Table 1.
Author/year | Setting/population | Purpose of intervention | Type of intervention | Intervention in control group | Method/time | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vallance et al. (2019)[7] | Alberta/Canada | Physical activity, fatigue and QoL* | Wearable device (Actigraph® and activPALTM accelerometers**) | Non | RCT***/4 M**** | The fatigue profile was improved. But effect not seen in QoL. |
Lynch et al. (2019)[8] | Australia | Physical activity (PA) | Wearable technology*****, telephone counseling | Non | RCT/12W****** | Increase of PA******* was proved. |
Kokts-Porietis et al. (2019)[9] | Canada | PA | Wearable technology (Polar A360® activity tracker********) | traditional treatment and rehabilitation according to daily specifications of the hospital | RCT, interview/12W | Technology was as a facilitator to physical activity, but technologic difficulties created a barrier to physical activity adherence. |
Nápoles et al. (2019)[10] | United States | PA, health behavior | Booklet- Spanish-language mobile phone app - activity tracker- telephone counseling | Non | Sampling/2M | The PA and health behaviors of participants increased significantly. |
Dong et al. (2019)[11] | China | PA | Phone, social media apps, tele-video | Traditional treatment and rehabilitation according to daily specifications of the hospital | RCT/12W | Positive effect on quality of life, muscle strength and cardiorespiratory capacity. |
Pope et al. (2018)[12] | Minneapolis, USA | PA | Facebook- and mobile app (MapMyFitness) | RCT/10 W | Increasing physical activity by Facebook, Impact of the smart watch was not proven (due to difficulty). | |
Lozano-Lozano et al. (2018)[13] | Spain | Diet and PA, body composition, muscular strength, upper body functionality and physical fitness | mHealth (BENECA)- tri-axial accelerometer | BENECA app for 8 weeks and usual care information | RCT/1M | It can be effective tool for managing breast cancer patient’s diet and PA behaviors. |
Anderson et al. (2018)[14] | Scotland | PA, diet behavior and weight loss. | Telephone counseling and web support | Usual care | RCT/12W | Desired results were obtained from the intervention. |
Lee et al. (2018)[15] | South Korea | Exercise | Mobile application | - | Retrospective/12W | Scores of patients with intervention were significantly higher than patients without intervention.Mutual feedback will increase user loyalty and motivational technology. |
Van de Wiel et al. (2018)[16] | Netherlands | Physiotherapy counseling | Internet-based Physical Activity Support program (IPAS) and Telephone Support (TS) | Non | RCT/6 & 12 M | The effectiveness on IPAS********* alone or with TS********** in improvement of PA, QoL and fatigue was proved. |
Hayes et al. (2011)[17] | Queensland/Australia | Exercise (aerobic) and PA | Telephone counseling | Usual care | RCT/8 M | The intervention had positive effect on survival. |
Uhm et al. (2017)[18] | South Korea | Exercise (Aerobic and resistance exercises), physical function, and Quality of Life (QoL) | mHealth app (Smart After Care) with In Body Band Pedometer*********** | - | Prospective, quasi-randomized multicenter trial/6 &12W | Improve physical function, physical activity and QoL. |
Lahart et al. (2017)[19] | United Kingdom | Cardiorespiratory fitness | Telephone | Usual care | RCT/6M | Increased cardiorespiratory fitness and self-reported PA. |
Hartman et al. (2017)[20] | San Diego/USA | Exercise | Telephone and emails | Usual care | RCT/12W | The intervention improved the physical activity |
Krebs et al. (2017)[21] | United States | PA and Healthy Eating | DVD************ | Advice and counseling alone | RCT/12W | Greater improvement in eating behavior change than physical activity. |
Valle et al. (2017)[22] | United States | PA, weight loss | Wireless scale with data transfer capability to Website/mobile app | Usual care | RCT/24W | Preventing of weight gain was positive in both groups. |
Cox et al. (2017)[23] | USA | PA and weight loss | Internet or telephone | Internet | RCT/6M | The outcomes of intervention in telephone group were better than internet group. |
Lawler et al. (2017)[24] | Queensland/Australia | PA, diet and weight loss | Telephone | ---- | Pre-post study/6M | Positive effect on PA and weight loss of participants. |
Harder et al. (2017)[25] | United Kingdom | Arm and shoulder exercises | Mobile app | ----- | Focus group | Self-management of arm and shoulder exercises was proved. |
Fazzino et al. (2017)[26] | United States | Weight management and PA | Group phone sessionsmailed newsletterspedometer | ------ | RCT/6M | The PA of participants improved |
Ritvo et al. (2017)[27] | Canada | PA | Telephone, Smart phone (iMovie), wearable technology | Only 12-week physical activity program | RCT/12W | Will assess |
Ollero et al. (2017)[28] | - | Monitor heart rate, energy expenditure, arm mobility | Smart watch, smart phone, web server application | - | System design | The patients have not been evaluated. Only software and application were evaluated. |
Ariza-Garcia et al. (2019)[29] | Spain | Exercise | Web-based (e-CUIDATE system) | Usual care | RCT/6-8 M | Global health status, physical, role, cognitive functioning, and arm symptoms, pain severity, and pain interference was improved. |
