TABLE III. Comparison of Capacity, PSNR, and SSIM for Medical Images.
Image | Scheme | Capacity (bits) | PSNR (dB) | SSIM |
---|---|---|---|---|
Image 1 | Proposed | 589824 | 41.944 | 0.9493 |
Loan et al., [23] | 589824 | 38.0816 | 0.9065 | |
Proposed | 196608 | 46.7701 | 0.9829 | |
Ahad et al., [24] | 196608 | 46.3685 | 0.9815 | |
Proposed | 38700 | 53.8437 | 0.9969 | |
GA scheme [22] | 38,700 | 49.011976 | 0.998578 | |
PSO scheme [22] | 38,390 | 49.004725 | 0.998566 | |
Luo et al., [17] | 36,060 | 48.946455 | 0.99858 | |
Lee et al., [25] | 10,882 | 48.420868 | 0.998843 | |
Image 2 | Proposed | 589824 | 41.98 | 0.9462 |
Loan et al., [23] | 589824 | 38.89 | 0.9077 | |
Proposed | 196608 | 46.7460 | 0.9815 | |
Ahad et al., [24] | 196608 | 46.3604 | 0.9878 | |
Proposed | 38700 | 53.7834 | 0.9965 | |
GA scheme [22] | 38700 | 49.011976 | 0.998578 | |
PSO scheme [22] | 38390 | 49.004725 | 0.998566 | |
Luo et al., [17] | 36060 | 48.946455 | 0.99858 | |
Lee et al., [25] | 10882 | 48.420868 | 0.998843 | |
Image 3 | Proposed | 589824 | 41.74 | 0.9509 |
Loan et al., [23] | 589824 | 38.35 | 0.9133 | |
Proposed | 196608 | 46.7550 | 0.9817 | |
Ahad et al., [24] | 196608 | 46.3694 | 0.9823 | |
Proposed | 38700 | 53.8762 | 0.9969 | |
GA scheme, [22] | 38700 | 49.011976 | 0.998578 | |
PSO scheme, [22] | 38390 | 49.004725 | 0.998566 | |
Luo et al. [17] | 36060 | 48.946455 | 0.99858 | |
Lee et al. [25] | 10,882 | 48.420868 | 0.998843 | |
Image 4 | Proposed | 589824 | 41.97 | 0.9672 |
Loan et al., [23] | 589824 | 38.33 | 0.9328 | |
Proposed | 196608 | 46.7611 | 0.9879 | |
Ahad et al., [24] | 196608 | 46.3713 | 0.9806 | |
Proposed | 38700 | 53.8202 | 0.9976 | |
GA scheme, [22] | 38700 | 49.011976 | 0.998578 | |
PSO scheme, [22] | 38390 | 49.004725 | 0.998566 | |
Luo et al. [17] | 36060 | 48.946455 | 0.99858 | |
Lee et al. [25] | 10882 | 48.420868 | 0.998843 | |
Image 6 | Proposed | 589824 | 41.99 | 0.9493 |
Loan et al., [23] | 589824 | 37.36 | 0.7198 | |
Image 7 | Proposed | 589824 | 41.96 | 0.9684 |
Loan et al., [23] | 589824 | 35.45 | 0.9352 |