Table 14.
The Fitness values obtained by each algorithm
| ID | Algorithm | Threshold level (n) | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2-n | 3-n | 4-n | 5-n | 10-n | 20-n | 40-n | 60-n | 80-n | 100-n | ||
| Barbara | IWOA | 12.8944 | 16.0776 | 19.0524 | 21.8663 | 33.9123 | 52.4601 | 79.0757 | 97.5044 | 111.1390 | 121.6892 |
| IMPA | 12.8944 | 16.0776 | 19.0524 | 21.8663 | 33.8879 | 52.2651 | 78.4649 | 96.2442 | 108.8346 | 119.0990 | |
| FFA | 12.8944 | 16.0775 | 19.0523 | 21.8658 | 33.8054 | 51.8108 | 76.8774 | 93.3866 | 105.6021 | 114.8431 | |
| SCA | 12.8944 | 16.0758 | 19.0482 | 21.8492 | 33.6107 | 50.7942 | 73.8078 | 89.7958 | 101.6265 | 111.2091 | |
| FPA | 12.8944 | 16.0756 | 19.0413 | 21.8341 | 33.3758 | 50.3978 | 73.7337 | 89.6948 | 102.0421 | 111.8403 | |
| L-SHADE | 12.8922 | 16.0579 | 18.9910 | 21.7421 | 33.0279 | 49.9484 | 72.8420 | 88.7265 | 100.7691 | 110.3752 | |
| SSA | 12.8944 | 16.0775 | 19.0523 | 21.8659 | 33.7984 | 51.7781 | 76.6527 | 93.2786 | 105.3635 | 114.6159 | |
| EO | 12.8944 | 16.0776 | 19.0524 | 21.8663 | 33.8446 | 51.9086 | 76.6778 | 93.4764 | 106.5393 | 115.7284 | |
| CSA | 12.8944 | 16.0764 | 19.0476 | 21.8471 | 33.5953 | 50.8853 | 74.2599 | 90.3407 | 103.0055 | 112.4235 | |
| Airplane | IWOA | 12.2274 | 15.5081 | 18.3280 | 20.9303 | 32.1921 | 49.4457 | 73.3265 | 89.5468 | 101.3674 | 110.3298 |
| IMPA | 12.2274 | 15.5081 | 18.3280 | 20.9443 | 32.1938 | 49.3655 | 72.9529 | 88.3452 | 99.0658 | 107.5168 | |
| FFA | 12.2274 | 15.5081 | 18.3277 | 20.9426 | 32.1144 | 48.7340 | 71.0379 | 85.4506 | 95.3996 | 103.3912 | |
| SCA | 12.2271 | 15.5060 | 18.3131 | 20.9008 | 31.8910 | 47.6428 | 68.1025 | 81.4938 | 91.3694 | 99.3757 | |
| FPA | 12.2274 | 15.5050 | 18.3041 | 20.8828 | 31.5846 | 46.8968 | 66.7783 | 80.3438 | 90.4299 | 98.7316 | |
| L-SHADE | 12.2193 | 15.4624 | 18.1729 | 20.6912 | 31.0167 | 45.4572 | 65.3350 | 78.7339 | 89.0651 | 97.3590 | |
| SSA | 12.2274 | 15.5081 | 18.3276 | 20.9398 | 32.1214 | 48.8001 | 70.8753 | 85.1912 | 95.0733 | 103.6766 | |
| EO | 12.2274 | 15.5081 | 18.3280 | 20.9323 | 32.1053 | 48.7336 | 71.1307 | 85.3082 | 96.0334 | 104.1792 | |
| CSA | 12.2273 | 15.5069 | 18.3155 | 20.9039 | 31.8410 | 47.6095 | 68.4197 | 82.4731 | 93.1874 | 101.3812 | |
| Mandrill | IWOA | 12.2772 | 15.3757 | 18.2736 | 20.9959 | 32.9155 | 51.1552 | 76.0453 | 92.9924 | 105.3956 | 114.9888 |
| IMPA | 12.2772 | 15.3757 | 18.2736 | 20.9959 | 32.9143 | 51.1099 | 75.6127 | 91.7131 | 103.1385 | 112.2372 | |
| FFA | 12.2772 | 15.3757 | 18.2736 | 20.9950 | 32.7840 | 50.5569 | 73.9999 | 89.7650 | 100.2964 | 108.6361 | |
| SCA | 12.2772 | 15.3750 | 18.2694 | 20.9754 | 32.5856 | 49.3850 | 70.8031 | 85.1097 | 95.4408 | 103.8036 | |
| FPA | 12.2772 | 15.3742 | 18.2574 | 20.9455 | 32.3696 | 48.6056 | 69.7875 | 83.8852 | 94.5511 | 103.5075 | |
| L-SHADE | 12.2716 | 15.3496 | 18.1481 | 20.7558 | 31.8418 | 47.5229 | 68.1328 | 82.4165 | 93.4220 | 102.1532 | |
| SSA | 12.2772 | 15.3757 | 18.2735 | 20.9946 | 32.7925 | 50.3889 | 73.9087 | 89.0713 | 100.4362 | 108.8014 | |
| EO | 12.2772 | 15.3757 | 18.2736 | 20.9956 | 32.8209 | 50.6321 | 74.1493 | 89.5809 | 100.6387 | 109.2418 | |
| CSA | 12.2772 | 15.3748 | 18.2661 | 20.9636 | 32.5732 | 49.4223 | 71.0083 | 85.4344 | 96.6188 | 105.3668 | |
| Lena | IWOA | 12.4048 | 15.4167 | 18.1576 | 20.8085 | 32.0524 | 49.6385 | 74.1868 | 90.5829 | 102.7917 | 112.0831 |
| IMPA | 12.4048 | 15.4167 | 18.1610 | 20.8085 | 32.0648 | 49.5704 | 73.5401 | 89.6584 | 100.5093 | 109.4049 | |
| FFA | 12.4048 | 15.4167 | 18.1575 | 20.8062 | 31.9091 | 48.9252 | 71.3114 | 85.7903 | 95.9802 | 104.9155 | |
| SCA | 12.4044 | 15.4150 | 18.1452 | 20.7724 | 31.6910 | 47.8182 | 68.6007 | 82.6401 | 92.7791 | 100.4986 | |
| FPA | 12.4048 | 15.4150 | 18.1412 | 20.7472 | 31.4874 | 47.2013 | 67.6995 | 81.6370 | 92.0589 | 100.1660 | |
| L-SHADE | 12.3984 | 15.3854 | 18.0679 | 20.5629 | 31.0228 | 46.3283 | 66.1567 | 80.2060 | 90.6329 | 99.0467 | |
| SSA | 12.4048 | 15.4167 | 18.1581 | 20.8081 | 31.9273 | 48.7946 | 71.3387 | 85.9434 | 96.7511 | 104.2898 | |
| EO | 12.4048 | 15.4167 | 18.1593 | 20.8085 | 31.9498 | 49.0792 | 71.6291 | 86.3202 | 97.0603 | 105.3507 | |
| CSA | 12.4048 | 15.4154 | 18.1476 | 20.7676 | 31.6884 | 47.9890 | 69.2904 | 83.6876 | 94.4701 | 102.7164 | |
Bold values indicate the best value