Table 2.
Comparison of different biomarker types, along with the information they contain, the most widely used detection method and their advantages and disadvantages. Abbreviations: ccfDNA (circulating cell-free DNA); CTC (circulating tumor cells); ELISA (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay); EV (extracellular vesicle); FISH (fluorescence in-situ hybridization); IHC (immunohistochemistry); NGS (next-generation sequencing); qPCR (quantitative polymerase chain reaction); RNA-Seq (RNA sequencing); RT-qPCR (reverse transcription quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction).
| Type of Biomarker | Sample Type | Information | Detection Methods (i.a.) | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Proteins [16] |
Tissue biopsies | Expression pattern in tissue of interest | ELISA IHC Immunoblotting Flow Cytometry |
Direct mediators of cellular changes Well-established biomarkers and assays available |
Expensive antibody-based detection In most cases invasive sampling necessary |
| Liquid biopsies (body fluids): blood, urine, saliva, i.a. |
Systemic expression information | ELISA IHC Immunoblotting Flow Cytometry |
Direct mediators of cellular changes High-throughput methods available Minimal invasive sampling |
Expensive antibody-based detection Tissue of origin not determined |
|
| Intracellular RNA [15,66] |
Tissue biopsies | Expression pattern in tissue of interest | RT-qPCR RNA-Seq Microarrays FISH |
Expression-level analysis Detection of ncRNA |
In most cases invasive sampling necessary |
| Liquid biopsies: blood |
Systemic expression information | RT-qPCR RNA-Seq Microarrays |
Expression-level analysis Immunophenotyping Analysis of ncRNA Minimal invasive sampling |
Tissue of origin not determined Almost exclusively information about immune response |
|
| Extracellular RNA, e.g., EV-associated [15,67,68] |
Liquid biopsies (body fluids): blood, urine, saliva, i.a. |
Systemic expression information | RT-qPCR RNA-Seq Microarrays |
Semi-direct information Analysis of ncRNA Minimal invasive sampling |
Fragmented Relatively new (few biomarkers and assays established) Only partial transcriptome Tissue of origin not determined |
| Genomic DNA [8,69] |
Tissue biopsies | Mutations in the tissue of interest Epigenetic status in tissue of interest |
qPCR NGS |
Complete genome of the tissue of interest | Only indirect expression information available In most cases invasive sampling necessary |
| Liquid biopsies (body fluids): blood, urine, saliva, i.a. |
Mutations in the tissue of interest Epigenetic status in tissue of interest |
qPCR NGS |
Not limited to a certain tissue Minimal invasive sampling |
Only limited gene expression information No information about tissue of origin |
|
| ccfDNA [6,18,67,70] |
Liquid biopsies (body fluids): blood, urine, saliva, i.a. |
Mutations throughout the whole body | qPCR NGS |
Minimal invasive sampling | No expression information available Fragmented |
| CTCs [6,7,18] |
Liquid biopsies: blood, urine |
Metastatic tumor cells | Flow Cytometry (RT-)qPCR NGS |
Minimal invasive sampling Tumor DNA, RNA and proteins combined |
Less useful in later tumor stages Limited to tumor diagnosis |