Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 24;25(3):e25889. doi: 10.1002/jia2.25889

Table A2.

Studies reporting on 95‐95‐95 goal(s) meeting inclusion criteria for meta‐analysis (N=129)

Study population Study type Dates Country Total number of study participants 95‐95‐95 Goal reported Proportion of men meeting 95‐95‐95 goal(s) Quality criteria
Abah et al. (2016) Individuals living with HIV initiated on NNRTI‐based ART, median age 34 years (interquartile range [IQR] 29–41 years) Retrospective cohort study 2009–2010 Nigeria 588 Third 0.89 All criteria met
Abah et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on first‐line ART, median age 34 years (IQR 29–41 years) Retrospective cohort study 2004–2012 Nigeria 12,115 Third 0.77 All criteria met
Abongomera et al. (2017) Individuals reporting HIV testing Cross‐sectional study 2015 Uganda 2124 Second 0.59 Criteria partially met
Ahonkhai et al. (2015) Individuals living with HIV on ART, median age 32 years (IQR 27–39 years) Retrospective cohort study 2009–2011 Nigeria 2496 Second 0.40 All criteria met
Andronescu et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV initiating third‐line ART, median age 40 years (IQR 18–49 years) Retrospective cohort study 2012–2015 Zambia 80 Third 0.69 Criteria partially met
Avong et al. (2015) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age 21–60 years Cross‐sectional study 2004–2010 Nigeria 502 Third 0.83 All criteria met
Baltazar et al. (2015) Men working in mines, age 23–68 years Cross‐sectional study 2012 South Africa and Mozambique 432 First and second 0.25 and 0.78 Criteria partially met
Barak et al. (2019) Individuals with median age 51 years (IQR 34–71 years) Prospective review cohort study 2015–2017 Botswana 1969 Second 0.68 All criteria met
Barnabas et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV, age ≥18 years Household‐randomized unblinded trial 2016–2019 South Africa and Uganda 1315 Third 0.54 All criteria met
Bhattacharjee et al. (2020) Men who have sex with men (MSM), age ≥15 years Cross‐sectional bio‐behavioural survey 2019 Kenya 1200 First and second 0.38 and 0.86 All criteria met
Billioux et al. (2015) Individuals living with HIV initiated on first‐line ART, median age 33 years (IQR 28–40 years) Prospective cohort study 2005–2011 Uganda 1841 Third 0.91 Criteria partially met
Billioux et al. (2017) Individuals living with HIV enrolled in care, age 15–49 years Retrospective longitudinal cohort study 2013–2015 Uganda 3666 First and third 0.97 and 0.89 Criteria partially met
Billioux et al. (2018) Individuals living with HIV enrolled in care, age 15–49 years Census surveillance cohort study 2015–2016 Uganda 1554 Third 0.93 Criteria partially met
Bock et al. (2016) Individuals living with HIV, age 18–49 years Cross‐sectional study 2012 Swaziland 927 Third 0.86 All criteria met
Borgdorff et al. (2018) Individuals aged 15–64 years Population‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2011–2012 and 2016 Kenya 28,486 First 0.38 Criteria partially met
Boyd et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV, age ≥15 years Cross‐sectional report 2018–2019 Zambia 248,002 Second 0.34 Criteria partially met
Brooks et al. (2016) Individuals living with HIV initiated on first‐line ART, median age 41 years (IQR 23–82 years) Cross‐sectional study 2012–2013 Kenya 333 Third 0.84 Criteria partially met
Brown et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV enrolled in care, age ≥15 years Prospective cohort study 2014–2015 Kenya and Uganda 5683 Second 0.58 All criteria met
Bulage et al. (2017) Individuals living with HIV on ART, mostly aged 35+ years Cross‐sectional study 2014–2015 Uganda 100,678 Third 0.74 All criteria met
Burgos‐Soto et al. (2020) Individuals aged 15–69 years Household‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2016 Uganda 1738 First, second and third 0.86, 0.97 and 0.86 All criteria met
Charurat et al. (2015) MSM living with HIV, age ≥16 years Prospective cohort study 2013–2014 Nigeria 186 Second 0.31 All criteria met
Cherutich et al. (2016) Individuals living with HIV, age 15–64 years Cross‐sectional study 2012–2013 Kenya 617 Third 0.72 All criteria met
Chikandiwa et al. (2019) Men living with HIV, age ≥18 years Prospective cohort study 2011–2012 South Africa 304 Third 0.82 Criteria partially met
