Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 15;12:829708. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2022.829708

Table 3.

Clinical results.

Study Follow up (month) MST (months) Type for RT Patients (n) 1-year OS (%) 2-year OS (%) Responser (n) CR (%) PR (%) SD (%) PD (%) ORR (%) LCR (%)
Hou et al. 10 CRT 181 181 29.3 31.5 33.7 5.5 60.8 94.5
Tan et al. 14.3 8 CRT 26 23 4 26 8 31 61 39
Toya et al. 9.6 CRT 38 39.4 17.5 38 15.8 28.9 44.7 10.5 44.7 89.4
Igaki et al. 5.6 CRT 18 33.3 9 12 16.7 16.7 58.3 8.3 33.4 91.7
Tanaka et al. 9.4 CRT 67 39 9 67 7.5 37.3 23.9 31.3 44.8 68.7
Okazaki et al. 5.3 6.4 CRT 56 50 0 22 44 34 22 66
Iwamoto et al. 13.3 CRT 80 56 26.7
Yu et al. 8 11.6 CRT 281 48.1 26.9 260 3.85 54.23 27.69 14.23 58.08 85.77
Rim et al. 13.9 CRT 45 51.5 45 6.7 55.6 31 6.7 62.3 93.3
Bae et al. 8 CRT 47 15 15 47 0 40 51 9 40 91
Huang et al. 3.8 CRT 326 16.7 5.5
Yeh et al. 10 7 CRT 106 34.7 11 106 9.5 52 33 5.5 61.5 94.5
Pao et al. 4.4 6.6 CRT 42 30 19 27 14.8 59.3 25.9 0 74.1 100
Onishi et al. 12.4 CRT+HAIC 33 54.5 22 31 3.2 45.2 45.2 6.5 48.4 93.6
Kodama et al. 9.9 CRT+HAIC 36 47 20.3 36 8.3 41.7 50 0 50 100
Han et al. 13.5 CRT+HAIC 152 60 29.5 152 1.3 46.7 34.2 17.8 48 82.2
Tang et al. 10.7 12.3 CRT+TACE 185 51.6 28.4
Lu et al. 13.02 CRT+TACE 30 62.4 20.81 30 16.7 53.3 20 10 70 90
Yamada et al. 7 CRT+TACE 19 40.6 10.2 19 0 57.9 42.1 0 57.9 100
Shirai et al. 9.4 10.3 CRT+TACE 19 47.4 23.7 19 0 36.8 52.6 10.5 36.8 89.4
Yoon et al. 10.6 10.6 CRT+TACE 412 42.5 22.8 409 6.6 33 46 14.4 39.6 85.6
Yoon et al. 12.8 CRT+TACE 45 53.3 26.8 45 0 28.9 51.1 20 28.9 80
Yu et al. 11.4 CRT+TACE
+hyperthermia
69 85 62.9 69 34 36.2 15.3 14.5 70.2 85.5
Sugahara et al. 21 22 PRT 35 68 48 35 22.8 60 8.6 8.6 82.8 91.4
Hashimoto et al. 8.4 PRT 34 55 34 15 47 35 3 62 97
Komatsu et al. PRT 31 47 24
Sekino et al. 21 PRT 21 62 33
Lee et al. 13.2 13.2 PRT 27 55.6 33.3 27 0 55.6 37 7.4 55.6 92.6
Kim et al. 15.2 34.4 PRT 41 73.2 51.1 41 34.2 48.8 14.3 2.4 83 97.3
Xi et al. 10 13 SBRT 41 50.3 41 36.6 39 17.1 7.3 75.6 92.7
Shui et al. 9.5 10 SBRT 70 40 62 9.7 69.4 6.4 14.5 79.1 85.5
Lou et al. 10 SBRT 75 38.7 13.3 75 22.7 73.3 4 0 96 100
Dutta et al. 6 11.4 (mean) SBRT 72 38 10 54 0 36 42 22 36 78
Kumar et al. 8 15 SBRT 29 60 29 7 80 13 87
Wang et al. 7.4 9.6 (mean) SBRT 20 58 22 36.4 31.8 27.3 4.4 68.2 95.5
Choi et al. 8.4 20.8 SBRT 24 67.5 48.2 24 8.3 45.8 29.2 16.7 54.1 83.3
Hou et al. 11.8 10.46 CRT 64 35.8 16 64 1.6 51.6 12.5 34.3 53.2 65.7
15.47 CRT 54 59.3 32 54 5.6 64.8 9.3 20.3 70.4 79.7
Zhao et al. 13 19 CRT+TACE+Sorafenib 28 72.4 48 28 10.7 35.7 28.6 25 46.4 75
14.1 15.2 CRT+TACE 35 77.5 16 35 0 45.7 31.4 22.9 45.7 77.1
Li et al. 31 10 CRT 154 48.1 25.1
10 SBRT 133 46.5 29.3
Nomura et al. 6.7 CRT+HAIC 18 21 6 32 9.4 50 21.9 18.7 59.4 81.3
49.2 CRT+HAIC+Sorafenib 14 75 50
Lin et al. 6 SBRT 22 14 7 71 21 0 78 100
6.7 CRT 21
Yang et al. 10.9 SBRT 54 34.9 15.3 45 11.1 51.1 33.33 4.4 62.2 95.53
4.7 CRT 86 15.7 8 59 8.5 25.4 45.8 20.3 33.9 79.7
Que et al. 13.22 (mean) 12.5 SBRT+Sorafenib 18 55.6 17.7 18 33.33 44.44 11.11 11.11 77.77 88.88
15.33 (mean) 7 SBRT 36 33.3 11.1 36 25 50 2.78 22.22 75 77.78
Khorprasert et al. 8.2 7.9 CRT 140 39.1 16.5 119 18.5 55.5 8.4 17.6 74 82.4
11.9 SBRT 20 45 22

Red font means overall survival in 1st year; overall survival in 2nd year.