Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Nov 15.
Published in final edited form as: J Chem Theory Comput. 2021 Oct 26;17(11):7056–7084. doi: 10.1021/acs.jctc.1c00628

Table 3.

Water cluster binding energies (kcal/mol) with HIPPO compared to ab initio calculations.

Cluster Structure Reference HIPPO HIPPO Minimum Difference
Trimera −15.77 −15.417 −15.767 0.00
Tetramera −27.39 −25.695 −26.685 0.71
Pentamera −35.90 −32.994 −34.582 1.32
Hexamerb Prism −45.92 −44.169 −46.145 −0.23
Cage −45.67 −43.635 −45.387 0.28
Bag −44.30 −41.106 −43.364 0.94
Chair −44.12 −40.484 −42.543 1.58
Book A −45.20 −42.359 −44.245 0.96
Book B −44.90 −42.103 −43.958 0.94
Boat A −43.13 −39.576 −41.548 1.58
Boat B −43.07 −39.612 −41.555 1.52
Octamera D2d −73.0 −68.309 −71.547 1.5
S4 −72.9 −68.253 −71.559 1.3
11-mera 43’4 −104.6 −94.775 −100.232 4.4
515a −1040 −93.635 −99.377 4.6
16-mera AABB 164.1 −155.457 −161.556 2.5
ABAB 164.2 −155.875 −161.836 2.4
Antiboat 164.6 −152.799 −159.634 5.0
Boat A 164.4 −152.457 −159.357 5.0
Boat B 164.2 −152.400 −159.425 4.8
17-mera 552’5 −175.7 −161.740 −169.938 5.8
Sphere −175.0 −162.549 −170.681 4.3
MAD:
Summary: Dimer – Hexamer 0.57
Octamer – 17-mer 3.8
a

Structures and reference values from reference 73.

b

Hexamer structures and reference energies from reference 74.