Table 12.
The Fitness values obtained by each algorithm
| ID | Algorithm | Threshold level (n) | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2-n | 3-n | 4-n | 5-n | 10-n | 20-n | 40-n | 60-n | 80-n | 100-n | ||
| 61060 | IWOA | 12.776 | 15.9511 | 19.0715 | 21.789 | 33.8015 | 52.3957 | 78.3952 | 96.322 | 109.6184 | 120.0533 |
| IMPA(Abdel-Basset et al. 2020) | 12.776 | 15.9561 | 19.0715 | 21.8197 | 33.8031 | 52.2547 | 77.7866 | 95.1371 | 107.3739 | 116.0695 | |
| FFA (Erdmann et al. 2015) | 12.776 | 15.9611 | 19.0712 | 21.788 | 33.7471 | 51.8177 | 75.8089 | 91.5198 | 103.0224 | 111.9054 | |
| SCA (Mirjalili 2016) | 12.7756 | 15.957 | 19.0357 | 21.7388 | 33.45 | 50.6662 | 73.1764 | 88.8787 | 100.2654 | 109.332 | |
| FPA(Yang 2012) | 12.776 | 15.9529 | 19.0336 | 21.7037 | 33.3017 | 50.2076 | 72.8298 | 88.225 | 100.0461 | 109.6068 | |
| L-SHADE(Brest et al. 2016) | 12.7402 | 15.848 | 18.7631 | 21.3867 | 32.6433 | 49.0551 | 70.8876 | 86.3258 | 98.1304 | 107.4438 | |
| SSA (Wang et al. 2020) | 12.776 | 15.9574 | 19.0712 | 21.7995 | 33.6629 | 51.7207 | 76.1782 | 91.5312 | 103.1833 | 112.8129 | |
| EO(Abdel-Basset et al. 2021) | 12.7760 | 15.9536 | 19.0715 | 21.7891 | 33.7511 | 51.7728 | 76.2052 | 92.0687 | 103.9213 | 113.4531 | |
| CSA(Moses et al. 2019) | 12.7759 | 15.9574 | 19.0516 | 21.7625 | 33.4716 | 50.8725 | 73.7686 | 89.3058 | 101.4225 | 110.6946 | |
| 105053 | IWOA | 11.8823 | 15.122 | 18.0216 | 20.6712 | 32.3523 | 50.3743 | 74.7683 | 91.2218 | 102.9993 | 112.056 |
| IMPA(Abdel-Basset et al. 2020) | 11.8823 | 15.122 | 18.0383 | 20.6791 | 32.3437 | 50.2377 | 74.2076 | 89.9192 | 100.9974 | 108.9814 | |
| FFA (Erdmann et al. 2015) | 11.8823 | 15.122 | 18.0247 | 20.6791 | 32.1936 | 49.4224 | 71.4182 | 85.7842 | 95.8659 | 104.189 | |
| SCA (Mirjalili 2016) | 11.881 | 15.113 | 17.9904 | 20.6263 | 31.9543 | 48.4581 | 69.2537 | 83.0938 | 93.5198 | 101.607 | |
| FPA(Yang 2012) | 11.8822 | 15.1112 | 17.9834 | 20.6066 | 31.7961 | 47.7961 | 68.4096 | 82.1473 | 92.5227 | 100.9397 | |
| L-SHADE(Brest et al. 2016) | 11.7392 | 14.8633 | 17.589 | 20.1722 | 30.8293 | 45.98 | 66.0778 | 79.8543 | 90.5128 | 98.9473 | |
| SSA (Wang et al. 2020) | 11.8823 | 15.1219 | 18.0358 | 20.6664 | 32.2229 | 49.4192 | 71.5406 | 85.3184 | 95.8636 | 104.4071 | |
| EO(Abdel-Basset et al. 2021) | 11.8482 | 15.1220 | 17.9966 | 20.6998 | 32.3109 | 49.7221 | 72.1895 | 86.1353 | 97.3854 | 104.7356 | |
| CSA(Moses et al. 2019) | 11.8821 | 15.1161 | 17.9991 | 20.6338 | 32.0011 | 48.5745 | 69.8052 | 84.2199 | 94.7203 | 103.0389 | |
| 181079 | IWOA | 12.5194 | 15.6559 | 18.5605 | 21.2831 | 33.0229 | 51.7113 | 77.6138 | 95.1912 | 108.2282 | 118.3517 |
| IMPA(Abdel-Basset et al. 2020) | 12.5194 | 15.6559 | 18.5607 | 21.2833 | 33.0227 | 51.5554 | 77.0396 | 93.8592 | 105.3401 | 114.4753 | |
| FFA (Erdmann et al. 2015) | 12.5194 | 15.6559 | 18.5596 | 21.2816 | 32.9363 | 51.0539 | 74.4852 | 89.7446 | 101.5361 | 110.4897 | |
| SCA (Mirjalili 2016) | 12.5193 | 15.6528 | 18.5481 | 21.2574 | 32.7656 | 50.0573 | 72.2192 | 87.5166 | 98.8036 | 107.7341 | |
