La Vecchia 1999.
Methods | Case‐control study of hip fractures conducted at Ospedale Maggiore (included 4 largest teaching and general hospitals in Milan, Italy) between 1983 and 1992 | |
Participants | Participants from control group within case‐control studies of breast and genital cancers (earlier reports: La Vecchia 1991; Parazzini 1996) | |
Interventions | Oral contraceptive use | |
Outcomes | Hip fracture Insufficient data for analysis; results presented as reported |
|
Notes | Report was in a letter to journal editor. Earlier publications (cited in letter) provided study design information but time periods differed and analysis may have differed. | |
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Case definition and representativeness | Low risk | Cases: 279 women, 29 to 74 years old, admitted for fracture of hip or proximal femur; median age 62 years |
Exposed cohort: representativeness | Unclear risk | Not applicable |
Control selection and definition; non‐exposed cohort selection | Low risk | Controls: 1861 women, 25 to 74 years old, admitted for acute condition (other than trauma) to same network of hospitals as cases; median age 55 years |
Exposure ascertainment, including same method for cases and controls | Low risk | History of lifetime use of oral contraceptives (structured questionnaire); analyzed as 'ever use' and use for 2 years or longer. Ever use of OCs: cases (N = 10); controls (N = 167) Data collected for cancer studies as noted in 'Participants.' |
Outcome assessment (cohort study): method and evidence outcome not present at study start | Unclear risk | Not applicable |
Comparability of groups on basis of design or analysis | Low risk | OR from multivariate analysis; no detail in this brief report Earlier publications focused on different exposures; identified relevant variables (e.g., demographics, alcohol and tobacco use, body mass index, use of hormone replacement therapy, and menopause) included in logistic regression models. |
Case‐control: non‐response rate | Unclear risk | Earlier report (La Vecchia 1991), with data through June 1989, noted < 3% refused to participate (8 cases, 38 controls) |
Cohort: follow‐up length and adequacy (including loss to follow‐up) | Unclear risk | Not applicable |