Table 2.
Summary of intervention, patient, and outcome characteristics
| Author year | Participants | Intervention and control | Outcome measures | Significant findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Gordon 2020 [20] USA |
87 T2D rural living veterans, HbA1c 8.5% |
12-min video and pamphlet designed to improve provider-patient communication during video consultation Fully digital solution One off session Control: Pamphlet version of provider-patient communication support |
Ratings for post-visit provider-patient therapeutic alliance | Patients who watched a pre-visit educational video before their telehealth video consultation reported higher therapeutic alliance scores post-visit than the control group |
| Gunawardena 2019 [27] Sri Lanka |
67 T2D patients Mean age 52 years, 40% female, HbA1c 9.4% |
Mobile app designed to support glucose management Fully digital solution 6 months Control: Usual care |
App usage HbA1c |
Significantly lower A1c levels compared to the control group were observed over 6 months A1c improvement was positively correlated with app usage with over 80% using the app 8–9 times/week and 52% 12 times or more/week and 78% at 6 months |
|
Kerfoot 2017 [19] USA |
456 T2D veterans, Mean age 60 years, 6.% female, HbA1c 9.0% |
Online diabetes self-management game with integrated teams competition Integrated solution 6 months Control: non-diabetes related game |
HbA1c | The intervention group had significantly greater reductions in mean HbA1c over 6 months compared to the control |
|
Kusnanto 2019 [26] Indonesia |
65 T2D patient 57% female, HbA1c 8.5% |
Diabetes calendar app for SM education program Fully digital solution 3 months Control: Leaflet version of SM education program |
Diabetes management self-efficacy scale (DMSES) HbA1c Cholesterol, triglyceride, LDL-c, insulin level |
The intervention group had a significantly higher self-efficacy scores than the control group The intervention group had a significantly lower mean HbA1c levels than the control group The intervention group had a significantly better cholesterol, triglyceride, LDL-c, and insulin levels than the control group |
|
Poppe 2019 [23] Belgium |
54 T2D patients Mean age 63 years, 27% female |
Website and app designed to increase physical activity and reduce sedentary behavior Fully digital solution 5 weeks Control: Wait-list control |
Accelerometer assessed breaks from sedentary time | The intervention group displayed a significant increase in accelerometer-assessed breaks from sedentary time in comparison with the control group |
|
Capozza 2015 [18] USA |
93 T2D patients Mean age 53 years 61% female |
Two-way SMS system designed to improve glycemic control through coaching, education and testing reminders Fully digital solution 180 days Control: Usual care |
CSQ-8 (8-question Client Satisfaction Questionniare) Satisfaction survey Frequency of engagement HbA1c |
Mean satisfaction score was 27.7/32 at 180 days 85% said “yes” to having improved disease knowledge and management strategies 94% said "yes” they would recommend intervention others 29% demonstrated frequent engagement (texting responses at least 3 × per week for ≥ 90 days) Both groups had decreased HbA1c but there was no significant difference between them |
|
Hilmarsdottir 2020 [25] Iceland |
37 T2D patients Mean age 51yrs, 63% female, HbA1c 7.8% |
Gamified app designed to support healthy lifestyle behaviors with the option to compete with other users Integrated solution 6 months Control: Usual care |
Problem Areas in Diabetes Scale (PAID) Satisfaction survey Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) HbA1c |
There was a significant decrease in the intervention group (but not between groups) in diabetes distress anxiety symptoms and HbA1c levels |
|
Lee 2020 [22] South Korea |
72 T2D patients Mean age 50 years, 68% female, HbA1c 7.4% |
Diabetes self-management education app with individualized feedback from health care professionals via the app Integrated solution 6 months Control: Usual care |
Diabetes Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire (DTSQc) HbA1c |
The intervention group had a significantly higher rates of treatment satisfaction than the control group |
|
Whittemore 2019 [29] Mexico |
47 T2D patients Mean age 56 years, 68% female |
Diabetes self-management group sessions (in-person) followed by a texting system to support behavior change Integrated solution 7.6 months Control: Usual care |
Diabetes self-efficacy Blood glucose monitoring HbA1c |
In the intervention group, HbA1c score, diet, and exercise was significantly improved (but not in comparison to the control) |
|
Xu 2020 [21] USA |
65 low-income, mostly African American T2D patients Mean age 55 years, 68% female, HbA1c 9.5% |
SMS/phone system designed to improve reduce HbA1c and fasting blood glucose (FBG) self-management through automated contact and some bidirectional communication Integrated solution 6 months Control: Reduced version of digital intervention (i.e., weekly only SMS and no bidirectional communication) |
Engagement as measured by proportion responding to ≥ 25% of texts or calls over 4 weeks Fasting blood glucose HbA1c |
Engagement was 58% for the intervention group and 48% for the control group The intervention groups had significantly decreased HbA1c and self-reported fasting blood glucose while the control group did not |