Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 9;14(2):382. doi: 10.3390/pharmaceutics14020382

Table 4.

The selected examples of studied fluorinated and PFC nanosystems explaining their preparation technique, fluorine component, characterisation techniques used for studying various aspects of the nanosystems, pros and cons based on the synthesis/preparation and the practicality, and applications. * The abbreviations are expanded at the ‘Abbreviation’ session.

Type Name Preparation Technique Fluorine Component Characterisation * Pros and Cons Application Ref
POLYMERIC Fluorous colloidal NPs Copolymer by ATRP. NPs formation by self-assembly to micelle Trifluoroethyl methacrylate DLS (260 nm), TEM, FMRI, FC, CM, UV-Vis, CyA–on macrophage cells, animal studies–female athymic NCR nude mice for breast cancer Simple preparation of copolymer Immune cell tracking and systemic disease monitoring [187]
No surfactant
Little off target accumulation
Tumour-homing
Poly(OEGA-co-TFEA)-b-poly(St-co-VBA) Polymerisation by RAFT and NPs by PISA 2,2,2-trifluoroethyl acrylate FMRI and NMR, DLS, TEM, CM Little or no cytotoxicity–Chinese Hamster Ovarian cells In vivo cell tracking [190]
Multiple NPs morphologies by controlling reaction time and polymer chain length in one preparation (spherical, worm, vesicle)
ROS-responsive fluorinated polymers Polymer by ATRP and NPs by self-assembly 2,2,2-trifluoroethyl methacrylate H and F NMR, FMRI, DLS (62, 32 and 18 nm), UV-Vis Enhanced sensitivity for acidic microenvironment and the presence of ROS ROS/pH dual-responsive 19F MRI agent [191]
The concentration of H2O2 studied (~1 M) were higher than biological levels (50–100 μM)
6-step synthesis that requires purification
“OFF–ON” regulation of NPs to acidic environment
Amino activable nanoprobe- p(mPEGMA)-co-poly(AMA-DNBS-F) (PEDF nanoprobe) Copolymers by RAFT polymerisation and nanoprobe by nanoprecipitation Trifluoromethyl-containing segments H and F NMR, DLS (33 nm), FMRI, TEM, FTIR, CLSM, in vivo imaging in tumours–xenograft tumour models in mice 2 step preparations for monomers In vivo bio-thiols imaging [192]
Highly sensitive to bio-thiols
Water soluble
Fluorinated block copolymers NPs RAFT for the block polymers and NPs by self-assembly in aqueous solution 2,2,2-trifluoroethylamide L-arginine methacrylamide H, F- NMR, DLS (25 to 60 nm), TEM Fluorinated functionalities in the hydrophilic shell MRI Imaging [300]
Increased T2
19F MRI-detectable drug delivery system Layer-by-layer technique deposition of polyelectrolyte shells on nanoemulsion drops Polyelectrolyte Nafion–fluorinated anionic polymer DLS (170 nm), LDV, NTA, C-SEM, QCM, FMRI Sufficient SNR ratio Passive tumour targeting and drug delivery [193]
Highly cationic particle (+68 ± 5 mV)
Self-assembled 19F nanoprobes Self-assembly of amphiphilic redox-responsive 19F-containing polymers and NIR-absorbing ICG molecules 3,5-Bis(trifluoromethyl) benzoic acid part in the polymer TEM, DLS (40 nm), UV–Vis, FNMR and MRI, TEM Water-soluble Accurate sensing and imaging of tumours [66]
In vivo and in vitro studies–HepG2 tumour-bearing cells and mice
High SNR ratio
Good biocompatibility
5 steps for preparation with purification requirement and moderate yield
Novel system which has potential to be extended for imaging other tumour targets
Multi-functional fluorocarbon NPs Single and double emulsion PFD, PFH, perfluorooctane, PFOB, PFCE DLS (200 nm–200 µm), SEM, CM, FC, FI, FMRI, Cell viability–primary human
dendritic cells, histology
