Skip to main content
NIHPA Author Manuscripts logoLink to NIHPA Author Manuscripts
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Feb 24.
Published in final edited form as: J Adolesc Health. 2021 Apr 10;69(4):664–667. doi: 10.1016/j.jadohealth.2021.03.003

“If It Needs to be Done, It Needs to be Done”: National Survey of Youth Experiences and Perspectives on Caregiving

Minakshi Raj a,*, Sara J Feldman b, Jodyn E Platt c, Tammy Chang d,e
PMCID: PMC8867996  NIHMSID: NIHMS1779865  PMID: 33846056

Abstract

Purpose:

The purpose of this study was to explore youth experiences and perspectives on family caregiving to improve programs and policies that impact the well-being of youth.

Methods:

In August 2020, we asked three open-ended questions about current and anticipated caregiving responsibilities, impact, and needs using MyVoice, a national text message poll of youth. Content and thematic analysis was conducted to evaluate qualitative responses.

Results:

In our sample (n = 1,076), 35% of respondents reported previously or currently providing care for an adult relative either independently or by helping another relative. Participants believed caregiving had or would hinder their educational or career goals and that specific training would better prepare them to be a caregiver.

Conclusions:

The prevalence of youth caregiving may be higher than previous estimates. Healthcare professionals should evaluate youth for caregiving responsibilities and support them in identifying resources or interventions to reduce potential impacts of caregiving burden on health outcomes.

Keywords: Youth, Family caregivers, Social support


An estimated 1.3 million youth and young people (ages 8–18 years) support relatives who have chronic health conditions, are disabled, and/or are aging. [1,2] Caregiver stress and burden due to family caregiving is well documented and is associated with negative physical and psychosocial health outcomes including depression, anxiety, and other chronic health conditions, as well as workplace impacts and social isolation. [3-5] However, studies on caregiver experiences have largely focused on adults resulting in a limited understanding of the caregiving experiences of youth.

Healthcare systems and other youth-serving institutions represent important sources of support for youth who are caregiving. However, caregiver burden is often not addressed by healthcare providers, especially those caring for youth. [1,5] Furthermore, the prevalence of youth caregiving has likely increased further during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. [6] The impacts of caregiving are likely compounded by additional stressors youth are facing because of the pandemic including the disruption of social, educational, and/or professional activities [7-11].

Given the considerable impact of caregiving on psychosocial and physical health, education, employment, and financial outcomes, the purpose of this study is to explore youth experiences and perspectives on family caregiving to improve programs and policies that impact the well-being of youth [12-15].

Methods

Participants and procedures

MyVoice is a national open-ended text message poll of youth and young adults aged 14–24 years. The MyVoice panel includes 1,174 participants who were recruited online using social media advertising to meet national benchmarks based on weighted samples of the American Community Survey, including age, race/ethnicity, gender, socioeconomic status, and region of the country [16]. The panel recruits youth beginning at age 14 years to ensure equitable and diverse recruitment of high-school and college-age youth because cell phone access is nearly ubiquitous at this age. Once enrolled, participants are sent weekly surveys with 3–5 questions on salient health and health policy topics that impact youth. This study was approved by the University of Michigan Institutional Review Board with a waiver of parental consent for minor participants to enable equitable enrollment of at-risk youth and was fielded in August 2020.

Measures

Along with demographic information collected at enrollment, open-ended questions were developed through an iterative process with survey experts, mixed-methods experts, youth, and members of the study team who are experts in the area of caregiving. Questions included the following: (1) This week is about family caregiving (taking care of an adult relative). Have you ever had to do that?; (2) How do you think taking care of an adult relative would impact your educational or career goals?; and (3) What would help you prepare to take care of an adult relative in the future?

Analysis

We summarized demographic characteristics (age, gender, race/ethnicity, education, and region) for the full sample. Qualitative responses were analyzed using content and thematic analysis. The study team iteratively developed a codebook by inductively identifying patterns and themes in responses. Two investigators independently coded all responses and discussed and resolved discrepancies. Responses that were unrelated to the question were excluded from coding. Frequencies of major themes within each question were summarized.

