
Femoris biceps | Proximal to short biceps head | 0–100% | |||||
Semitendinosus | Distal to short biceps head | ||||||
Semimembranosus | |||||||
Bordalo-Rodrigues, M. 2005 | MRI image of Proximal Rectus Femoris - anatomical location | ||||||
Avulsion injury of the apophysis Musculotendinous junction injury (JMT) Muscle contusion and laceration | |||||||
Cohen, S. 2011. | MRI-based graduation system | ||||||
Item | Description | 0 points | 1 point | 2 points | 3 points | ||
1 | N° of muscles involved | No | 1 | 2 | 3 | ||
2 | Location | − | Proximal | Middle | Distal | ||
3 | Insertion | No | − | Yes | − | ||
4 | Total area of injury in % of the muscle involved | 0% | 25% | 50% | ≥ 75% | ||
5 | Retraction | No | − | > 2 cm | − | ||
6 | Longitudinal axis involvement | 0 cm | 1–5 cm | 6–10 cm | > 10 cm | ||
Chan, O. 2012 | Graduation based on imaging findings and lesion site | ||||||
Degree | MRI | US | Local | ||||
I (distension) | < 5% fiber rupture; | Normal; without distortion of architecture | . Proximal to JMT | ||||
II (Partial loom) | < 5% fiber rupture; high intramuscular signal; edema and bleeding of the muscle or JMT extending to the fascial planes between the muscle groups | Discontinuity of muscle fibers | Muscle A. Proximal B. Medium C. Distal |
||||
III (Complete loom) | Complete discontinuity of muscle fibers, hematoma, and muscle retraction | Comparable with MRI | Distal to JMT | ||||
Corazza, A. 2013. | Combined US-MRI assessment | ||||||
Degree | MRI | US | |||||
0 | No pathological findings | No pathological findings | |||||
I | Muscle edema without tissue alteration | Altered echotexture at the site of pain, without rupture | |||||
Ii | Partial muscle injury | Lesion with associated hematoma | |||||
Iii | Complete muscle injury | Complete muscle injury | |||||
3. Classifications based on clinical findings | |||||||
Bass, A. 1969. | Classifies muscle injuries by etiology and location | ||||||
Type | Etiology | Location | |||||
I | Direct external contact | Intramuscular | |||||
Ii | Twitch | Intermuscular | |||||
Wise, D. 1977 | Classification based on cause, severity, and location of leg muscle injury | ||||||
Indirect lesions - inflammation | |||||||
Direct injuries - trauma | |||||||
Degree | Pain | Circumference difference | Arc of motion | During contraction | |||
Pain | Loss of strength | Function disorder | |||||
I | Minimum; | < 6 mm | 100% | Minimum | No | Moderate | |
Ii | Substantial | 6–12 mm | 50% | Middle | Middle | Important | |
Iii | Intractable | > 12 mm | <5 0% | Serious | almost total | Don't step |
Abbreviations: JMT, myotendinous junction; MRI, magnectic resonance imaging; US, ultrasound.