Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 11;10:824726. doi: 10.3389/fcell.2022.824726

TABLE 2.

Assays and their limitations for OS, antioxidant or free radical scavenger expression or activity in the LG, tear film or the ocular surface.

Reference Goal Method Detected Product Specificity Limitations
Morrison and Allen (1966) Identify LPO in LG Rabbit immune serum against LPO and electrophoresis Immunoprecipitation in electrophoretic gel Low No quantification or cell localization
(Herzog and Miller 1972b) Determine the location of endogenous peroxidase in acinar cells and fluid Biochemistry and electron microscopy Dark spots on electron microscopy and colorimetric assay with guaiacol and pyrogallol test Low Limited distinction among peroxidases and catalase activity
Herzog and Fahimi (1976) Distinguish peroxidase and catalase in acinar cells Optimum pH evaluation, glutaraldehyde activity to selectively inhibit catalase or peroxidase and electron microscopy Peroxidase activity and dark spots in electron microscopy Moderate Limited distinction from other peroxidase enzymes
Herzog et al. (1976) Measure the peroxidase release under pharmacologic modulation from the LG cells Histological and biochemical response to α-adrenergic and muscarinic cholinergic stimulus Location of dark spots in the acinar cells in vitro and measurement thereof in the tissue and in the supernatant by DAB colorimetric assay Moderate Limited distinction among peroxidases isoforms
De (1992) Measure tissue peroxidase activity and confirm tissue location Peroxidase purification from tissues and rabbit antiserum anti peroxidase production for western blotting Comparative enzymatic tissue assays and tissue presence confirmation Moderate Potential cross-reaction on western blotting analysis and enzymatic assays
Rios et al. (2005) Compare LG peroxidase activity as biomarker of DE Colorimetric assay to obtain peroxidase activity in LG tissues Colorimetric assay of peroxidase activity Moderate Limited distinction among peroxidases isoforms
Jee et al. (2014) Measure antioxidant enzymes in the tear film Luminex: magnetic bead-based immunoassay Catalase and SOD in tear secretion High Amount of tear sample and external contamination
Sakai et al. (2015) Observe the conjunctiva cell culture in the absence of specific antioxidant enzymes Knockdown of antioxidant enzymes with small interfering RNA Lipid oxidation and ROS measured by LDH method High Immortalized cells in culture have limited compensatory mechanisms
Soria et al. (2017) Comparative expression of peroxidase and other tear film contents in different diseases Liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry and quantitative analysis with spectral APEX proteomics Identification and quantification of enzymatic Redox markers in the tears High Tear volume availability and collection method

DAB: 3-3 diaminobenzidine tetrahydrochloride; LDH: lactate dehydrogenase.