Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar;161:107136. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2022.107136

Table 4.

Stages of receipt and integration of feedback during the development of QoE-SPEO and main innovations introduced.

Stage Feedback Main innovations
1 Two rounds of feedback on QoE-SPEO v.1 received from two WHO experts and five individual experts on systematic review methods and integrated in QoE-SPEO v.2 - Adopted and/or revised steps and components from existing tools
- Developed a new step
- Developed new components
- Introduced concepts, terms and examples from occupational health and safety
2 First round of pilot testing on QoE-SPEO v.2, feedback received from ten pilot testers and integrated in QoE-SPEO v.3 - Made minor editorial changes
3 Second round of pilot testing on QoE-SPEO v.3 received from 20 individual experts in occupational health, occupational safety, and/or exposure science that applied QoE-SPEO v.3 in a systematic review of prevalence studies for the WHO/ILO Joint Estimates and integrated QoE-SPEO v.4 - Reviewed and improved the concept, definition and term for “expected heterogeneity”
- Refined considerations and criteria for some downgrade domains
- Added definitions of quality of evidence ratings