Table 1.
Cell Therapy Approach | Cell Source | Routes of Administration | SCI Level/ASIA Grade | SCI Phase | Interventions Associated | Tools for Evaluating Functioning and Motor/Sensory Improvements |
Clinically Significant Outcomes | Statistically Significant Outcomes | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 × 106 cells/kg |
Autologous BM | Intrathecal | Cervical and Thoracic AIS A |
Sub-acute, Chronic | No | ASIA, BI, SSEP, MEP, NCV, MRI | Improvement in bladder function, supportive walking and sitting | No | Pal et al., 2009 |
4 × 108 | Autologous AD | Intravenous | Cervical and thoracolumbar AIS A, B |
Chronic | No | ASIA, SCIM, VAS, MRI, MEP, SEP | improvement in Self-care |
SEP in 3 subjects and ASIA A to C in 1 subject | Ra et al., 2011 |
7 × 105 to 1.2 × 106 |
Autologous BM | Intrathecal | Thoracic AIS A |
Acute and Sub acute | Rehabilitation | ASIA | 5 Subjects changed from AIS A to C | No | Karamouzian et al., 2012 |
25 μL–8 × 105 cells/μL | Autologous BM | Intralesional | Cervical AIS A |
Chronic | No | ASIA, RUV, EMG, PSSEP, MRI | Improvement in ASIA score, residual urine volume |
ASIA score, residual urine volume | Dai et al., 2013 |
1 × 108 cells in 5 mL |
Autologous BM | Intralesional | Cervical and thoraco lumbar AIS A-, B, and C |
Acute, Sub acute and Chronic | No | ASIA, BI, ASHWORT | Benefits in AIS grading and score, bowel, and urinary function, reduction of pain, erectile dysfunction and hypertonia | Not mentioned | Jiang et al., 2013 |
2 × 106 cells/kg 1–8 monthly injections | Autologous-BM | Intrathecal | Cervical and thoracic AIS A and B |
Chronic | Rehabilitation | ASIA, SSEP MRI, FIM | Improvement of neurological and functional measures | Motor and sensory improvement | El-Kheir et al., 2014 |
2 doses (50 µL to 4 × 105 cells/μL) | Allogenic UC | Intralesional | Thoraco Lumbar AIS A |
Chronic | Neurological rehabilitation | ASIA, BI, MMS, MTS | Significant and stable improvement in movement, self-care ability, and muscular tension; residue urine volume | Strength of waist, abdomen, and lower limbs increased, excessive muscle tension decreased, and self-care ability | Cheng et al., 2014 |
5 × 106 cells/cm3 | Autologous BM | Intralesional | Thoraco Lumbar AIS A |
Chronic | Rehabilitation | ASIS, SSEP, MRI, VAS, USD | Improvement in urologic function, lower limb sensitivity and motor function, reduction in pain | ASIA sensitivity and motor scores | Mendonça et al., 2014 |
2 × 107 cells | Autologous BM | Intralesional | Thoraco Lumbar AIS A |
Chronic | No | ASIA, SSEP, MRI, SCIM, FIM, USD | Improvement in sexual dysfunction, urinary bladder-filling sensation and sphincter control. | Bowel regularity | Larocca et al., 2016 |
2 or 3 injections (1.2 × 106/kg) |
Autologous BM | Intrathecal | Thoracic AIS A |
Sub-acute, Chronic | No | ASIA, MRI | Not mentioned | Not mentioned | Satti et al., 2016 |
3–7 injections; 100 × 106 to 230 × 106 cells. additional dose (30 × 106 cells) after 3 months | Autologous BM | Intrathecal | Thoracic AIS A |
Chronic | Not mentioned | ASIA, FIM, IANR-SCIFRS, BI, Ashworth, Geffner, VAS, MRI, USD | Improvement in sensitivity and sphincter (urinary and bowel) control, infralesional motor activity, decreases in spasms and spasticity, improvement in sexual function | Sphincter control, reduction of neuropathic pain and spasticity | Vaquero, 2016 |
4 doses 3 × 107 cells day 1, 4, 7 and 10 months (120 × 106 total) | Autologous BM | Intrathecal | Cervical and thoraco Lumbar AIS B, C or D |
Chronic | Not mentioned | ASIA, FIM, IANR-SCIFRS, BI, Ashworth, Geffner, VAS, MRI, USD | Sensitivity and motor improvement, reduction of pain | Sensitivity and motor improvement | Vaquero et al., 2017 |
3 doses 100 × 106 (1, 4 e 7 months) | Autologous BM | Intrathecal | Cervical, thoracic and lumbar AIS A, B, C and D |
Chronic | Not mentioned | ASIA, FIM, IANR- SCIFRS, BI, Ashworth, Geffner, VAS, MRI, USD | Improvement in sensitivity, in neurogenic bowel and bladder dysfunction, spasms and spasticity, neuropathic pain, and voluntary muscle contraction | Pin prick score assessment, improvements in the syrinx size | Vaquero et al., 2018 |
(9 × 107 céls) | Autologous AD | Intrathecal | Cervical and thoraco Lumbar AIS A, B, D |
Sub-acute, Chronic | Not mentioned | ASIA, MRI, EMG, SSEP, MEP | Improvement in ASIA motor score, Voluntary anal contraction improvement | Not mentioned | Hur et al., 2016 |
2 doses: 1.6 × 107 + 3.2 × 107 | Autologous BM | Intralesional/subdural | Cervical AIS B |
Chronic | Rehabilitation | MEP, SEP, MRI | Improvement in motor grade of the upper extremities and ADL; Increases in spinal cord diameter; disappearance of the cavity; SEP and MEP improvements | Not mentioned | Oh et al., 2016 |
5 × 107 | Autologous BM and SC | Intrathecal | Cervical, thoracic and lumbar AIS A |
Subacute | Rehabilitation | ASIA, SCIM-III, EMG, NCV, MRI, UDS | Recovery of trunk movement and equilibrium in standing/sitting positions, reduction in the severity of constipation, sensation of the filling bladder, voiding. |
Score Sensory (pinprick and light touch); SCIM III total score respiration and sphincter management, mobility, and self-care; | Oraee-Yazdani 2021 |
5 × 107/kg | Allogenic UC | Subarachnoid | Cervical, thoracic, thoracolumbar ASIA A-D |
Chronic | ASIA, IANR-SCIFRS, MRI Penn scale, Geffner, Neurogenic Bowel Dysfunction score, RUV | Improvements of pinprick, light touch, motor and sphincter scores. Decrease in muscle spasticity |
Improvements in muscle spasm, autonomic system, bladder and bowel functions, RUV and MRI |
Yang et al., 2020 |
AD = adipose; ASIA = American Spinal Injury Association; AIS = America International Spinal Injury Scale; BI = Barthel’s index; BM = bone marrow; EMG = electromyography; FIM = functional independence measure; IANR-SCIFRS = International Association of Neurorestoratology—Spinal Cord Injury Functional Rating Scale; MEP = motor-evoked potentials; MRI = magnetic resonance imaging; MMS = manual muscle strength; MTS = muscle tension scale; NVC = nerve conduction velocity; PSSEP = paraspinal somatosensory evoked potential; RUV = residual urine volume; SCIM = spinal cord independence measure; SSEP = Somato-sensory evoked potentials; UC = umbilical cord; UDS = urodynamic study; VAS = Visual Analog Scale; SC = Schwann cells.