TABLE 1.
Methods of force application | Weight of the piston on the top Tse et al. (2012) | Weight of the cube filled with iron ball bearings Kim et al. (2017) | Weight of the piston on the top Kalli et al. (2019) | Cylindrical weight on the top Morikura and Miyata (2019) | Cylindrical weight on the top Morikura and Miyata (2021) | Air pressure applied via a bioreactor device Novak et al. (2020) | Weight of gels on the top [this work] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Compression force | 5.8 mmHg | 5.8 mmHg (∼0.773 kPa) | 4 mmHg | 0.77 kPa | 0.77 kPa | 3.9–6.5 kPa dynamically | 0.08–0.24 mmHg |
Compression force applied duration | 16 h | 24 h | 16 h | 8 and 32 h | a cycle of 4 h on/4 h off | 24 and 72 h | 1, 2, 4, and 24 h |
Cell types | Breast cancer cells | Breast cancer cells | Brain cancer cells | Melanoma cells | Melanoma cells | Ovarian cancer cells | Breast cancer cells |
Cell culture condition | Cells sandwiched between gels | Cells embedded in agarose | Spheroids embedded in agarose | Cells embedded in collagen | Cells embedded in collagen | Cells embedded in agarose/collagen | Cells sandwiched between gels |
Real-time observation | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
Single cell resolution | No | No | No | No mentioned | No mentioned | No | Yes |
Hydrogel digest for cell harvest | Not required | Required | Required | Required | Required | Required | Not required |