Skip to main content
. 2021 Sep 24;21(1):34–43. doi: 10.1007/s12663-021-01643-9

Table 2.

Characteristics of included studies

No Authors No of patients Race Age Sex Site of origin Histology Local recurrence Cranial Involvement Latency (years) Surgery cranial Radiation Therapy Other metastasis Recurrence Outcome
1 Harrer 1970 [29] 1 Caucasian 52 F Maxillary \ No Anterior cranial fossa 23 No No Yes (Lung) No Dead 6 month
2 Kyriazis et. al. 1971 [30] 1 Caucasian 73 M Maxillary Follicular Yes Orbit 5 No No No No Dead 1 year
3 Shaw and Katsikas 1973 [31] 1 \ 81 M Maxillary \ No Orbit 0 No 50 gy No Yes Dead 4 year
4 Daramola et. Al 1980 [32] 1 \ 22 M Maxillary Follicular Yes Orbit 5 Yes 36 gy Yes (lung) No Dead
5 Komisar et. al. 1984 [25] 1 \ 63 M Maxillary Plexiform Yes Orbit, Anterior cranial fossa 2 No No No No Dead
6 Weiss et. al. 1985 [33] 1 \ 72 M Maxillary Mixed Yes Orbit, Middle cranial fossa 5 Yes No No Yes (1 year) Dead
7 Oka et. Al. 1986 [34] 1 Asian 27 M Mandibular \ Yes Middle cranial fossa 18 Yes No No Yes (4 years) Dead 1 year
8 Bredenkamp et. al. 1989 [4] 5 African 53 M Maxillary Mixed No Middle cranial fossa 0 No 64 gy No No Alive
Caucasian 59 F Maxillary Plexiform No Orbit 0 Yes No No No \
Caucasian 43 M Maxillary Follicular Yes Middle cranial fossa 13 Yes No No Yes Alive
Caucasian 15 M Maxillary Plexiform Yes Orbit 2 Yes 65 gy No Yes (3 years) Dead 1 year
Caucasian 36 F Nasal \ No Anterior cranial fossa 2 months Yes No No No Alive
9 Eliasson et. Al. 1989 [35] 1 \ 40 F Maxillary \ Yes Orbit, Middle cranial fossa \ \ \ Yes (Lung) Yes (8,5 year) Alive
10 Scaccia et. al. 1991 [36] 2 Caucasian 53 M Maxillary \ Yes Orbit, Middle cranial fossa 13 Yes No No Yes (2 years) Alive
Caucasian 60 M Maxillary Follicular No Orbit 3 Yes No No No Alive
11 Phillips et. al. 1992 [10] 1 Caucasian 65 M Mandibular Mixed Yes Parieto-occipital 15 Yes Yes No Yes (1 years) \
12 Sato et. al. 1994 [37] 1 Asian 79 M Maxillary Follicular Yes Orbit, Anterior cranial fossa 9 Yes No No No Alive
13 Hayashi et. al. 1997 [38] 1 Asian 63 F Mandibular \ Yes Orbit, Middle cranial fossa 27 Yes 29 Gy No No Alive
14 Zarbo et. al. 2003 [39] 1 African 14 F Maxillary Spindle cell Yes Anterior cranial fossa 29 No No No No Dead 1 month
15 Goldenberg et. al. 2004 [40] 2 Caucasian 77 F Mandibular \ Yes Not specified 10 Yes \ No \ \
Caucasian 37 F Maxillary \ Yes Anterior cranial fossa 3 No Yes No \ Dead 1 month
16 Leibovitch et. al. 2006 [41] 2 Caucasian 73 M Maxillary Follicular Yes Middle cranial fossa 30 Yes No No \ \
Asian 60 F Mandibular \ Yes Not Specified 7 Yes Yes No \ \
17 Chen et. al. 2006 [27] 3 Asian 42 F Mandibular Mixed Yes Orbit, Anterior cranial fossa 15 Yes No No Yes (6 years) Alive
Asian 57 F Maxillary Follicular Yes Fronto-temporal 13 Yes No No Yes (4 years) Dead
Asian 34 F Mandibular Follicular Yes Fronto-temporal 17 Yes No No Yes (3 years) Alive
18 Yoshida et. Al. 2009 [42] 1 Asian 70 F Maxillary \ Yes Fronto-temporal \ \ \ \ \ \
19 Woodroffe et. al. 2013 [9] 1 Caucasian 60 M Maxillary \ Yes Clivus 4 Yes 65 Gy No 1 year Alive
20 Rotellini et. al. 2016 [43] 1 Caucasian 29 M Maxillary Plexiform Yes Orbit, Middle cranial fossa 20 Yes 60 Gy No 8 months Alive
21 Quick-Weller et. al. 2016 [44] 1 African 57 M Maxillary \ Yes Anterior cranial fossa 12 Yes No No No Alive
22 Bettoni et. Al. 2018 [45] 1 African 22 M Mandibular Papillary Yes Right parietal lobe 4 Yes No No No Alive
23 Li et. Al. 2019 [46] 1 Asian 28 F Mandibular \ Yes Left frontal lobe 5 No SRS 24,2 gy Yes (lung) \ \