Reeves et al. (2016) Australia[30] | The University of Queensland | Weight loss | Telephone counseling, posted materials and text-message | Usual care | RCT/6 &12 & 18 | The intervention had positive effect on PA, weight loss and other examined criteria. |
Quintiliani et al. (2016)[31] | United States | Weight, diet and physical activity. | Text message- pedometer- phone counseling | Usual care | Pre-post study/10W | Weight of participants decreased. Dietary behavior improved. PA increased |
Cadmus-Bertram et al. (2016)[32] | United States | PA | Telephone and web-based self-monitoring tools. | Usual care | RCT/12M | The PA and weight condition of participants improved significantly |
Harrigan et al. (2016)[33] | United States | Weight loss | Telephone and in-person counseling. | Usual care | RCT/3M | The both interventions led to significant weight loss via increasing PA and favorable diet changes |
Lyons et al. (2016)[34] | United States | Fitness and physical activity | Mobile application | Mobile application + narrative-based active video game. | RCT/6M | Improve breast cancer survivors’ health |
Forbes et al. (2015)[35] | Nova Scotia/Canada | PA | PA tracking website UWALK | Usual care | RCT/9W | Intervention was successful in changing PA behavior. |
McCarroll et al. (2015)[36] | United States | Control overweight. | Mobile app (LoseIt!) in website and mobile versions. | Usual care | Prospective/1M | The patients PA increased significantly. |
Kyung Lee et al. (2014)[37] | South Korea | Promoting exercise (aerobic), dietary behaviors, and self-efficacy. | Web-based Self-Management Exercise and diet Intervention (WSEDI) | Booklet on exercise and diet | RCT/12W | Better results in the intervention group |
De Cocker et al. (2014)[38] | Belgium | PA | Web and pedometer-based PA advice program | - | Pilot/3W | The usability and acceptability of program for PA proved. |
Short et al. (2017)[39] | Queensland/Australia | PA | Website | - | RCT/12W | Positive effect on increasing PA in breast cancer survivors. |
Winger et al. (2014)[40] | United States | Exercise and diet. | Telephone and mailed print | Non | RCT/-1Y************* | more positive results of the telephone intervention |
Rock et al. (2013, 2015)[41,42] | United States | Effect of intervention on weight loss. | Telephone counseling and tailored newsletters | Usual care | RCT/2Y | The intervention group had significantly weight loss comparing with control group. |
Hatchett et al. (2012)[43] | The University of Mississippi/USA | PA | Usual care | RCT/6 and 12M | Increased physical activity and exercise behavior. | |
Ligibel et al. (2012)[44] | United States | Exercise | Telephone | Usual care | RCT/16M | Increase PA, physical functioning, and fitness. |
Demark-Wahnefried et al. (2012)[45] | United States | Diet-exercise to control overweight or obese | Telephone counseling and print materials. | Wait-list control | RCT/2Y | Diet quality, PA, Physical function and BMI were improved significantly. |
Eakin et al. (2012)[46] | Australia, Queensland | Aerobic and resistance exercise | Telephone | Non | RCT/8Y | Improve the physical activity and fitness |
Lee et al. (2011)[47] | South Korea | PA and diet behaviors | Telephone and workbook | Non | RCT/12W | The PA increased significantly. Diet behaviors and QOL was improved. |
Hegel et al. (2011)[48] | Hanover, USA | Quality of Life | Telephone | Usual care | RCT/6 and 12 W | Increase quality of life, Increase emotional state |
Morey et al. (2009)[49] | United States | PA and diet | Telephone counseling, Automated telephone messages and mailed materials. | Delayed intervention | RCT/4M | PA and health behavior increased significantly in intervention group |
Pinto et al. (2015)[50] | United States | PA | Telephone | Usual care | RCT/12 W | Increased physical activity, improved fitness and some aspects of psychological well-being |
Matthews et al. (2007)[51] | United States | PA behaviors, body weight and body composition | Telephone | Usual care | RCT/12W | The level of PA increased in intervention group. No significant change in body weight. |
Vallance et al. (2007)[52] | Alberta/Canada | PA and QoL | Wearable device and Print Materials | Print materials | RCT/7 M | Effectiveness of each intervention alone proved. Also, the combined approach produces better results. |
QoL*: Quality of Life. Accelerometers**: Device that measures proper acceleration (the rate of change of velocity). RCT***: Randomized Controlled Trial. M****: Month. wearable technology*****: The electronic device that can be embedded in user’s body or clothes. W******: Week. PA*******: Physical Activity. Activity tracker********: Device such as smart watches that monitoring fitness related indicators. IPAS*********: Internet-based Physical Activity Support Program. TS**********: Telephone Support. Pedometer***********: Electronic device that counts steps of a person by detecting the motion of the person’s hands or hips. It measures and encourage physical activity in adults. DVD************: Digital Video Disk. Y*************: Year