Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 17;11(6):1019. doi: 10.3390/cells11061019

Table 1.

Main variables described in the reviewed clinical trials.

Cell Therapy Approach Cell Source Routes of Administration SCI Level/ASIA Grade SCI Phase Interventions Associated Tools for Evaluating Functioning and Motor/Sensory
Improvements
Clinically Significant Outcomes Statistically Significant Outcomes References
1 × 106
cells/kg
Autologous BM Intrathecal Cervical and Thoracic
AIS A
Sub-acute, Chronic No ASIA, BI, SSEP, MEP, NCV, MRI Improvement in bladder function, supportive walking and sitting No Pal et al., 2009
4 × 108 Autologous AD Intravenous Cervical and thoracolumbar
AIS A, B
Chronic No ASIA, SCIM, VAS, MRI, MEP, SEP improvement in
Self-care
SEP in 3 subjects and ASIA A to C in 1 subject Ra et al., 2011
7 × 105 to
1.2 × 106
Autologous BM Intrathecal Thoracic
AIS A
Acute and Sub acute Rehabilitation ASIA 5 Subjects changed from AIS A to C No Karamouzian et al., 2012
25 μL–8 × 105 cells/μL Autologous BM Intralesional Cervical
AIS A
Chronic No ASIA, RUV, EMG, PSSEP, MRI Improvement in
ASIA score, residual urine volume
ASIA score, residual urine volume Dai et al., 2013
1 × 108 cells
in 5 mL
Autologous BM Intralesional Cervical and thoraco
lumbar AIS A-, B, and C
Acute, Sub acute and Chronic No ASIA, BI, ASHWORT Benefits in AIS grading and score, bowel, and urinary function, reduction of pain, erectile dysfunction and hypertonia Not mentioned Jiang et al., 2013
2 × 106 cells/kg 1–8 monthly injections Autologous-BM Intrathecal Cervical and thoracic
AIS A and B
Chronic Rehabilitation ASIA, SSEP MRI, FIM Improvement of neurological and functional measures Motor and sensory improvement El-Kheir et al., 2014
2 doses (50 µL to 4 × 105 cells/μL) Allogenic UC Intralesional Thoraco
Lumbar
AIS A
Chronic Neurological rehabilitation ASIA, BI, MMS, MTS Significant and stable improvement in movement, self-care ability, and muscular tension; residue urine volume Strength of waist, abdomen, and lower limbs increased, excessive muscle tension decreased, and self-care ability Cheng et al., 2014
5 × 106 cells/cm3 Autologous BM Intralesional Thoraco
Lumbar
AIS A
Chronic Rehabilitation ASIS, SSEP, MRI, VAS, USD Improvement in urologic function, lower limb sensitivity and motor function, reduction in pain ASIA sensitivity and motor scores Mendonça et al., 2014
2 × 107 cells Autologous BM Intralesional Thoraco
Lumbar
AIS A
Chronic No ASIA, SSEP, MRI, SCIM, FIM, USD Improvement in sexual dysfunction, urinary bladder-filling sensation and sphincter control. Bowel regularity Larocca et al., 2016
2 or 3 injections
(1.2 × 106/kg)
Autologous BM Intrathecal Thoracic
AIS A
Sub-acute, Chronic No ASIA, MRI Not mentioned Not mentioned Satti et al., 2016
3–7 injections; 100 × 106 to 230 × 106 cells. additional dose (30 × 106 cells) after 3 months Autologous BM Intrathecal Thoracic
AIS A
Chronic Not mentioned ASIA, FIM, IANR-SCIFRS, BI, Ashworth, Geffner, VAS, MRI, USD Improvement in sensitivity and sphincter (urinary and bowel) control, infralesional motor activity, decreases in spasms and spasticity, improvement in sexual function Sphincter control, reduction of neuropathic pain and spasticity Vaquero, 2016
4 doses 3 × 107 cells day 1, 4, 7 and 10 months (120 × 106 total) Autologous BM Intrathecal Cervical and thoraco
Lumbar
AIS B, C or D
Chronic Not mentioned ASIA, FIM, IANR-SCIFRS, BI, Ashworth, Geffner, VAS, MRI, USD Sensitivity and motor improvement, reduction of pain Sensitivity and motor improvement Vaquero et al., 2017
3 doses 100 × 106 (1, 4 e 7 months) Autologous BM Intrathecal Cervical, thoracic and lumbar
AIS A, B, C and D
Chronic Not mentioned ASIA, FIM, IANR- SCIFRS, BI, Ashworth, Geffner, VAS, MRI, USD Improvement in sensitivity, in neurogenic bowel and bladder dysfunction, spasms and spasticity, neuropathic pain, and voluntary muscle contraction Pin prick score assessment, improvements in the syrinx size Vaquero et al., 2018
(9 × 107 céls) Autologous AD Intrathecal Cervical and thoraco
Lumbar
AIS A, B, D
Sub-acute, Chronic Not mentioned ASIA, MRI, EMG, SSEP, MEP Improvement in ASIA motor score, Voluntary anal contraction improvement Not mentioned Hur et al., 2016
2 doses: 1.6 × 107 + 3.2 × 107 Autologous BM Intralesional/subdural Cervical
AIS B
Chronic Rehabilitation MEP, SEP, MRI Improvement in motor grade of the upper extremities and ADL; Increases in spinal cord diameter; disappearance of the cavity; SEP and MEP improvements Not mentioned Oh et al., 2016
5 × 107 Autologous BM and SC Intrathecal Cervical, thoracic and lumbar
AIS A
Subacute Rehabilitation ASIA, SCIM-III, EMG, NCV, MRI, UDS Recovery of trunk movement and equilibrium in standing/sitting positions, reduction in the severity of constipation,
sensation of the filling bladder, voiding.
Score Sensory (pinprick and light touch); SCIM III total score respiration and sphincter management, mobility, and self-care; Oraee-Yazdani 2021
5 × 107/kg Allogenic UC Subarachnoid Cervical, thoracic, thoracolumbar
ASIA A-D
Chronic ASIA, IANR-SCIFRS, MRI Penn scale, Geffner, Neurogenic Bowel Dysfunction score, RUV Improvements of pinprick,
light touch, motor and sphincter scores. Decrease in muscle spasticity
Improvements in muscle spasm, autonomic system, bladder and bowel functions, RUV and
MRI
Yang et al., 2020

AD = adipose; ASIA = American Spinal Injury Association; AIS = America International Spinal Injury Scale; BI = Barthel’s index; BM = bone marrow; EMG = electromyography; FIM = functional independence measure; IANR-SCIFRS = International Association of Neurorestoratology—Spinal Cord Injury Functional Rating Scale; MEP = motor-evoked potentials; MRI = magnetic resonance imaging; MMS = manual muscle strength; MTS = muscle tension scale; NVC = nerve conduction velocity; PSSEP = paraspinal somatosensory evoked potential; RUV = residual urine volume; SCIM = spinal cord independence measure; SSEP = Somato-sensory evoked potentials; UC = umbilical cord; UDS = urodynamic study; VAS = Visual Analog Scale; SC = Schwann cells.