Customizable NPs, minimal toxicity In vivo imaging and targeting applications [194]
Size smaller than 200 nm is not formed by this NP formation
PLGA PFPE Emulsification (Sonicator)–1:1 molar ratio of autoclaved PFPE and sterile filtered Pluronic PFPE DLS (103 nm), FNMR and MRI, FM, cellular viability–diabetogenic mice T cells Specificity for the labelled cells Non-invasive monitoring the trafficking of cellular therapeutics [195]
Reliable estimates of the apparent number of cells from image data
PFCE encapsulated PLGA Single emulsion PFCE DLS, FNMR and MRI, SANS, animal studies–male Wistar rats, mouse, mice, cell studie–primary murine/human dendritic cells Biocompatible NPs US and 19F MRI [197]
Better acquisition time Murine cardiac 19F MRI/MRS [199]
Obtains complimentary information when in combination with other imaging agents In vivo PAI, 19F MRI and fluorescent imaging (FI) [198]
NPs loaded with chemotherapeutic drugs could give it a theranostic effect, Resomer RG 502 H, lactide: glycolide molar ratio 48:52 to 52:48 is the mostly used PLGA. The other ratios of lactide: glycolide and also their end group might give interesting results. The encapsulation efficiency of PFC could be studied each time to better understand the sensitivity FMRI and CT (with gold NPs) [200]
SPECT/PET and 19F MRI [204]
Chitosan coated PLGA -PFOB NPs Single emulsion by homogenisation followed by sonication using 1.5% sodium cholate PFOB DLS (170 nm), CLSM, FC, FNMR and FMRI, TEM Background-free signal compared to Gd (III) and super paramagnetic iron oxides NPs Labelling and tracking therapeutic cells in vivo [206]
As chitosan coating is just a physical adsorption, the stability of it has to be verified in biological environment
Size of NPs is increased (200–400 nm) after the chitosan coating
PEGylated PLGA NPs (PLGA NP (NIR700 + PFC)-PEG-800 CW O/W emulsion and solvent evaporation-extraction method PFCE DLS (240–250 nm), TEM, FMRI, TEM, FM, histology, cell culture–murine breast carcinoma cell line Quantitative 3D information from deeper tissues In vivo imaging [212]
Rapid qualitative optical monitoring
PLGA–PEG folate-receptor-targeted NPs Single emulsion-evaporation (1.5% sodium cholate surfactant) PFOB DLS (150 nm), FC, CLSM, F MRI, NIRS, CyA-KB cells Encapsulate imaging agent and drug Theranostic NP [207]
Insufficient SNR in vivo for FMRI
The loading capacity of the NPs is low for doxorubicin and ICG (0.04% and 0.127%)
Doxorubicin-conjugated PFPE NPs Polymers by RAFT polymerization PFPE DLS (8.1, 9.3 and 8.3), FNMR, MD Improved cellular uptake Improved therapeutic efficacy [222]
Deep tumour penetration
Studies done using 3D tumour spheroids
F3-PLGA and F9-PLGA Nanoprecipitation–surfactant free Fluorinated PLGA (2,2,2-trifluoroethanolamine, nonafluoro-t-butoxyethylamine) DLS (~54 nm and 58 nm), TEM, F NMR, FM, CyA–immortalized human glomerular endothelial cells and podocytes No surfactant used Theranostic NPs [217]
Encapsulate hydrophobic drugs
The reaction yield of the fluorinated polymer is not understood
HYPERBRANCHED Multifunctional hyperbranched polymers containing 19F RAFT polymerization for polymer, NPs by self-assembly in water 2,2,2-trifluoroethylacrylate DLS (∼13 nm), GPC, TEM, FNMR and MRI, CT Direct dissolution in water Quantitative 19F MRI CA [232]
Biodegradable
3 step preparation and the final product is not pure (3 mixture products)
FNMR with multiple peaks
T2 shortened
