TABLE 2.
Assays and their limitations for OS, antioxidant or free radical scavenger expression or activity in the LG, tear film or the ocular surface.
| Reference | Goal | Method | Detected Product | Specificity | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Morrison and Allen (1966) | Identify LPO in LG | Rabbit immune serum against LPO and electrophoresis | Immunoprecipitation in electrophoretic gel | Low | No quantification or cell localization |
| (Herzog and Miller 1972b) | Determine the location of endogenous peroxidase in acinar cells and fluid | Biochemistry and electron microscopy | Dark spots on electron microscopy and colorimetric assay with guaiacol and pyrogallol test | Low | Limited distinction among peroxidases and catalase activity |
| Herzog and Fahimi (1976) | Distinguish peroxidase and catalase in acinar cells | Optimum pH evaluation, glutaraldehyde activity to selectively inhibit catalase or peroxidase and electron microscopy | Peroxidase activity and dark spots in electron microscopy | Moderate | Limited distinction from other peroxidase enzymes |
| Herzog et al. (1976) | Measure the peroxidase release under pharmacologic modulation from the LG cells | Histological and biochemical response to α-adrenergic and muscarinic cholinergic stimulus | Location of dark spots in the acinar cells in vitro and measurement thereof in the tissue and in the supernatant by DAB colorimetric assay | Moderate | Limited distinction among peroxidases isoforms |
| De (1992) | Measure tissue peroxidase activity and confirm tissue location | Peroxidase purification from tissues and rabbit antiserum anti peroxidase production for western blotting | Comparative enzymatic tissue assays and tissue presence confirmation | Moderate | Potential cross-reaction on western blotting analysis and enzymatic assays |
| Rios et al. (2005) | Compare LG peroxidase activity as biomarker of DE | Colorimetric assay to obtain peroxidase activity in LG tissues | Colorimetric assay of peroxidase activity | Moderate | Limited distinction among peroxidases isoforms |
| Jee et al. (2014) | Measure antioxidant enzymes in the tear film | Luminex: magnetic bead-based immunoassay | Catalase and SOD in tear secretion | High | Amount of tear sample and external contamination |
| Sakai et al. (2015) | Observe the conjunctiva cell culture in the absence of specific antioxidant enzymes | Knockdown of antioxidant enzymes with small interfering RNA | Lipid oxidation and ROS measured by LDH method | High | Immortalized cells in culture have limited compensatory mechanisms |
| Soria et al. (2017) | Comparative expression of peroxidase and other tear film contents in different diseases | Liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry and quantitative analysis with spectral APEX proteomics | Identification and quantification of enzymatic Redox markers in the tears | High | Tear volume availability and collection method |
DAB: 3-3 diaminobenzidine tetrahydrochloride; LDH: lactate dehydrogenase.