Table 2.
Summary of Findings on Impact of Cannabis Policy on Alcohol Use Measures Among Youth and Young Adults
Article | Data (Study Period) | Age Group | MJ Policy Measure | Alcohol Policy or Price Measure | Impact of MJ Policy on Alcohol Use Measure | Impact of MJ Policy on MJ Use Measure |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Youth Population (Age 19 and Younger) | ||||||
Wen et al. (2015)48 | NSDUH (2004–2012) | Ages 12–20 | MML | Beer tax | ↓ 30 d total alcohol drinks ↑ 30 d binge drinking days ↓ AUD past year |
↓ 30 d MJ use ↓ 30 d daily/near daily MJ use ↓ Days of MJ use ↑ First MJ use last year ↓ DSM-IV MJ use/dependence |
MML provisions | Beer tax | NS | Retail dispensary: ↑ 30 d MJ use |
|||
Cerdá et al. (2018)50 | MTF (1991–2015) | Grades 8, 10, and 12 | MML | Beer tax | ↓ Binge drinking, 8th graders ↑ Binge drinking, 10th graders ↑ Binge drinking, 12th graders |
↓ 30 d MJ use for 8th graders ↑ 30 d MJ use for 10th graders ↓ 30 d MJ use for 12th graders |
Dills et al. (2017)47 | MTF (1977–2015) | Grade 12 | Either MML or RML | Beer tax, MLDA, Zero tolerance law, 0.08 BAC limit | ↓ Lifetime alcohol use ↓ 30 d alcohol use ↓ 30 d number of times used |
↓ Lifetime MJ use ↓ 30 d MJ use ↓ 30 d number of times used |
Either MML, RML, or Decrim | Beer tax, MLDA, Zero tolerance law, 0.08 BAC limit | ↑ Lifetime alcohol use ↑ 30 d alcohol use ↓ 30 d number of times used |
↑ Lifetime MJ use ↑ 30 d MJ use ↑ 30 d number of times used |
|||
Johnson et al. (2018)49 | YRBSS (1991–2011) | Grades 9–12 | MML | None | ↓ 30 d alcohol use ↓ 30 d alcohol use without MJ ↓ 30 d binge drinking |
↓ 30 d MJ use without alcohol |
MML Restrictiveness (Scale: Less restrictive law means higher value) | None | ↓ 30 d alcohol use ↓ 30 d alcohol use without MJ ↓ 30 d binge drinking |
↓ 30 d MJ use without alcohol | |||
Coley et al. (2020)46 | YRBSS (1999–2017) | Ages 14–18+ | RML | Beer tax | ↓ Any 30 d alcohol use ↓ Level of 30 d alcohol use |
↑ Any 30 d MJ use ↓ Level of 30 d MJ use |
MML | Beer tax | ↑ Any 30 d alcohol use ↓ Level of 30 d alcohol use |
↑ Any 30 d MJ use ↓ Level of 30 d MJ use |
|||
Decrim | Beer tax | ↑ Any 30 d alcohol use ↓ Level of 30 d alcohol use |
↑ Any 30 d MJ use ↓ Level of 30 d MJ use |
|||
Mason et al. (2016)52 | Common Sense Parenting Intervention (2010–2013) | Grades 8–9 | RML | None | ↓ 30 d alcohol use | ↑ 30 d MJ use |
Bailey et al. (2020)51 | Seattle Social Development Project (2002–2011–2015–2018) | ≤ age 20 | RML | None | ↑ Past-year alcohol use | ↑ Past-year MJ use |
Young Adult Population (Ages 18–25) | ||||||
Kerr et al. (2017)55 | Healthy Minds Study (2012–2016) | Ages 18–26 | RML | No | ↓ Past 2-week heavy alcohol use | ↑ 30 d MJ use |
Cook et al. (2020)53 | FARS (2010–2017) | Ages 15–24 | DML | Beer tax ALR laws | NS: MVCs with BAC ≥ 0.08% | None |
MML | Beer tax ALR laws | ↓ MVCs with BAC ≥ 0.08% | None | |||
Alley et al. (2020)56 | National College Health Assessment (2008–2018) | Ages 18–26 | RML | No | ↓ Binge drinking ≤ 20 years ↓ Binge drinking ≥ 21 years |
None |
Sabia et al. (2017)26 | BRFSS (1993–2012) | Ages 18–24 | MML | Alcohol tax Zero tolerance laws | ↓ 30 d any alcohol use ↓ 30 d binge drinking |
None |
Sabia & Nguyen (2018)57 | BRFSS (1990–2016) | Ages 18–19 Ages 20–29 | MML | Beer tax | ↓ 30 d number of drinks, ages 18–19 ↓ 30 d number of drinks, ages 20–29 |
None |
Kerr et al. (2018)54 | National College Health Assessment II (2008–2016) | Ages 18–26 | RML | No | ↓ 30 d alcohol use | ↑ 30 d MJ use ↑ Level of 30 d MJ use |
Bold text indicates finding statistically significant at alpha = 0.05 for a two-tailed test.
Note: ALR, administrative license revocation; AUD, alcohol use disorder; BAC, blood alcohol concentration; BRFSS, Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System; Decrim, decriminalization; DML, decriminalization marijuana law; DSM-IV, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition; FARS, Fatality Analysis Reporting System; MJ, marijuana; MLDA, minimum legal drinking age; MML, medical marijuana law; MTF, Monitoring the Future; MVCs, motor vehicle crashes; NS, nonsignificant; NSDUH, National Survey on Drug Use and Health; RML, recreational marijuana law; YRBSS, Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System.