Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 17;17(3):e0265559. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0265559

Table 1. Description of included studies: ED setting.

Study Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria Mean/Median age (years) % Male Sample size Outcome EWS Cut-off points SEN% SPE% AUC/OR (95% CI) ROB
Jiang et al. 2019 [22] Multiple trauma Age < 16yrs and missing data, DOA, medical patients 48.0 73.7 1127 28 days in-hospital mortality MEWS ≥3 93.0 75.0 0.78 Poor
Demircan et al. 2020 [23] Age ≥65yrs, Yellow or red triage code TRI, CPR prior arrival, loss of contacts 77.2 52.0 1106 28 days in-hospital mortality MEWS ≥3 58.4 65.3 0.65 Good
Mitsunaga et al. 2019 [24] Age ≥65yrs N/S 78.0 53.9 2204 28 days in-hospital mortality NEWS ≥5 78.7 64.0 0.79 Good
28 days in-hospital mortality MEWS ≥3 69.3 67.6 0.72
Koksal et al. 2016 [25] Age ≥18yrs, triage category 1 or 2 Age <18yrs and TRI 62.0 49.4 502 28 days in-hospital mortality MEWS ≥3 78.0 79.9 0.85 Poor
Maftoohian et al. 2020 [26] Age ≥18yrs Advance airway, CPR, intubation applied, not admitted, DOA 62.1 50.9 381 30 days in-hospital mortality MEWS ≥3 78.3 68.4 0.73 Good
30 days in-hospital mortality MEWS ≥4 30.4 83.2 N/S
ICU admission MEWS ≥3 85.7 67.6 0.77
Yuan et al. 2018 [27] Stay longer than 24 hours Age < 14yrs, LOS less than 24 hours, incomplete information, lost follow up, non-cooperative family members 64.0 60.0 612 28 days in-hospital mortality MEWS ≥4 56.9 79.4 0.72 Good
ICU admission MEWS ≥3 64.5 68.7 0.73
Dundar et al. 2016 [28] Age ≥65yrs Age < 65yrs and TRI patients, CPR 75.0 55.9 671 28 days in-hospital mortality MEWS ≥4 74.0 89.0 0.89 Good
Graham et al. 2020 [29] Age ≥18yrs with triage as Emergency or Urgent Age <18yrs, pregnant, presenting out of research hours 72.0 50.9 1253 30 days in-hospital mortality NEWS ≥5 35.8 86.8 0.61 Good