Skip to main content
. 2022 Jan 25;12(2):309. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics12020309

Table 1.

The main characteristics of the included studies in the meta-analysis.

No. crt. Author Study Design Comparison No. of Patients (Overall Data) No. of Images (Overall Data) Testing Data Final Diagnosis Analysis Target Type of Computer-Aided Diagnosis (CAD) Algorithm of AI
1 Kuwahara 2019 retrospective benign IPMN vs malignant IPMN 50 3970 no separate testing data 27 benign IPMN/23 malignant IPMN B-mode images deep learning-based CAD CNN
2 Das 2008 retrospective normal pancreas vs. chronic pancreatitis (CP) vs PDAC 56 319 50% of all data 2 normal pancreas/12 CP/22 PDAC Texture features from B-mode image conventional CAD ANN
3 Marya 2020 retrospective autoimmune pancreatitis vs. normal pancreas vs. CP vs. PDAC 583 1,174,461 123 patients 146 AIP/292 PDAC/72 CP/73NP B-mode images conventional CAD CNN
4 Norton 2001 retrospective CP vs PDAC 35 N/A N/A 14 CP/21 PDAC Grey-scale pixels from B-mode image conventional CAD Basic Neuronal Network/Machine Learning
5 Ozkan 2015 retrospective PDAC vs. normal pancreas 172 332 72 (42 PDAC, 30 normal pancreas) 202 PDAC/130 normal pancreas (images) Digital features from B-mode image conventional CAD ANN
6 Saftoiu 2015 Prospective CP vs. PDAC 167 15% of pts 112 PDAC/55 CP TIC parameters from contrast-enhanced EUS conventional CAD ANN
7 Tonozuka 2021 Prospective normal pancreas vs. CP vs. PDAC 139 1390 47 pts, 470 images (25 PDAC, 12 CP, 10 NP) 76 PDAC/34 CP/29 normal pancreas B-mode images deep learning-based CAD CNN
8 Udristoiu 2021 Retrospective CP vs. PDAC vs. NET 65 3360 672 images from 65 pts 30 PDAC 20 CP/15 NET Multi parametric (B-mode, contrast, elastography) deep learning-based CAD CNN
9 Zhang 2010 Retrospective CP vs. PDAC vs. normal pancreas 216 50% of all data 153 PDAC/20 normal pancreas/43 CP Texture features from B-mode image conventional CAD SVM
10 Zhu 2013 Retrospective CP vs. PDAC 388 50% of all data (194; 131 PDAC, 63 CP) 262 PDAC/126 CP Texture features from B-mode image conventional CAD SVM