Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 6;22(1):1470320321999497. doi: 10.1177/1470320321999497

Table 1.

Key characteristics of the meta-analyzed reports (n = 18).

Index test Author Year Country Ref. Cutoff value TP FP FN TN
BNP1 Armand 2006 France [10] 275 pg/ml 35 7 6 54
Xu 2013 China [44] 263 pg/ml 10 13 2 41
Xing 2014 China [42] 849.1 pg/ml 26 9 8 80
Zhou 2013 China [46] 204 pg/ml 13 3 3 25
Ma 2016 China [40] 294.79 pg/ml 15 10 3 42
He 2013 China [45] 139 pg/ml 12 4 5 15
Total 111 46 27 257
BNP2 He 2013 China [45] 157 pg/ml 13 4 4 15
Xing 2014 China [43] 224.5 pg/ml 40 15 10 93
Ma 2016 China [40] 332.95 pg/ml 16 6 2 46
Shereen 2014 Egypt [33] 164 pg/ml 9 6 5 10
Lara 2013 Brazil [37] 299 pg/ml 11 11 1 78
Total 89 42 22 242
ΔBNP Cheng 2015 China [34] 80 pg/ml 31 12 2 11
Yang 2011 China [38] 123 pg/ml 64 1 6 12
He 2013 China [45] 29 pg/ml 13 1 6 16
Ma 2016 China [40] 69.36 pg/ml 48 2 4 16
Zhang 2012 China [47] 46 pg/ml 44 2 2 10
Total 200 18 20 65
ΔBNP% Cheng 2015 China [34] 13.4% 28 4 5 19
Chien 2008 China [19] 20% 65 4 6 26
Sameh 2014 Egypt [35] 20% 23 2 2 13
Shereen 2014 Egypt [33] 14.9% 13 5 3 9
Total 129 15 16 67
NT-proBNP1 Hu 2010 China [48] 3635.5 pg/ml 41 16 13 90
Li 2016 China [39] 715.5 pg/ml 14 7 1 20
Total 55 23 14 110
NT-proBNP2 Gang 2013 China [36] 448 pg/ml 6 7 1 15
Wen 2015 China [41] 1199 pg/ml 26 4 8 79
Total 32 11 9 94

BNP1, BNP levels were measured before the preparation of SBT and the prediction of weaning failure. BNP2, BNP levels were measured at the end of SBT and the prediction of weaning failure.

ΔBNP, the change of BNP levels before and after SBT and the prediction of weaning success.

ΔBNP%, ΔBNP divided by BNP1 and the prediction of weaning success.

NT-proBNP1, NT-pro BNP levels were measured before the preparation of SBT and the prediction of weaning failure. NT-proBNP2, NT-pro BNP levels were measured at the end of the SBT and the prediction of weaning failure.

TP: true positive; FP: false positive; FN: false negative; TN: true negative.