Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Mar 11.
Published in final edited form as: J Chem Theory Comput. 2010 Nov 9;6(12):3836–3849. doi: 10.1021/ct100481h

Table 1.

Overview of MD Simulations of TL Systems Carried Out

label force field duration (ns) the first appearance of “ladder-like” structure80 (ns)a
UUCG_94 ff94  50 NO
UUCG_99 ff99   100 NO
UUCG_bsc0 ff99bsc0   100 NO
UUCG_99χODE ff99χODE   100 NO
UUCG_bsc0χODE ff99bsc0χODE   100 NO
UUCG_99χYIL ff99χYIL   100 NO
UUCG_bsc0χYIL ff99bsc0χYIL   300 NO
UUCG_99χOL-DFT ff99χOL-DFT   100 NO
UUCG_bsc0χOL-DFT ff99bsc0χOL-DFT   300 NO
UUCG_99χOL ff99χOL   100 NO
UUCG_bsc0χOL ff99bsc0χOL   800 NO
UUCG_charmm CHARMM27  50 NO
UUCG_99SEb ff99, KCl SE   100 NO
UUCG_bsc0SEb ff99bsc0, KCl SE   100 NO
GAAA_99 ff99  50 NO
GAAA_bsc0 ff99bsc0   100 NO
GAAA_99χODE ff99χODE   100 85  
GAAA_bsc0χODE ff99bsc0χODE   100 NO
GAAA_99χYIL ff99χYIL   100 NO
GAAA_bsc0χYIL ff99bsc0χYIL   300 NO
GAAA_99χOL-DFT ff99χOL-DFT   100 NO
GAAA_bsc0χOL-DFT ff99bsc0χOL-DFT   300 NO
GAAA_99χOL ff99χOL   100 NO
GAAA_bsc0χOL ff99bsc0χOL   800 NO
GAAA_charmm27 CHARMM27   100 NO
GAAA_99K+c ff99, K+   100 95  
GAAA_99SEb ff99, KCl SE   100 NO
GAGA_99 ff99   100 36  
GAGA_bcs0d ff99bsc0  25 20  
GAGA_99χODEd ff99χODE  15 5 
GAGA_bsc0χODEd ff99bsc0χODE  25 21  
GAGA_99χYIL ff99χYIL   100 NO
GAGA_bsc0χYIL ff99bsc0χYIL   300 NO
GAGA_99χOL-DFT ff99χOL-DFT   100 NO
GAGA_bsc0χOL-DFT ff99bsc0χOL-DFT   300 NO
GAGA_99χOL ff99χOL   100 NO
GAGA_bsc0χOL ff99bsc0χOL 1000 NO
GAGA_charmm27 CHARMM27   100 NO
GAGA_99SEb ff99, KCl SE   100 50  
GAGA_bsc0SEb ff99bsc0, KCl SE   100 NO
a

“NO” means not observed.

b

Simulations in excess of KCl salt.

c

Simulation under minimal salt conditions with Na+ ions replaced by K+.

d

Simulations were terminated because a “ladder-like” structure was irreversibly formed.