PFPE based hyperbranched NPs conjugated with targeting aptamers RAFT polymerization–for NPs, click chemistry for aptamers attaching PFPE F-DOSY (<10 nm), FM, FC, CrM, MD, FNMR and MRI Superior MR imaging sensitivity and fluorine content -breast cancer cells Quantitative 19F MRI CA [233]
Low-cost fluorescence imaging
Unsuitable for long term studies due to faster clearance from the body
Accumulation of polymer in the liver was observed after 48 h and the 19F signal could be still detected in the liver
Fluorinated hyperbranched polyether copolymers ROMBP and copolymerization for polymers and self-assembly of the colloids 2-[(2,2,2-trifluoroethoxy) methyl]oxirane/epifluorohydrin DLS (160–200 nm), H NMR and F MRI, FM, HPLC, cytotoxicity studies - immortalized human glomerular endothelial cells and immortalized human podocytes Repair damaged kidney glomerular cells in vitro New generation 19F MRI nanotheranostics [234]
Negligible cytotoxicity
Narrow size distribution
Relatively long T1
Higher amount of F gives less SNR
DENDRIMERS Fluorinated Gd(III)-DOTA complexes Convergent synthesis for polymer and self-assembly for NPs Fluorinated amino acid group F NMR, DOSY, H and F MRI, KB cells for in vitro cytotoxicity study, animal imaging—Sprague Dawley female rats Substantial improvement in relaxation rate and SNR ratio CA for high field imaging [239]
Easily cleared through the kidneys
The fluorine in the surface layer of dendrimers is toxic which can be diminished by burying the fluorine further into the dendrimer interior
Second-generation dendron Sonogashira coupling, alkyne deprotection and CuAAC PFTB group attached to the dendron FNMR Higher number of equivalent fluorine than commercially available 19F MRI probes Probes for 19F MRI [240]
Too unpolar to be water-soluble
Just one characterisation technique used
Pseudo-symmetrical fluorines dendrimers Polymer prep–bromination and Williamson ether synthesis, NPs by self-assembly Bis(4-fluorophenyl) trifluoromethyl carbinol group FNMR and MRI Large amount of fluorine with a single NMR peak 19F MRI-guided drug therapy [241]
Optimize 19F relaxation time
High sensitivity
Reliable quantification
Comparatively low yield (8%) for 11 synthesis steps
Self-assembled fluorinated amphiphiles Convergent way–Sonogashira coupling and Williamson ether synthesis for polymer, NPs by self-assembly Fluorinated benzyl group FNMR, DLS (6.3 nm), TEM Quantifying drugs, detecting drug microenvironments and weak interactions 19F NMR/MRI guided drug therapy. [242]
Several synthetic step for the preparation with most of them requiring separation
NANOHYDROGELS Chitosan Ionic gelation using hyaluronic acid and tripolyphosphate 4,4,4-trifluorobutyric acid DLS (274 nm), ELS (+30 mV), FNMR (−66 ppm), HNMR, TGA, DOSY, IR Good biocompatibility toward murine macrophages cell line Chitosan drug delivery systems for MRI lymphography [247]
Degree of substitution is comparatively low (0.3% and 20%) and varies between different substitutes, and determination is laborious
Diblock polymers Self-assembly by heating in aqueous solution Poly[N(2,2 difluoroethyl)acrylamide] SLS (100 and 67 nm), TEM, C-TEM, FNMR Good sensitivity 19F MR imaging–angiogenesis imaging or the labelling of pancreatic islets [248]
Non-cytotoxic for several cell lines
Long synthesis steps for preparation of polymers
Fluorinated amphiphilic polymers Self-assembly of polymers–direct dissolution of amphiphilic polymers in PBS buffer -CF3 groups attached to the chains of polymer DLS (6- 14 nm), FNMR, FMRI–phantom and animal imaging, CM, CyA-HeLa cells Enhancement in T2 relaxation times by increasing the segment mobility Multimodal imaging and therapeutic applications. [249]