Chikandiwa et al. (2020) Men living with HIV, age ≥18 years Prospective cohort study 2012–2013 South Africa 304 Second 0.59 All criteria met
Chimukangara et al. (2017) Individuals living with HIV on ART, median age 43 years (95% CI 39–44 years) Cross‐sectional study 2014 Zimbabwe 143 Third 0.95 Criteria partially met
Colombe et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV, median age 36 years (IQR 27–46 years) Community‐based prospective cohort study 2006–2016 Tanzania 175 First 0.82 Criteria partially met
Conan et al. (2020) Individuals age ≥15 years old Population‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2016 Zimbabwe 4979 First, second and third 0.80, 0.74 and 0.65 Criteria partially met
Cornell et al. (2017) Individuals living with HIV Prospective cohort study 2004–2015 South Africa 72,812 Third 0.83 Criteria partially met
Crowell et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV, median age 35.7 years (IQR 29.7–42.7) years Retrospective cohort study 2013–2019 Uganda, Kenya, Tanzania and Nigeria 972 Second 0.18 Criteria partially met
Czaicki et al. (2014) Individuals age ≥16 years Prospective cohort study 2011–2012 Zambia 21,612 Second 0.16 All criteria met
De Anda et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV, age ≥18 years old Cross‐sectional study 2015–2016 Kenya 1136 First 0.18 Criteria partially met
Desta et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV, age ≥15 years Retrospective cross‐sectional study 2015–2019 Ethiopia 19,525 Third 0.7 All criteria met
Dokubo et al. (2014) Individuals living with HIV, age 15–49 years Cross‐sectional study 2009 Mozambique 1182 First 0.31 All criteria met
Dorward et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age >15 years Retrospective cohort study 2016–2019 South Africa 4952 Third 0.93 All criteria met
Fearon et al. (2020) MSM and transgender individuals, age ≥18 years Cross‐sectional study 2017 South Africa 301 First, second and third 0.64, 0.51 and 0.74 Criteria partially met
Fentie Wendie et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥15 years old Retrospective cohort study 2018–2019 Ethiopia 384 Third 0.82 All criteria met
Fogel et al. (2019) MSM and transgender women (TGW) who have sex with men, age 18–44 years Prospective cohort study 2015–2016 Kenya, Malawi and South Africa 183 First 0.56 All criteria met
Foley et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, median age 32 years (IQR 26–40) years Prospective cohort study Uganda 657 Third 0.85 Criteria partially met
Fonner et al. (2019) Individuals age ≥18 years old Cross‐sectional study 2006 Tanzania 644 First 0.32 All criteria met
Genberg et al. (2015) Individuals living with HIV enrolled in care, median age 36 years (IQR 30–45 years) Retrospective cohort study 2004–2014 Kenya 3482 First 0.54 All criteria met
Grobler et al. (2017) Individuals aged 15–49 years Household‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2014–2015 South Africa 9812 First, second and third 0.50, 0.66 and 0.86 All criteria met
Gumede et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on second‐line ART mostly 25+ years Prospective cohort study 2014–2015 South Africa 825 Third 0.78 Criteria partially met
Gumede et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on second‐line ART, median age 42 years (IQR 36–47 years) Cross‐sectional study 2018 South Africa 149 Third 0.59 All criteria met
Gunda et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on second‐line ART, median age 48 years (IQR 41–54 years) Unmatched case–control study 2017–2018 Tanzania 197 Third 0.82 Criteria partially met
Gupta‐Wright et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥18 years Observational cohort study 2015–2017 Malawi 1316 Third 0.62 Criteria partially met
Haachambwa et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV, age ≥18 years Prospective cohort study 2017–2018 Zambia 239 Second and third 0.49 and 0.74 Criteria partially met
Hailu et al. (2018) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age 10–63 years Retrospective cohort study 2008–2016 Ethiopia 260 Third 0.82 Criteria partially met
Hakim et al. (2018) MSM and TGW, age ≥18 years Cross‐sectional study 2014–2015 Mali 552 First 0.34 Criteria partially met
Hakim et al. (2019) Individuals age ≥13 years Cross‐sectional study 2011–2013 Uganda 12,233 First 0.33 All criteria met
