Table 3.
Summary of the reproducibility/repeatability studies.
Reference | Intra-repro | Inter-repro | Repeatability | Condition | Variables | Object | Modality |
Jha et al. [23], 2021 | 30.7% (332/1080) |
14.3% (154/1080) |
82.2% (888/1080) | ICC >0.90 | Slice Sickness | Phantoms | CT |
Emaminejad et al. [24], 2021 | 8.0% (18/226) |
/ | / | CCC>0.90 | Reconstruction | Patients | CT |
7.5% (17/226) |
/ | / | CCC>0.90 | Radiation Dose | Patients | CT | |
Kim et al. [25], 2021 | 11.0% (112/1020) |
/ | / | CCC>0.85 | Acceleration Factors | Patients | MRI |
Ymashita et al. [26], 2020 | / | 5.6% (15/266) |
/ | CCC>0.90 | Different Scanners | Patients | CECT |
Fiset et al. [27], 2019 | / | 22.6% (398/1761) |
/ | ICC >0.90 | Different Scanners | Patients | MRI |
Saeedi et al. [28], 2019 | 20.5% (8/39) |
/ | / | CoV< 5% | Tube Voltage | Phantoms | CT |
30% (13/39) |
/ | / | CoV< 5% | Tube Current | Phantoms | CT | |
Meyer et al. [29], 2019 | 20.8% (22/106) |
/ | / | Radiation Dose | Patients | CT | |
52.8% (56/106) |
/ | / | Reconstruction | Patients | CT | ||
39.6% (42/106) |
/ | / | Reconstruction | Patients | CT | ||
12.3% (13/106) |
/ | / | Slice Sickness | Patients | CT | ||
Perrin et al. [30], 2018 | 24.8% (63/254) |
/ | / | CCC>0.90 | Injection Rates | Patients | CECT |
13.4% (34/254) |
/ | / | CCC>0.90 | Resolution | Patients | CECT | |
Midya et al. [31], 2018 | 11.7% (29/248) |
/ | / | CCC>0.90 | Tube Current | Phantoms | CT |
19.8% (49/248) |
/ | / | CCC>0.90 | Noise | Phantoms | CT | |
63.3% (157/248) |
/ | / | CCC>0.90 | Reconstruction | Patients | CT | |
Altazi et al. [32], 2017 | 21.5% (17/79) |
/ | / | Mean difference <25% | Reconstruction | Patients | PET |
Zhao et al. [13], 2016 | 11.2% (10/89) |
/ | / | CCC>0.90 | Reconstruction | Patients | CT |
/ | / | 69.7% (62/89) |
CCC>0.90 | / | Patients | CT | |
Hu et al. [33], 2016 | / | / | 64.0% (496/775) |
ICC>0.80 | / | Patients | CT |
Choe et al. [34], 2019 | 15.2% (107/702) |
/ | / | CCC>0.85 | Reconstruction | Patients | CT |
CCC: concordance correlation coefficient; ICC: intraclass correlation coefficient; CoV: coefficient of variation; : R-squared; CT: computed tomography; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; CECT: consecutive contrast-enhanced computed tomography; PET: positron emission tomography.