Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 1;13:795224. doi: 10.3389/fendo.2022.795224

Table 1.

Summary of eligibility criteria.

Included Excluded
Population
  • Children aged <18 years with GHD, an rhGH- indicated condition, or a chronic condition requiring daily or weekly self- or caregiver-administered injectable treatment (MS, JIA, IBD)

  • Parents or caregivers of pediatric patients treated with regular injections for these conditions

  • Studies in adults or where outcomes of pediatric patients are not reported separately from those of adult patients

Intervention
  • rhGH or a self- or caregiver-administered injectable drug (SC or IM) indicated for ongoing daily or weekly treatment of chronic conditions (MS, JIA, IBD) in pediatric populations

  • Interventions that are not delivered by SC or IM injection (i.e., topical, oral, or infusion)

  • Interventions that are not identified as SC or IM injection only and that could include other administration routes (e.g., “biologics” if this category includes infused or IV agents) ( Supplementary Table S1 )

Comparator
  • Any or none

  • Not applicable

Outcomes
  • Clearly identifiable/defined standardized measures (validated or non-validated) AND reported prevalence of adherence/non- adherence or compliance/non-compliance to injectable drugs, OR

  • Explicitly identifiable and measured (a) barriers to adherence, OR (b) characteristics of patients, families/caregivers, providers, or institutions associated with adherence to prescribed treatment, OR (c) properties of the treatment, such as administration route or schedule, associated with adherence

  • Publications that (a) do not define how adherence was measured, or (b) do not report rate of adherence/non-adherence (e.g., discontinuation or persistence only would be excluded), or (c) do not report barriers/factors affecting adherence

  • For inclusion, outcomes must be reported for SC or IM injectable drugs separately from infusion/IV, oral, or other routes of administration ( Supplementary Table S1 )

Study design
  • Observational studies (prospective or retrospective; including cohort studies, cross- sectional studies, or surveys)

  • RCTs or non-RCTs (if reporting medication adherence or compliance)

  • Studies with non-empirical, theoretical, or narrative discussion of adherence and no quantitative measure of adherence

  • Publications reporting methods or tool development, unless they report either a quantitative measure of adherence/non- adherence or factors associated with adherence

  • Other study designs were not eligible (e.g., pre-clinical, case reports/studies reporting patient- level data only, economic studies, pooled data analyses, or meta-analyses)

  • Systematic reviews published from 2015 onwards were not eligible for inclusion but were hand-searched for additional relevant references

Limits
  • Published in peer-reviewed journal from 2015 to 2020

  • Studies not published in English will be considered, with data extraction limited to English language elements and numerical data

  • Unpublished data and data from conference abstracts

GHD, growth hormone deficiency; IBD, inflammatory bowel disease; IM, intramuscular; IV, intravenous; JIA, juvenile idiopathic arthritis; MS, multiple sclerosis; RCT, randomized contrail trial; rhGH, recombinant growth hormone; SC, subcutaneous.