Halle et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV aged 22–82 years Retrospective cohort study 2007–2013 Cameroon 156 Second 0.64 All criteria met
Hansoti et al. (2019) Individuals mostly aged 20+ years Cross‐sectional study 2017–2018 South Africa 2901 First, second and third 0.59, 0.58 and 0.43 Criteria partially met
Hansoti et al. (2019) Individuals mostly aged 20+ years Cross‐sectional serosurvey study 2016 South Africa 2100 Second 0.55 Criteria partially met
Hassan et al. (2014) Individuals living with HIV on ART, median age 38.5 years (IQR 32.2–44.8 years) Cross‐sectional study 2008–2011 Kenya 232 Third 0.78 All criteria met
Hayes et al. (2017) Individuals age ≥18 years Cluster randomized trial 2013–2015 Zambia 121,130 Second 0.47 Criteria partially met
Hayes et al. (2019) Individuals aged 18–44 years Community‐randomized trial 2013–2018 Zambia and South Africa 48,301 Third 0.54 All criteria met
Hensen et al. (2015) Men aged 15–60 years Cluster randomized stepped‐wedge trial 2011–2012 Zambia 2828 First 0.43 All criteria met
Herce et al. (2018) MSM, TGW, and female sex workers (FSW), mostly >25 years Cross‐sectional study 2016–2017 Malawi and Angola 1924 First 0.18 All criteria met
Hermans et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on first‐line ART, median age 35.7 years (IQR 29.9–43.0 years) Retrospective cohort study 2007–2018 South Africa 104,719 Third 0.78 All criteria met
Hirasen et al. (2018) Individuals living with HIV initiated on first‐line ART, median age 37.8 years (IQR 31.7–45.0 years) Retrospective cohort study 2011–2015 South Africa 3151 Third 0.75 Criteria partially met
Hirasen et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥18 years Prospective cohort study 2014–2017 South Africa 2410 Third 0.83 Criteria partially met
Hladik et al. (2017) MSM with median age 23 years (IQR 21–26 years) Cross‐sectional study 2012–2013 Uganda 608 First 0.2 Criteria partially met
Holland et al. (2016) MSM and FSW, age ≥18 years Prospective cohort study 2013 Burkina Faso and Togo 2738 Second 0.45 Criteria partially met
Huerga et al. (2017) Individuals aged 15–59 years Cross‐sectional survey study 2013 South Africa 5649 Third 0.85 All criteria met
Huerga et al. (2018) Individuals aged 15–59 years Cross‐sectional study 2013 South Africa 5649 First and second 0.68 and 0.68 Criteria partially met
Iwuji et al. (2016) Individuals aged ≥16 years Cluster‐randomized trial 2012–2014 South Africa 9927 First 0.7 Criteria partially met
Jean et al. (2016) Individuals aged 18–49 years Cross‐sectional survey study 2012 South Africa 6766 Second 0.43 All criteria met
Joram et al. (2017) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age 2–80 years Retrospective cohort study 2013–2014 Kenya 1859 Third 0.43 All criteria met
Joseph Davey et al. (2018) Individuals living with HIV initiated on first‐line ART, median age 37.8 years (IQR 31.7–45.0 years) Retrospective cohort study 2004–2016 South Africa 244,370 Third 0.82 Criteria partially met
Kagaayi et al. (2019) Individuals aged 15–49 years Population‐based prospective cohort study 2016–2017 Uganda 8942 Second 0.78 Criteria partially met
Kenyon et al. (2015) Individuals living with HIV, age 15–59 years Cross‐sectional study 2011 Uganda 1495 First 0.35 All criteria met
Keshinro et al. (2017) Individuals living with HIV on first‐line ART, age ≥18 years Cross‐sectional study 2012 Nigeria 325 Third 0.88 All criteria met
Kharsany et al. (2018) Individuals aged 15–49 years Cross‐sectional survey study 2014–2015 South Africa 9812 Third 0.83 Criteria partially met
Kharsany et al. (2019) Individuals aged 15–49 years Community‐based longitudinal study 2014–2015 South Africa 20,048 First and second 0.55 and 0.72 All criteria met
Kityo et al. (2014) Individuals living with HIV on ART, mostly aged 30+ years Open randomized trial 2003–2009 Uganda and Zimbabwe 1896 Third 0.81 Criteria partially met
Kiweewa et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV, age ≥18 years Prospective cohort study 2013–2017 Nigeria, Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania 2054 Third 0.91 Criteria partially met
Kufa et al. (2018) Individuals, median age 26 years (IQR 23–32 years) Cross‐sectional study 2017–2018 South Africa 1054 First 0.32 Criteria partially met
