Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 7;22:106. doi: 10.1186/s12876-022-02132-0

Table 2.

Clinical outcomes and manifestations of the patients included for meta-analysis

No. of study Author No. of  patients No. of death No. of GI symptom No. of diarrhea No. of nausea/vomiting No. of abdominal pain
1 Alizadehsani R et al. 123 15 (12.2%) 11 (8.9%) NA NA NA
2 An P et al. 205 6 (2.9%) 79 (38.5%) NA NA NA
3 Atalla E et al. 111 48 (43.2%) 8 (7.2%) 8 (7.2%) 2(1.8%) NA
4 Caillard S et al. 243 43 (17.7%) 96 (39.5%) 96 (39.5%) NA NA
5 Chadalavada P et al. 84 11 (13.1%) 44 (52.4%) NA NA NA
6 Chen R et al. 1077 85 (7.9%) 359 (33.3%) NA NA NA
7 Chen T et al. 274 113 (41.2%) 77 (28.1%) 77 (28.1%) 24(8.8%) 19(6.9%)
8 Comoglu Ş et al. 1086 38 (3.5%) 78 (7.2%) 78 (7.2%) NA NA
9 Crespo M et al. 414 109 (26.3%) 152 (36.7%) NA NA NA
10 Doganci S et al. 397 34 (8.6%) 292 (73.6%) NA NA NA
11 Du H et al. 182 1 (0.5%) 20 (11.0%) 9 (4.9%) 7(3.8%) 7(3.8%)
12 Elimian K et al. 3215 295 (9.2%) 132 (4.1%) 132 (4.1%) 103(3.2%) 20(0.6%)
13 Ferm S et al. 877 208 (23.7%) 219 (25.0%) NA NA NA
14 Gayam V et al. 408 132 (32.4%) 111 (27.2%) NA NA NA
15 Ghoshal U et al. 252 5 (2.0%) 26 (10.3%) NA NA NA
16 Hajifathalian K et al. 1059 147 (13.9%) 349 (33.0%) NA NA NA
17 Huang H et al. 49 9 (18.4%) 3 (6.1%) 3 (6.1%) 1 (2.0%) NA
18 Jiang Y et al. 281 114 (40.6%) 33 (11.7%) 33 (11.7%) 13 (4.6%) NA
19 Jin X et al. 651 1 (0.2%) 74(11.4%) NA NA NA
20 Kang M et al. 118 6 (5.1%) 54 (45.8%) 54(45.8%) NA NA
21 Kim D et al. 867 121 (14.0%) 181 (20.9%) 181 (20.9%) 175 (20.2%) NA
22 Lanthier N et al. 50 26 (52.0%) 15 (30.0%) 12 (24.0%) 3 (6.0%) 3 (6.0%)
23 Laszkowska M et al. 2804 542 (19.3%) 1084 (38.7%) NA NA NA
24 Leal T et al. 201 55 (27.4%) 60 (29.9%) NA NA NA
25 Liang J et al. 109 23 (21.1%) 26 (23.9%) 26 (23.9%) 10 (9.2%) 5 (4.6%)
26 Liu J et al. 29,393 711 (2.4%) 2289 (7.8%) NA NA NA
27 Livanos A et al. 634 151 (23.8%) 299 (47.2%) NA NA NA
28 Luo S et al. 1411 66 (4.7%) 183 (13.0%) NA NA NA
29 Ma X et al. 467 16 (3.4%) 25 (5.4%) 25(5.4%) NA NA
30 Montazeri M et al. 611 104 (17.0%) 155 (25.4%) NA NA NA
31 Moura D et al. 400 89 (22.3%) 133 (33.3%) NA NA NA
32 Nobel Y et al. 278 9 (3.2%) 97 (34.9%) 56 (20.1%) 63 (22.7%) NA
33 Pan L et al. 204 36 (17.6%) 103 (50.5%) NA NA NA
34 Peng X et al. 49 16 (32.7%) 22 (44.9%) 11 (22.4%) 15 (30.6%) 3(6.1%)
35 Ramachandran P et al. 150 58 (38.7%) 31 (20.7%) NA NA NA
36 Redd W et al. 318 32 (10.1%) 195 (61.3%) NA NA NA
37 Renelus B et al. 734 237 (32.3%) 231 (31.5%) NA NA NA
38 Russell B et al. 156 34 (21.8%) 25 (16.0%) NA NA NA
39 Schettino M et al. 190 41 (21.6%) 138 (72.6%) NA NA NA
40 Shang H et al. 564 51 (9.0%) 157 (27.8%) 157 (27.8%) NA NA
41 Soares R et al. 1152 456 (39.6%) 126 (10.9%) 126 (10.9%) NA NA
42 Sulaiman T et al. 140 12 (8.6%) 78 (55.7%) NA NA NA
43 Tsibouris P et al. 61 16 (26.2%) 11 (18.0%) 11 (18.0%) 4 (6.6%) 2 (3.3%)
44 Vena A et al. 275 120 (43.6%) 14 (5.1%) 14(5.1%) 11(4.0%) NA
45 Villanego F et al. 1011 220 (21.8%) 323 (31.9%) NA NA NA
46 Vrillon A et al. 52 17 (32.7%) 17 (32.7%) NA NA NA
47 Wan, Y et al. 230 6 (2.6%) 49 (21.3%) 49 (21.3%) NA NA
48 Wang Z et al. 59 41 (69.5%) 22 (37.3%) 22 (37.3%) 4 (6.8%) NA
49 Yang X et al. 52 32 (61.5%) 2 (3.8%) NA 2 (3.8%) NA
50 Zhang J et al. 663 25 (3.8%) 61 (9.2%) 61 (9.2%) 31 (4.7%) 5 (0.8%)
51 Zhang L et al. 409 102 (24.9%) 91 (22.2%) 91 (22.2%) 50 (12.2%) 28 (6.8%)
52 Zhou F et al. 191 54 (28.3%) 9 (4.7%) 9 (4.7%) 7 (3.7%) NA
53 Zhou Z et al. 254 16 (6.3%) 66 (26.0%) NA NA NA
Cumulative incidence 25% 16% 7.5% 3.6%

GI, gastrointestinal; NA, not available