Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 23;9:648835. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2022.648835

Table 2.

Comparison of outcomes according to the three criteria.

Berlin Definition (253 cases) Altitude-P/F-corrected criteria (229 cases) Zhang criteria (204 cases)
Mild Moderate Severe P values Mild Moderate Severe P values ALI ARDS P values
No(%) 49(19.37) 148(58.50) 56(22.13) 107(46.72) 84(36.68) 38(16.59) 87(42.65) 117(57.35)
ICU mortality, No(%) 3(6.12) 28(18.92) 24(42.86) <0.001 19(17.76) 18(21.43) 18(47.37) 0.001 16(18.39) 36(30.77) 0.045
28-day mortality, No(%) 3(6.12) 49(33.11) 34(60.71) <0.001 25(23.36) 37(44.05) 24(63.16) <0.001 23(26.44) 60(51.28) <0.001
No of ventilator-free days over a 28-day period, d, median (IQR) 26.17 18.73 0 <0.001 21.42 16.53 5.6 <0.01 19.5 4.21 0.03
(20.00–27.21) (0.00–25.30) (0.00–18.26) (3.75–26.50) (0.00–24.28) (0.00–16.02) (0.00–26.04) (0.00–23.31)
ICU length of stay, d, median (IQR) 6 8.71 6.69 0.024 7.67 8.23 7.69 0.929 8.08 7.79 0.246
(2.23–12.32) (4.63–18.10) (3.53–14.18) (3.67–14.92) (3.71–16.96) (4.30–14.77) (4.63–16.42) (3.63–15.17)
Duration of invasive ventilation, d, median (IQR) 1.79 4.75 4.23 0.003 3.88 4.46 5.11 0.132 5.08 4.67 0.945
(0.73–4.98) (1.50–10.62) (2.16–9.92) (1.04–9.13) (1.40–9.45) (2.73–11.85) (1.46–9.83) (2.15–10.63)
Hospital length of stay, d, median (IQR) 24 22 16 0.001 23 18.5 18 0.036 23 18 0.059
(19.00–38.00) (13.25–35.75) (6.00–25.75) (14.00–37.00) (9.25–30.00) (8.00–26.00) (14.00–38.00) (9.00–29.50)

IQR, Inter Quartile Range.