| FPA(Yang 2012) | 12.5194 | 15.6525 | 18.5463 | 21.2322 | 32.5791 | 49.4161 | 71.6639 | 86.8136 | 98.6199 | 107.5495 | |
| L-SHADE(Brest et al. 2016) | 12.5021 | 15.5605 | 18.3787 | 20.9216 | 31.8685 | 48.2518 | 69.8864 | 84.675 | 96.4386 | 105.7433 | |
| SSA (Wang et al. 2020) | 12.5194 | 15.6559 | 18.56 | 21.2813 | 32.9585 | 51.1506 | 74.8946 | 90.6978 | 101.2136 | 110.3164 | |
| EO(Abdel-Basset et al. 2021) | 12.5194 | 15.6530 | 18.5598 | 21.2829 | 32.9412 | 51.0342 | 74.8979 | 90.8307 | 102.4668 | 111.2834 | |
| CSA(Moses et al. 2019) | 12.5194 | 15.6545 | 18.5530 | 21.2561 | 32.7245 | 49.9210 | 72.6653 | 88.2450 | 99.7304 | 109.0304 | |
| 232038 | IWOA | 11.9894 | 15.2615 | 18.0564 | 20.8226 | 32.5819 | 50.9049 | 76.2528 | 93.5106 | 106.3026 | 116.2968 |
| IMPA(Abdel-Basset et al. 2020) | 11.9894 | 15.2615 | 18.0657 | 20.8512 | 32.5896 | 50.6511 | 75.6467 | 92.4374 | 104.1028 | 112.7034 | |
| FFA (Erdmann et al. 2015) | 11.9894 | 15.2606 | 18.0551 | 20.7902 | 32.4147 | 50.1182 | 73.7958 | 89.8715 | 100.9383 | 109.7447 | |
| SCA (Mirjalili 2016) | 11.9891 | 15.249 | 18.022 | 20.7231 | 32.1319 | 49.1496 | 71.225 | 85.6759 | 96.8546 | 105.4877 | |
| FPA(Yang 2012) | 11.9893 | 15.2502 | 18.025 | 20.7002 | 31.9145 | 48.6638 | 70.3656 | 85.5129 | 96.7159 | 105.5622 | |
| L-SHADE(Brest et al. 2016) | 11.9613 | 15.0528 | 17.7702 | 20.3541 | 31.1784 | 47.232 | 68.699 | 83.3479 | 94.5921 | 103.6789 | |
| SSA (Wang et al. 2020) | 11.9894 | 15.261 | 18.0619 | 20.8162 | 32.4102 | 50.1126 | 74.0407 | 90.1449 | 101.0976 | 110.3437 | |
| EO(Abdel-Basset et al. 2021) | 11.9894 | 15.2615 | 18.0687 | 20.8512 | 32.5406 | 50.1159 | 74.1409 | 90.2424 | 101.5987 | 110.4611 | |
| CSA(Moses et al. 2019) | 11.9894 | 15.2547 | 18.0412 | 20.7296 | 32.2061 | 49.0106 | 71.4365 | 86.6975 | 98.2346 | 106.9818 | |
| 277095 | IWOA | 11.9706 | 14.9796 | 17.802 | 20.4036 | 31.6016 | 48.2872 | 70.2967 | 84.8372 | 95.0545 | 102.9802 |
| IMPA(Abdel-Basset et al. 2020) | 11.9706 | 14.9795 | 17.802 | 20.4091 | 31.5793 | 48.2265 | 69.9503 | 83.2584 | 91.978 | 98.399 | |
| FFA (Erdmann et al. 2015) | 11.9706 | 14.9793 | 17.7932 | 20.3993 | 31.5387 | 47.9795 | 68.6196 | 80.9031 | 89.0562 | 95.4017 | |
| SCA (Mirjalili 2016) | 11.9703 | 14.9777 | 17.7794 | 20.3582 | 31.2482 | 46.4847 | 65.0903 | 77.2917 | 86.0844 | 92.7041 | |
| FPA(Yang 2012) | 11.9706 | 14.9763 | 17.7676 | 20.3349 | 30.9178 | 45.3584 | 62.8773 | 74.6368 | 83.5616 | 90.2943 | |
| L-SHADE(Brest et al. 2016) | 11.9036 | 14.8163 | 17.5314 | 19.8222 | 29.1678 | 42.401 | 59.4692 | 71.5032 | 79.9929 | 86.9559 | |
| SSA (Wang et al. 2020) | 11.9706 | 14.9791 | 17.7927 | 20.4005 | 31.5368 | 47.8578 | 67.9296 | 80.6834 | 89.2749 | 96.6264 | |
| EO(Abdel-Basset et al. 2021) | 11.9706 | 14.9797 | 17.8020 | 20.4010 | 31.5495 | 47.7624 | 68.4138 | 81.7316 | 90.9752 | 98.3387 | |
| CSA(Moses et al. 2019) | 11.9704 | 14.9777 | 17.7781 | 20.3590 | 31.1246 | 46.0247 | 64.5108 | 76.7458 | 85.4095 | 92.4490 | |
Bold values indicate the best value