Superhydrophilic 19F MRI CA Hydrogel matrix attached to zwitterionic, fluorinated and alkynyl molecule by click chemistry The fluorine atoms on trifluoromethyl groups HMRS, FTIR, GPC, CD, Rheometer, SEM, FMRI, degradation study–female BALB/c mice, CyA-Dendritic cells, NIH 3T3 cells Gelation properties of hydrogels unaffected by labelling CA Real-time FMRI to precisely locate and quantify the degradation rate of hydrogel scaffolds in vivo [250]
3D-stereoscopic and 2D-anatomical information
LIPIDS Antigen-loaded PFC particles High-frequency mixing of the liquid PFC with a cationic lipid mixture-particles coat with PEG PFH or PFCE CM, TEM, F NMR, Cytotoxicity in transplanted pancreatic islets and beta cell-like cells and T-cell proliferation assay Improving pancreatic islets transplantation technique Theranostic PFC NPs [255,256]
Good cell viability and no change in cells’ phenotypical properties
High resolution localization of transplanted cells
The use of PFCE is better than PFH because the latter have 3 peaks in FNMR which reduces its sensitivity
Thermally responsive lipid nano-emulsion Nano-emulsion Modified α-tocopherol FNMR, DLS (50 nm), ZP Proved that T2 changes more than T1 due to variation in temperature for FNMR Potential tumour diagnosis [258]
The temperature studied is extreme (37 and 42 °C) compared to real tumour
Multifunctional paramagnetic PFC NP Microfluidization PFCE DLS (132 nm), AFM, UV–vis, FM, cellular toxicity on bronchial epithelium, FC, clinical pathology, FMRI Enhanced intratumoural penetration PFC NP delivery from intravenous applications to intratracheal use (for lung cancer) [259]
NPs stored under very special condition
The lipid surfactant used have a laborious preparation
The studied NPs contain Gd3+ as Gd-lipid chelates
MICELLE Fluorinated thermoresponsive assembled protein (F-TRAP) Self-assembly micelle Fluorinated amino acids within a protein (5,5,5-DL-trifluoroleucines) DLS (30 nm), FA, SLS, CD, MALDI-TOF-MS, TEM, turbidometry, FNMR, FMRI, Animal studies-mouse xenograft model of human breast cancer No change in T1 Thermoresponsive 19F MRI/MRS-traceable theranostic agents [260]
Doxorubicin encapsulation and thermoresponsive release
Zero echo time 19F MRI was used to get the direct imaging of protein as after micelle formation, there is a reduction in T2
The release of drug is at 45 °C (usually tumour temperature range is 37 °C to 39 °C)
INORGANIC Gold NPs protected by fluorinated ligands (F- MPC) Homogeneous phase synthesis Fluorinated tetraethylene glycol part of the ligand DLS (10 nm), TEM, HAADF-STEM, FNMR, UV-Vis, ESR, CLSM, cell interaction with HeLa cells Elimination of the use of surfactants Nanovector [266]
Size may help to reach small vasculature vessels
Soluble in many organic solvents
The preparation of fluorinated ligands contains 6 steps, most of them requiring purification
Functionalized gold NPs Homogeneous phase synthesis Fluorinated tetraethylene glycol part of the ligand DLS, HNMR, TEM (1.5–2 nm), UV-Vis, FNMR and MRI Water-soluble Dual 1H/19F MRI [267]
Good quality MRI images
Same as ref [266] + Gd(III) is embedded deep in the layer of Au NPs that causes reduction in T1 relaxation times of bulk water proton
Gold NP functionalised with fluorine atoms Reduction of HAuCl4 in the presence of NaBH4 PFTB ICP-MS, F-NMR/MRI, UV-Vis, TEM, Cell viability and apoptosis assays -MDA-MB-231, C33-A and MDA-MB-435S cell lines, MTS CyA Colloidal stability in water and other solvents 19F MR imaging [268]