Kunzweiler et al. (2018) MSM living with HIV, median age 27 years (IQR 22–32 years) Prospective cohort study 2015–2016 Kenya 63 Third 0.71 Criteria partially met
Lahuerta et al. (2018) MSM, age ≥18 years Cross‐sectional study 2014–2015 Kenya, Mozambique, Rwanda and Tanzania 552 First 0.1 All criteria met
Lane et al. (2014) MSM, age ≥18 years Cross‐sectional study 2012–2013 South Africa 605 First 0.23 All criteria met
Lewis et al. (2019) Individuals aged 15–49 years Cross‐sectional study 2015–2016 South Africa 10,236 First 0.62 Criteria partially met
Liégeois et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on ART, median age 41 years (IQR 35–49 years) Cross‐sectional study 2014 Cameroon 1700 Third 0.82 All criteria met
Lippman et al. (2016) Individuals aged 18–49 years Population‐based household cross‐sectional survey study 2014 South Africa 1044 First and second 0.48 and 0.33 All criteria met
Lyons et al. (2017) MSM and FSW, mostly aged 25+ years Prospective cohort study 2013–2016 Senegal 1482 First, second and third 0.13, 0.76 and 0.64 Criteria partially met
MacKellar et al. (2019) Individuals aged 18–49 years Prospective longitudinal cohort study 2014–2017 Tanzania 5067 Second 0.23 All criteria met
Mafigiri et al. (2017) Individuals aged 15–24 years Cross‐sectional study 2013–2014 Uganda 792 Second 0.07 Criteria partially met
Maina et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥18 years Retrospective cohort study 2017–2019 Kenya 549 Third 0.5 All criteria met
Maman et al. (2015) Individuals aged 15–59 years Population‐based cross‐sectional study 2012 Kenya 6076 First 0.55 All criteria met
Maman et al. (2016) Individuals aged 15–59 years Retrospective nested cohort study 2013 Malawi 7270 First 0.66 All criteria met
Manne‐Goehler et al. (2019) Individuals age ≥40 years Prospective longitudinal cohort study 2014–2015 South Africa 4560 Second 0.47 Criteria partially met
Marinda et al. (2020) Individuals age ≥15 years Population‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2017–2018 South Africa 36,627 First, second and third 0.78, 0.68 and 0.82 Criteria partially met
Mbengue et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥18 years Prospective cohort study 2012–2014 South Africa 353 Third 0.53 All criteria met
Mekuria et al. (2016) Individuals living with HIV on ART, mean age 37.7 years (SD 9.3 years) Prospective cohort study 2009–2013 Ethiopia 642 Third 0.92 All criteria met
Merrill et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age 15–24 years Cross‐sectional study 2017–2018 Zambia 272 Third 0.59 Criteria partially met
Meshesha et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on first‐line ART, age of cases and controls was 31.6 years (SD ±10.72) and 36.6 years (SD±9.48), respectively Unmatched case–control study 2016–2018 Ethiopia 389 Third 0.66 All criteria met
Mogosetsi et al. (2018) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥21 years Prospective cohort study 2012–2013 South Africa 98 Third 0.97 All criteria met
Mokhele et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥18 years Retrospective cohort study 2004–2014 South Africa 3685 Third 0.53 Criteria partially met
Moyo et al. (2016) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥18 years Retrospective cohort study 2007–2012 South Africa 13,475 Third 0.91 All criteria met
Mshweshwe‐Pakela et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV, mostly age ≥30 years Retrospective clinical review 2017 South Africa 826 Third 0.77 Criteria partially met
Muraguri et al. (2015) MSM, age ≥18 years Cross‐sectional study 2010 Kenya 563 First 0.34 Criteria partially met
Nakanyala et al. (2016) Individuals, age ≥15 years Cross‐sectional study 2014–2015 Namibia 2163 First, second and third 0.41, 0.31 and 0.79 Criteria partially met
Ndagijimana et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on ART, median age 34 years (IQR 27–41 years) Retrospective cohort study 2012–2015 Rwanda 775 Third 0.82 All criteria met
Nega et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on first‐line ART, age ≥10 years Hospital‐based cross‐sectional study 2018–2019 Ethiopia 295 Third 0.83 All criteria met
Negash et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age 5–78 years Hospital‐based cross‐sectional study 2019 Ethiopia 393 Third 0.85 Criteria partially met
Ng'ang'a et al. (2014) Individuals aged 15–64 years Population‐based cross‐sectional study 2012–2013 Kenya 13,720 First 0.38 All criteria met
