Table 2. Comparison of the cladistic characteristics between the mitochondrial and nuclear trees of East Asian Bufo.
The comparison between concatenated mtDNA and nuDNA trees demonstrated the discordances between the recovered clades of Bufo gargarizans distributed in East Asia and showed identical patterns of divergence in the septentrional East Asian Bufo sachalinensis clades. The number of clades in the description is matching the phylogenetic trees in Figure 4.
| Distribution range | Clade | Description of cladistics | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concatenated mtDNA (CR-ND2) | Concatenated nuDNA (POMC-RAG1-Rho) | ||
| Japanese Archipelago | Bufo japonicus formosus | Monophyletic (Clade 1) | Grouped together in a clade of Japanese Bufo |
| Japanese Archipelago | Bufo japonicus japonicus | Monophyletic (Clade 2) | |
| Korean Peninsula | Bufo stejnegeri | Monophyletic (Clade 3) | B. stejnegeri were grouped with Korean B. gargarizans in a nested clade of southeastern mainland and septentrional East Asian B. gargarizans (Clade 3) |
| Northeastern Mainland Asia | Bufo gargarizans | Monophyletic (Clade) | Contained multiple clades of B. gargarizans restricted to the southeastern and northeastern Asian mainland |
| Eastern Mainland | Bufo gargarizans | Polyphyletic with a clade of B. bankorensis distributed in Taiwan Island(Clade 5) | Formed multiple clades across Eastern Asian Bufo lineages. A clade grouped with northeastern B. gargarizans. Another clade is polyphyletic with of B. bankorensis of Taiwan Island and B. gargarizans distributed in septentrional East Asia (Clade 3). |
| Taiwan Island | Bufo bankorensis | ||
| Central Mainland | Bufo gargarizans | Formed two distinctive clades:
|
|
| Septentrional East Asia (Korean Peninsula) | Bufo sachalinensis cf. sachalinensis | Monophyletic (Clade 6) | Monophyletic (Clade 3) |
| Septentrional East Asia (Amur River Basin) | Bufo sachalinensis sachalinensis | Monophyletic (Clade 6) | Monophyletic (Clade 3) |