Single chemical shift
Long storage
High fluorine loading
Long preparation and purification procedure for the fluorine ligands
The position of fluorine in the NPs is not established
Hollow mesoporous silica NPs (HMSN-PFCE) Modified protocol from [301] PFCE DLS, SEM (290 nm), TEM, MRI, NMR, PAGE Prolonged circulation time Dual MRI (1H and 19F) [270]
Helps in understanding the effect of loading agent on the biodistribution of NPs
Better biodistribution of NPs
The study is majorly applicable to systems whose cargo is on the outer surface
Fluorinated mesoporous silica NPs (FMSNs and polyFMSNs) Repeated impregnation-calcination process Fluorosilane or polyfluorosiloxane TGA, TEM (140 nm), DLS, FNMR and MRI, XPS, relaxometric properties Colloidal stability Dual MRI (1H and 19F) [273]
Increase in 19F relaxivities
Meticulous NPs preparation
Contains Gd3+
The detection of probe might be impeded by the strong reduction of T2 after NPs formation
PEG modified silica NP Dehydration polymerizing reaction–PFCE including micelle as a platform PFCE TEM, DLS (50 nm), 1H/19F MRI High sensitivity Tumour imaging [274]
Water stability
Information on long term stability, encapsulation efficiency of PFCE is deficient
Silica multifunctional core–shell NPs (FLAMEs) PFCE-phospholipid nanoemulsion by sol-gel process using a novel surfactant, PAP PFCE DMS (76 nm), F NMR and MRI, TEM, biocompatibility by MTT assay-colon-26 cells, Passive targeting, and accumulation- mice
bearing a tumour
High sensitivity Detection of gene expression and in vivo tumour imaging [277]
Modifiability of the surface, biocompatibility
In vivo stability
The FLAME NPs needs to be PEGylated as naked NPs is trapped immediately by the RES
The information on long term stability of NPs is lacking
Mesoporous FLAME (mFLAME) PFCE emulsion by Sol–gel process PFCE DLS (165 nm), TEM, FNMR and MRI, CLSM, FC, MTT CyA-KB cells, FM Ample cellular uptake and drug release in folate receptor-overexpressing tumour cells Theranostic cancer treatment [278]
Drug release abilities at lower pH. (pH 5)
Efficient tumour cell internalization
Gd3+ complexes on FLAME NPs surface (FLAME-SS-Gd3+) Gd3+ complexes were attached to the FLAME surface by disulfide linkers PFCE DLS (53.4 nm), FNMR and MRI, ICP-AES Smart nanoprobe–based on PRE effect Novel 19F MRI probes that visualize reducing environments [279]
In vivo imaging
High SNR ratio
PFC based 19F MRI nanoprobes (PFC@SiO2, FLAME) PFC emulsion by sol–gel process PFCE, PFOB, FC-43, PFN, PFDCO, TPFBME DLS, TEM (40–120 nm), FI-RAW264.7 cells, H MRI and FMRI, hepatic uptake in mouse T2 values -relatively longer than polymer-based or inorganic 19F MRI nanoprobes Multicolour MRI probes [281]
In vivo triple-colour 19F MRI
The shelf-life information is lacking for the NPs
Fluorinated paramagnetic CAs Multistep synthesis–cycloaddition reaction Nonafluorinated carboxylic acid FNMR, relaxivity measurements, MD Relaxation times depending on the lanthanide ion 19F MRI [35]
Low solubility in aqueous media
Hexagonal-phase NaGdF4:Yb3+/Tm3+ NPs Hydrothermal method NH4F/NaF XRD, SEM, EDX, UV, photoluminescence spectra, EPR Conducive to the UV light IR tomography and MRI [261]
Good water solubility
Lanthanide-based upconversion NPs
Inorganic nanocrystals-PEG-coated CaF2 nanocrystals Solvothermal approach CaF2 H and C and F-NMR, DLS (<10 nm), TEM, XRD, EDX, FTIR, TGA, mouse model of inflammation Maximal 19F density Imaging tracers for in vivo 19F MRI [263]