Nnambalirwa et al. (2016) Individuals living with HIV on first‐line ART, median age 36.7 years (IQR 31.5–43.3 years) Retrospective cohort study 2004–2011 South Africa 11,724 Third 0.84 All criteria met
Novitsky et al. (2015) Individuals aged 16–64 years Community‐based open prospective cohort study 2010–2013 Botswana 6238 First 0.66 Criteria partially met
Novitsky et al. (2018) Individuals living with HIV aged 16–29 years Population‐based cross‐sectional study 2013–2015 Botswana 552 First, second and third 0.87, 0.90 and 0.95 Criteria partially met
Nsanzimana et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on second‐line ART, median age 41 years (IQR 33–49 years) Retrospective observational cohort study 2004–2016 Rwanda 1688 Third 0.79 All criteria met
Nuwagaba‐Biribonwoha et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV, age ≥18 years Cross‐sectional study 2013–2014 South Africa 2196 First 0.09 Criteria partially met
Omooja et al. (2019) Individuals living with HIV on ART, median age 36 years (IQR 30–44 years) Cross‐sectional study 2016–2017 Uganda 1169 Third 0.91 Criteria partially met
Ondoa et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, mostly age ≥25 years Prospective cohort study 2008–2015 Kenya, South Africa, Zambia, Nigeria, Zimbabwe and Uganda 2420 Third 0.87 Criteria partially met
Petersen et al. (2017) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥15 years Cross‐sectional study 2013–2014 to 2015–2016 Kenya and Uganda 77,774 Third 0.87 All criteria met
Pulerwitz et al. (2019) Individuals aged 18–49 years Population‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2014 South Africa 2019 Second 0.79 All criteria met
Ramadhani et al. (2018) MSM, age ≥16 years Community‐based prospective cohort study 2013–2017 Nigeria 1506 First, second and third 0.58, 0.37 and 0.71 Criteria partially met
Reynolds et al. (2018) Men aged 20–34 years Cross‐sectional study 2016–2017 Swaziland 568 Second 0.96 All criteria met
Rhead et al. (2019) Men aged 15–54 years Cross‐sectional survey study 2012–2013 Zimbabwe 3116 First and second 0.47 and 0.77 Criteria partially met
Riedel et al. (2018) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age 14–86 years Retrospective cohort study 2008–2010 Rwanda 531 Third 0.93 All criteria met
Rohr et al. (2017) Individuals age ≥40 years Open cohort general‐population survey study 2014–2015 South Africa 4560 First 0.55 All criteria met
Ross et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, age ≥15 years Cross‐sectional study 2018 Rwanda 12,238 Third 0.91 All criteria met
Shanaube et al. (2017) Individuals age ≥18 years Community‐randomized trial 2013–2015 Zambia 101,102 First 0.59 All criteria met
Ssemwanga et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on first‐line ART Clinic‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2017 Uganda 1611 Third 0.93 All criteria met
Steiner et al. (2020) Individuals age 18–49 years Population‐based pre‐post cross‐sectional survey study 2013–2014 Tanzania 5067 Second 0.22 All criteria met
Thin et al. (2019) Individuals age 15–59 years Household‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2016–2017 Lesotho 11,682 First, second and third 0.77, 0.77 and 0.92 Criteria partially met
Twahirwa Rwema et al. (2020) MSM and TGW age ≥ 18 years Cross‐sectional bio‐behavioural survey study 2018 Rwanda 736 First, second and third 0.61, 0.98 and 0.75 All criteria met
Umar et al. (2019) Adolescents and young adults living with HIV on ART, aged 13–24 years Cross‐sectional study 2016 Malawi 209 Third 0.53 All criteria met
Villa et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV on ART, median age 48 years (IQR 42–54 years) Prospective cohort study 2018 Ghana 333 Third 0.39 All criteria met
Wafula et al. (2014) Individuals living with HIV, age 15–64 years Population‐based household cross‐sectional survey study 2012–2013 Kenya 363 Second 0.67 All criteria met
Wirth et al. (2020) Individuals age 16–64 years Prospective longitudinal cohort study 2013–2018 Botswana 10,791 First, second and third 0.78, 0.70 and 0.96 Criteria partially met
Young et al. (2020) Individuals living with HIV, age 15–64 years Household‐based cross‐sectional survey study 2012 Kenya 648 First and second 0.44 and 0.85 Criteria partially met