Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 15;11(2):252. doi: 10.3390/pathogens11020252

Table 2.

Modeling of unobserved processes in the non-phylogenetic family. Within-host evolution (modeled or not) includes whether the transmission bottleneck is complete or weak. When transmission is modeled, we mention the states hosts can find themselves in (S: susceptible, E: latent, I: infectious, R: removed). In addition, either geographical distance (spatial kernel), contact data, or random mixing are considered. Finally, the transmission model mentions whether there is only one index case possible (single introduction) or multiple.

Method (Name) [Reference] Sequence Mutation Within-Host Evolution Transmission Case Observation Inference Method
Aldrin et al., 2011 [28] Kimura model No explicit model SIR (infectious period) All cases are observed but not always sampled Partial Maximum Likelihood
Complete Distance kernel
Multiple
Jombart et al., 2011 (Seqtrack) [16] User’s choice No explicit model No explicit model All cases are observed and sampled Edmonds algorithm
Complete
Ypma et al., 2012 [32] Deletion + Transition + Transversion No explicit model SEIR (latency/infectious period) All cases are observed but not always sampled Bayesian
Complete Spatial kernel
Single
Jombart et al., 2014
(outbreaker) [24]
Mutation rate No explicit model SI (generation times) Proportion of sampled cases Bayesian
Complete Random mixing
Multiple
Worby et al., 2014 [37] Mutation rate Pathogen population size No explicit model All cases are observed and sampled Observed genetic distance vs. theoretical distribution
Weak
Famulare et al., 2015 [38] Mutation rate No explicit model No explicit model No assumption Likelihood ratio test + Pruning algorithm
Worby et al., 2016 (bitrugs) [6] No explicit model No explicit model SEIR (latency/infectious period) Test sensitivity < 1 Bayesian
No assumption Random mixing
Multiple
Campbell et al., 2019
(outbreaker2) [30]
Mutation rate No explicit model SI (generation times) Proportion of sampled cases Bayesian
Complete Contact data
Multiple