Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 23;157(5):406–413. doi: 10.1001/jamasurg.2022.0290

Table 1. Patient and Surgeon Characteristics.

Characteristic Findingsa
Patient characteristics
No. of patients 378
Age, mean (SD), y 72 (7)
Gender
Male 206 (55)
Female 172 (45)
Race and ethnicity
American Indian or Alaska Native 3 (1)
Asian 10 (3)
Black or African American 28 (7)
Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander 0
White 312 (83)
Missing 10 (3)
Other 15 (4)
Language spoken
English 364 (96)
Spanish 13 (3)
Receipt of QPL intervention
QPL intervention 185 (49)
Usual care 193 (51)
Family present at initial consultation 299 (79)
Educational level
Some college or less 233 (62)
College degree or higher 145 (38)
Insurance
Medicare and Medicare plus supplemental 250 (66)
Any Medicaid 28 (7)
Private insurance 97 (26)
Surgical indication
Oncologic 306 (81)
Vascular 72 (19)
Final treatment decision
No surgery planned 40 (11)
May consider surgeryb 107 (28)
Surgery planned 231 (61)
Surgeon reluctance to operate
No reluctance 287 (76)
Surgeon expressed reluctance to operate 91 (24)
Audio length, mean (SD), min 23.7 (12)
Surgeon characteristics
No. of surgeons 43
Age, mean (SD), y 46.1 (8)
Gender
Male 35 (81)
Female 8 (19)
Race and ethnicity
Asian or Pacific Islander 18 (42)
Black or African American 1 (2)
Hispanic or Latino 1 (2)
White 22 (51)
Unknown or >1 race 2 (5)
Time in practice, mean (SD), y 20 (8)

Abbreviation: QPL, question prompt list.

a

Data are presented as number (percentage) unless otherwise indicated.

b

During group adjudication of the 5-domain Observing Patient Involvement in Decision-making scores, coders assessed the final treatment decision based on the content of the recorded consultation. The response “may consider surgery” was used to indicate consultations when surgery was discussed but not definitely planned (eg, awaiting additional workup or discussion with tumor board) or when surgery was being considered in the future.