Table 8. Characteristics of the selected studies in pediatric dentistry.
S. no | Author, Year, Country | VR system | Participants | Study design | Assessment tool | Tested outcome | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abbreviations: AR, augmented reality; CCO, comparative crossover; CST, cross sectional trial; DS, dental students; LAVR, local anesthesia virtual reality; MCQs, multiple choice questions; RCT, randomized controlled trial; VP, virtual patient; VR, virtual reality. | |||||||
1 | Papadopoulos et al 2013 in Greece 77 | VR simulation pediatric VP | (103) 4th year DS | RCT | MCQs knowledge questionnaire VP feedback |
Students’ knowledge of behavior and communication pediatric dentistry | VP group had significantly higher scores and the majority evaluated the aspects of the simulation very positively |
2 | Mladenovic et al 2020 in Serbia 78 | AR simulator | (21) Fourth and fifth year DS | RCT | The time taken to administer the anesthesia. Level of salivary cortisol before and after Level of salivary cortisol before and after the administration of anesthesia | Perception of learning and acute stress level | AR group reported significantly shorter time. The level of cortisol significantly increased no statistical difference between the groups |
3 | Zafar et al 2020, Australia 79 | Simodont Haptic simulator | (100) Doctorate degree students | CCO | Traditional and simulator training on pulpotomies and stainless-steel crowns (SSCs), followed by a questionnaire | Experience of pulpotomy and SSCs procedures on the Simodont, vs. conventional training | Over 50% agreed that Simodont-assisted learning, and facilitated understanding of pediatric dentistry tasks, although they felt more comfortable with the conventional training setup |
4 | Zafar et al 2021, Australia 80 | Oculus Quest (VR headset plus digital 3D holograms and 360-degree spatial sound) |
(71) Second year DS | CST | Self-administered questionnaire before and after the use of dental LAVR simulator | Dental student’s perception of dental LAVR simulation on a pediatric patient | Most of the participants reported improved LA skills, more engaged in the learning activity, improved understanding of anatomical landmarks, and added value compared with traditional LA teaching methods |