Results

Of 1,174 MyVoice panel participants 1,076 responded to the survey (91.7% response rate).

Demographic characteristics of respondents are summarized in Table 1. Table 2 summarizes major themes and representative quotes for each question. More than one-third (35%) of respondents reported previously or currently providing care for an adult relative (e.g., parent, grandparent) either independently or by helping another relative. Youth who specified caregiving circumstances described supporting an adult relative with a chronic condition (e.g., dementia, disabilities, cancer) and acute illnesses (e.g., COVID-19, flu, postoperative care). For example, 1 participant described: “My mom developed dementia and had to come stay with me so I can care for her.” Another explained, “My dad had to get some cancerous chunks of skin removed and needed help applying antibiotic ointment afterwards.”

Table 1.

Sample demographics and characteristics (n = 1,076)

n (%) or mean (SD)
Age, mean 18.87 (2.66)
 14–18 566 (52.8)
 19–24 504 (47.2)
Gender 496 (46.1)
 Female 486 (45.2)
Male 35 (3.3)
 Nonbinary 49 (4.7)
 Transgender 8 (.7)
Race/Ethnicity
 White/Caucasian, NH 613 (57.3)
 Black/African American, NH 93 (8.7)
 Asian, NH 144 (13.5)
 2 + Races, NH 66 (6.2)
 Other, NH 11 (1.0)
 Hispanic 142 (13.3)
Highest educational attainment
 Some high school or lessa 442 (41.5)
 High school graduate 159 (14.9)
 Some college/vocational training/associate degree 341 (32.0)
 Bachelor’s degree or higher 124 (11.6)
Region of U.S.
 West 227 (21.1)
 Midwest 352 (32.7)
 South 313 (29.1)
 Northeast 177 (16.5)
Qualification for free/reduced lunch
 Yes 406 (38.2)

N = 1030 – N = 1076 owing to missing values.

NH = non-Hispanic; U.S. = United States.

a

Includes currently in high school.

Table 2.

Themes and representative quotes from youth aged 14–24 years

Frequency
(percentage)
reporting theme
Representative quotes
1. Have you ever had to take care of an adult relative? (n = 1066 complete responses)
 Yes 373 (35.0) “My father has pulmonary hypertension so I’ve had to look after him in the past” (19 years, male, white or Caucasian)
“I currently take care of my grandma… I moved in to help her” (21 years, female, white/Caucasian)
“Not independently, but my grandparents did live with us when I was young and became more dependent as I got older” (22 years, female, Asian)
“Yeah. There have been several times that I have watched my grandmother with Alzheimer’s by myself or with one of my sisters for multiple days in a row.” (17 years, female, American Indian or Alaska Native, white or Caucasian)
2. How do you think taking care of an adult relative would impact your educational or career goals?a,b (n = 909 complete responses)
Hinder 692 (76.2) “I think would definitely make it harder to balance achieving educational goals and having a social life” (19 years, female, black or African American)
 Help 80 (8.8) “I think it would teach me sympathy and compassion which may help in my field of work” (18 years, male, Asian)
 No impact 111 (12.2) “It would not. I’d take online classes” (20 years, transgender, white or Caucasian)
 Would do/have done it anyway 78 (8.6) “It’s possible it would get in the way but I feel that it’s a way to repay someone for all they have given you when they took care of you” (16 years, male, white or Caucasian)
3. What would help you better prepare to take care of an adult relative in the future?a,b (n = 906 complete responses)
Training 388 (42.8) “Some helpful articles of what to expect and advice from medical professionals on things to learn before taking on such tasks.” (21 years, male, Asian)
 Financial support 249 (27.5) “Having enough money to hire a trained caregiver” (19 years, male, Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander)
 Social support 108 (11.9) “Having others around so it would be a shared responsibility- but also the adult would have more people around them showing them love” (18 years, female, white or Caucasian)
 Advance care planning 82 (9.1) “Having that conversation about what they want now before they really require care” (23 years, female, white or Caucasian)
 Time and space 73 (8.1) “I would make sure I have my time planned out and the balance between school and care equal or whatever it needs to be so both stay on track.” (15 years, male, white or Caucasian)
 Workplace policies 53 (5.9) “Making sure they have a safe environment to live in” (18, female, white or Caucasian) “Financial support or leniency from an employer to take care of an adult relative would be really helpful” (17 years, female, Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander, white or Caucasian)
Mental health 28 (3.1) “I wish I would’ve known the emotional bank it takes to put energy into both yourself and another human being. I was not prepared to drain myself for her but that’s exactly what I did. If there was a way I could prepare myself for the imbalance I would’ve taken it.” (18 years, female, black or African American)
a

Category percentages may add to more than 100% because responses could reflect multiple themes.

b

Only major themes are presented.

