Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 7;1(4):236–247. doi: 10.1038/s44159-022-00034-2

Table 1.

Summary and comparison of timescales for stigma and health research

Historical context Human development Stigma course
Concept The extent to which and ways in which statuses are stigmatized change over time; thus, the impact of stigma on health and processes linking stigma with health change over time The ways in which individuals experience stigma and the extent to which stigma impacts health change across the lifespan The ways in which individuals experience stigma and the extent to which stigma impacts health change in relation to the course of stigmatized statuses
Examples Declines in sexual diversity stigma in the second half of the twentieth century and beginning of the twenty-first century Childhood and adolescence are sensitive periods, when experiences of stigma have particularly profound effects on health and development People living with HIV experience higher internalized stigma immediately following HIV diagnosis
Emergence of HIV-related stigma in the 1980s and COVID-19 stigma in the 2020s According to the weathering hypothesis, older adults are vulnerable to the effects of accumulated stress due to stigma Individuals who enter recovery from substance use disorders (SUDs) replace a stigmatized identity (‘addict’) with a valued identity (‘person in recovery’)
Research questions How do experiences of stigma differ within various historical contexts? How do experiences of stigma evolve across the life course? How do experiences of stigma change alongside the course of stigmatized statuses, including status gains and losses?
During which social change contexts is stigma most harmful to health? At which developmental stages are individuals most vulnerable to the harmful effects of stigma on health? As individuals gain and lose stigmatized statuses, when are they most vulnerable to the impacts of stigma?
When and how do pathways linking stigma with health change over time? For how long do experiences of stigma impact health?
Research methods Multilevel methods Life course histories Mixture modelling
Longitudinal policy analysis Longitudinal studies Moderation analyses
Integrative data analysis
Implications for interventions During times when stigma is not changing at structural or individual levels, interventions that promote resilience to stigma among individuals with stigmatized statuses might be most effective Deliver stigma interventions during stages of human development when individuals are most vulnerable to stigma Address internalized stigma in the weeks and months following the development of a new stigmatized status
During times when stigma is changing at structural and/or individual levels, stigma reduction might be most effective Stigma interventions delivered early in life might promote well-being later in life Individuals might continue to be impacted by stigma even after they have lost a stigmatized status
Intervention strategies should be leveraged to address the cumulative effects of experienced and anticipated stigma among people who have lived with stigmatized statuses for long periods of time