Average out homonuclear dipolar interactions
Direct and real-time in vivo 19F MRI
Chemically surface modifiable
Long T2
Halloysite nanotubes- benzeneboronic acids (HNTs-6FBB) One-pot synthesis 3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl) benzeneboronic
acid
FNMR (−60 ppm), XRD, FTIR, XPS, TEM, EA (0.31% F) Relatively long T2 Selective response toward H2O2 [285]
Water dispersibility
Detection of H2O2 is based on a very minute shift in FNMR (0.2 ppm)
Low cell cytotoxicity
MIXED/HYBRID Fe(III) tris-β-diketonate with PFPE (‘FETRIS’) Microfluidization –metal-binding β-diketones conjugated to PFPE using pluronic surfactant PFPE and PFPE derivatives, PFOB DLS (140 nm to 200 nm), FNMR and FMRI, cell labelling-rodent glioma cell line Ability to tune T1 by Fe concentration In vivo detection of cell therapies and inflammatory cells [288]
Low cytotoxicity
Small rates of metal leakage in the presence of EDTA in vitro and after cell labelling
Cu1.75S–19F@OFP–SiO2 One-pot encapsulation method-PFCE anchored to Cu1.75S NPs and trapped within the silica shell PFCE DLS (20.8 nm), TEM, FMRI, PTT Ultrahigh F signal Ablation and sensitive multimodal imaging [290]
Biocompatible
Capable of both in vivo imaging (F-MRI) and photothermal ablation
Presence of excess of metals in a single probe!
The degradation of this complex should be evaluated since without the SiO2 coating it is cytotoxic
Fluorinated POSS-star polymers Synthesis of star polymers by RAFT polymerization and polymer formation in water 2,2,2-Trifluoroethyl acrylate in the ligands attached to POSS DLS (8–10 nm), FNMR and FMRI High imaging intensity Theranostic agents for cancer diagnosis and treatment [291]
No surfactants
The yield for the formation of star polymers is low and extreme conditions for preparation
Hybrid of fluorinated graphene oxide and iron oxide (IFGO) Graphene oxide-Hummer’s method. Hybrid–co-precipitation Fluorinated graphene DLS (8–10 nm), FMRI, XRD, XPS, SEM and HRTEM, FTIR, MTT CyA-benign breast epithelial cell line, Raman, UV-Vis, hysteresis Additional imaging modality–magnetic targeted drug delivery Superior CAs for MRI and fluorescent imaging [292]
Increased magnetic saturation-better contrast
Cu7S4−Au heterodimer Cu7S4−Au@PSI−19F/PEG nanocomposites Wet-chemical method for Cu7S4-Au nano seeds followed by click chemistry 2,2,2-trifluoro-N-2-propyn-1-yl-acetamide DLS, HRTEM (27 nm), XRD, EDX, HAADF-STEM, XPS, STEM, F NMR and MRI, CT, cell viability-4T1 cell lines, PTT–liver of female mice Deep penetration Multimodal imaging guided photothermal therapy [293]
High spatial resolution
Enhances the photothermal efficacy
Long preparation for the nanocomposite
Mn-LDH@PFPE NPs Composite system by conjugating a PFPE onto the surface of manganese-incorporated layered double hydroxide PFPE NMR and MRI, DLS (10 nm), TEM, GPC, CM, MTT assay–MDA-MB- 468 breast cancer cells, histopathologic examination High specificity to breast cancer cells Potential “smart” 19F MRI agent for detection of cancer diseases [297]
Fe3+@F,N-CD (fluorine and nitrogen co-doped carbon dot) Simple microwave-assisted thermal decomposition method–from glucose and levofloxacin Levofloxacin DLS (16 nm), TEM, GPC, FTIR, XPS, FM, ESR, cytotoxic studies–HeLa cells, In vivo experiments -4T1 tumour bearing BALB/c mice, FMRI, CLSM High T1 relaxivity T1-weighted MRI CA [298]
Strong photoluminescence
Low synthetic cost
Low toxicity
Cannot be used for long term imaging in the body as they are excreted in a very short time from the body