Most respondents (72%), and especially those aged 19–24 years, reported that caregiving would hinder their educational or career goals. One respondent who had been a caregiver explained, “I had to travel home from college to help my mother. It made attending class impossible for a month… I was behind in school, and could not go to work… It can completely alter someone’s life trajectory.” Another respondent anticipated, “It could be time consuming and take away from your school work/career work, and it could completely put you in a position where you have to choose between your family and your education/career.” Nearly one-tenth (8.6%) of respondents said they would provide care regardless of any personal impact. As one participant described, “While it may impact those goals, taking care of parents should be the priority.” Youth reported that training in specific skills (42.8%; e.g., medication administration), financial resources (27.5%), and social support (11.9%) would better prepare them for caregiving.

Discussion

More than one-third of respondents reported caregiving for adult relatives, including those with COVID-19. Most described caregiving as a stressful responsibility that had already, or would, hinder their educational or career goals. Yet, similar to many adult caregivers who neglect their own health and needs to provide care, respondents in this study reported they would support adult relatives regardless of negative personal impact [5]. To prepare for future caregiving, respondents reported needing training from healthcare professionals, financial resources, and social support, which have been suggested as critical resources for adult caregivers [17].

The prevalence of youth caregiving is much higher in our large diverse national sample than that of previous estimates, potentially owing to the COVID-19 pandemic [1]. Prior research has referred to youth as emerging adults, protected from responsibilities and adult commitments as they explore their future [18]. However, this study suggests that youth who are caregiving—and even those who are not caregiving—perceive challenges associated with caregiving and anticipate a need for resources to support them in the future. Healthcare institutions and professionals should recognize caregiving as a responsibility that many youth already manage either independently or by supporting other relatives or expect to manage in the future.

Clinicians should screen youth and young adults during healthcare visits for caregiving responsibilities and evaluate caregiver stress and burden. Given the likelihood that youth are supporting an adult relative who may be infected with COVID-19 or with other needs during the COVID-19 pandemic, it may be especially timely to begin assessing youth for caregiving responsibilities [8,19]. Policy makers and clinicians should also evaluate the potential implications of caregiving such as delayed educational and career goals. Youth-serving professionals such as healthcare providers and educators can engage young people in discussions about the potential downstream impacts of these delays to prevent negative outcomes and can link youth to interventions and supportive resources [20]. Future research should explore what caregiving means to youth and how youth’ descriptions of caregiving may extend current conceptualizations of what it means to be a caregiver. In addition, future research should identify interventions and resources that can support youth and mitigate the negative physical, mental, and psychosocial impacts of caregiving to which youth may be particularly susceptible. It is critical to ensure that practices optimally support the health and well-being of youth who may care for an adult relative now and in the future.

IMPLICATIONS AND CONTRIBUTION.

Little is known about youth experiences and perspectives on caregiving. These findings suggest a higher prevalence of youth caregiving than previous estimates and draw on youth perspectives to identify needs and impacts of caregiving on youth health and well-being.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank the MyVoice team for their assistance with developing questions and data collection.

Funding Sources

This work was supported by the Department of Kinesiology and Community Health at the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign (MR), the Michigan Institute for Clinical & Health Research and the University of Michigan Department of Family Medicine (TC), and a predoctoral fellowship from the National Human Genome Research Institute (T32 HG010030) (SJF).

Footnotes

Conflicts of Interest: The authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose.

Sponsor role: The study sponsors had no role in any part of the study design, collection, analysis or interpretation of data, writing, or in the decision to submit the manuscript. The authors wrote the manuscript.

References

RESOURCES