Schematic of
the β-lactam screening strategy. (a) β-lactams
were sent from four pharma partners to three academic screening centers
to test for activity against wild-type H37Rv or ΔpanCDΔlysA Mtb that was replicating or rendered
nonreplicating in a four-stress model.48,50 Primary screening
hit rates are shown in Table S1. (b) Subset
of actives from Sanofi and GSK were resupplied as fresh stocks to
a single academic screening center (WCM) for retesting head-to-head
against Mtb ΔpanCDΔlysA at WCM. The GSK primary and secondary screens included some β-lactams
from an earlier screen of their β-lactam collection.47 Actives from Lilly and MSD were retested at
the IDRI and NIAID, respectively. (c) 416 confirmed actives from all
four companies were tested at WCM head-to-head for clavulanate dependency
in the dose–response format against replicating Mtb ΔpanCDΔlysA. (d) Final set of 48 β-lactams
supplied for PK, DMPK, chemistry, and phenotypic testing. The annotation
on the right of the figure describes the structure reveal: in (a),
no structures were disclosed; in (b,c), 638 structures were revealed
to all parties; and in (d), the final 48 compounds were all assigned
a structure (primarily those that were not assigned in (b,c). Abbreviations:
GSK, Diseases of the Developing World at GlaxoSmithKline; IDRI, Infectious
Disease Research Institute; WCM, Weill Cornell Medicine; NIAID, National
Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases; UNC, University of North
Carolina; TBDA, Bill & Melinda Gates TB Drug Accelerator; R, replicating
conditions; NR, 4-stress nonreplicating conditions; clav, clavulanate
at 4 μg/mL; DsRed/mCherry, red fluorescent protein; GFP, green
fluorescent protein; and OD, optical density at A580.