Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 15;11(2):252. doi: 10.3390/pathogens11020252

Table 4.

Modeling of unobserved processes in the simultaneous phylogenetic family. For the sequence mutation process, the user could either use a single substitution model or choose. Within-host evolution (modeled or not) includes whether the transmission bottleneck is complete or weak. When transmission is modeled, we mention the states hosts can find themselves in (S: susceptible, E: latent, I: infectious, R: removed). In addition, either geographical distance (spatial kernel), contact data, or random mixing are considered. Finally, the transmission model mentions whether there is only one index case possible (single introduction) or multiple. * means multiple sequences can be considered per epidemiological unit.

Method (Name) [Reference] Sequence Mutation Within-Host Evolution Transmission Case Observation Inference Method
Ypma et al., 2013 [5] Mutation rate Coalescent process SEIR (latency/infectious period) All cases are observed and sampled Bayesian
Complete Spatial kernel
Single
Hall et al., 2015 (beastlier) [18] User’s choice Coalescent process SEIR (latency/infectious period) All cases are observed but not always sampled Bayesian
Complete * Spatial kernel
Single
De Maio et al., 2016 (SCOTTI) [41] User’s choice Coalescent process Migration model Maximum number of hosts Bayesian
Weak *
Klinkenberg
et al., 2017
(phybreak) [26]
Mutation rate Coalescent process SI (generation times) All cases are observed but not always sampled Bayesian
Complete Random mixing
Single
Morelli et al., 2012 [23] Jukes Cantor model No explicit model SEIR (latency/infectious period) All cases are observed and sampled Bayesian
Complete Spatial kernel
Single
Mollentze et al., 2014 [1] Kimura model No explicit model SEIR (latency/infectious period) Observed cases contribute to transmission after removal time Bayesian
Complete Spatial kernel
Multiple
Lau et al., 2015 [42] Kimura model No explicit model SEIR (latency/infectious period) All cases are observed but not always sampled Bayesian
Complete Spatial kernel
Multiple
Firestone et al., 2020 (BORIS) [29] Kimura model No explicit model SEIR (latency/infectious period) All cases are observed but not always sampled Bayesian
Complete Spatial kernel
Multiple
Montazeri et al., 2020 [43] Jukes Cantor model No explicit model No explicit model All cases are observed and sampled Bayesian
Complete