Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 12;12(3):696. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics12030696

Table 1.

Comparison between the proposed system and different machine learning classifiers using lung, hybrid, and lesion models.

Class Evaluation Overall Evaluation
Classifier Class Recall Precision F1-Score Overall Accuracy Kappa
Lung Model Random Forest [35] Healthy/Mild 80% 66.67% 72.73% 83.33% 73.98%
Moderate 81.82% 81.82% 81.82%
Severe 87.50% 100% 93.33%
Decision Trees [36] Healthy/Mild 80% 57.14% 66.67% 66.67% 48.8%
Moderate 63.64% 70% 66.67%
Severe 62.50% 71.43% 66.67%
Naive Bayes [37] Healthy/Mild 100% 41.67% 58.82% 54.17% 34.32%
Moderate 9.09% 50% 15.38%
Severe 87.50% 70% 77.78%
SVM [38] Healthy/Mild 100% 62.50% 76.92% 70.83% 56.92%
Moderate 45.45% 83.33% 58.82%
Severe 87.5% 70% 77.78%
KNN [39] Healthy/Mild 60% 75% 66.67% 79.17% 66.1%
Moderate 90.91% 71.43% 80%
Severe 75% 100% 85.71%
Proposed System Healthy/Mild 100% 100% 100% 95.83 % 93.39 %
Moderate 100% 91.67% 95.65%
Severe 87.50% 100% 93.33%
Hybrid Model Random Forest [35] Healthy/Mild 40% 66.67% 50% 75% 58.62%
Moderate 90.91% 66.67% 76.92%
Severe 75% 100% 85.71%
Decision Trees [36] Healthy/Mild 20% 50% 28.57% 62.50% 36.84%
Moderate 81.82% 56.25% 66.67%
Severe 62.50% 83.33% 71.43%
Naive Bayes [37] Healthy/Mild 80% 44.44% 57.14% 58.33% 39.39%
Moderate 27.27% 60% 37.50%
Severe 87.50% 70% 77.78%
SVM [38] Healthy/Mild 80% 80% 80% 70.83% 55.56%
Moderate 54.55% 85.71% 66.67%
Severe 87.5% 58.33% 70%
KNN [39] Healthy/Mild 60% 42.86% 50% 66.67% 49.2%
Moderate 54.55% 66.67% 60%
Severe 87.5% 87.5% 87.50%
Proposed System Healthy/Mild 100% 100% 100% 91.67 % 86.67 %
Moderate 100% 84.62% 91.67%
Severe 75% 100% 85.71%
Lesion Model Random Forest [35] Healthy/Mild 100% 100% 100% 87.5% 79.83%
Moderate 100% 78.57% 88%
Severe 62.5% 100% 76.92%
Decision Trees [36] Healthy/Mild 80% 100% 88.89% 79.17% 66.1%
Moderate 90.91% 71.43% 80%
Severe 62.5% 83.33% 71.43%
Naive Bayes [37] Healthy/Mild 100% 100% 100% 91.67% 87.1%
Moderate 81.82% 100% 90%
Severe 100% 80% 88.89%
SVM [38] Healthy/Mild 80% 100% 88.89% 79.17% 66.94%
Moderate 81.82% 75% 78.26%
Severe 75% 75% 75%
KNN [39] Healthy/Mild 100% 100% 100% 79.17% 67.48%
Moderate 72.73% 80% 76.19%
Severe 75% 66.67% 70.59%
Proposed System Healthy/Mild 100% 100% 100% 100 % 100 %
Moderate 100% 100% 100%
Severe 100% 100% 100%