Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 16;12:845549. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2022.845549

Table 3.

Included studies details.

First author Year Elastography Estimate of sensitivity Estimates of specificity Prospective Retrospective
Chong Y. (28) 2013 qualitative USE 66% 75% x
semi-quantitative USE 66% 54%
Cantisani V. (29) 2013 semi-quantitative USE 93% 92% x
Refaat R. (30) 2014 qualitative USE 79% 81% x
semi-quantitative USE 86% 90%
Tatar I.G. (31) 2014 semi-quantitative USE 100% 76% x
Grazhdani H. (32) 2014 quantitative USE 91% 75% x
Mona A. (33) 2014 semi-quantitative USE 88% 86% x
Jun-Mei X. (34) 2014 qualitative USE 74% 91% x
quantitative USE 68% 77%
Cakir B. (35) 2014 semi-quantitative USE 99% 96% x
Bederina E.L. (36) 2014 qualitative USE 95% 98% x
Erman Çakal. (37) 2014 qualitative USE 76% 96% x
semi-quantitative USE 83 95
Cantisani V. (38) 2015 semi-quantitative USE 92% 93% x
Huang X. (39) 2015 qualitative USE 74% 90% x
quantitative USE 82% 77%
quantitative USE 74% 90%
Azizi G. (40) 2015 quantitative USE 79% 72% x
Cetin N. (41) 2015 semi-quantitative USE 56% 86% x
qualitative USE 75% 81%
Dobruch-Sobczak K. (42) 2016 quantitative USE 60% 70% x
Duan S.B. (43) 2016 quantitative USE 84% 78% x
Friedrich-Rust M. (44) 2016 qualitative USE 56% 81% x
semi-quantitative USE 58% 78%
Ping X. (45) 2016 quantitative USE 81%, 74% x
Seong M. (46) 2016 qualitative USE 29% 77% x
semi-quantitative USE 50% 57%
Chen B.D. (47) 2016 quantitative USE 85% 87% x
Ahmed E.E. (48) 2017 qualitative USE 83% 91%, x
Mohammed M.D. (49) 2017 qualitative USE 94% 77% x
Liu B.J. (50) 2017 quantitative USE 77% 80% x
Liu Z. (51) 2017 quantitative USE 81% 83% x
Wang D. (52) 2017 quantitative USE 70% 81% x
Kyriakidou G. (53) 2018 qualitative USE 73% 73% x
quantitative USE 91% 79%
quantitative USE 73% 67%
Wahab S. (54) 2018 qualitative USE 97% 83% x
Cantisani V. (55) 2019 semi-quantitative USE 83% 93% x
quantitative USE 67% 83%
Huang Y. (56) 2019 qualitative USE 80% 57% x
 Yang Q. (57) 2019 quantitative USE 73% 85% x
semi-quantitative USE 82% 88%
Aghaghazvini L. (58) 2020 quantitative USE 90% 79% x
Li H. (59) 2020 qualitative USE 92% 61% x
semi-quantitative USE 81% 50%
Huang S.T. (60) 2020 quantitative USE 69% 91% x
Goel S. (61) 2020 quantitative USE 75%, 96% x
Shufang P. (62) 2020 qualitative USE 74% 81% x
qualitative USE 90% 92%
qualitative USE 94% 94%
qualitative USE 79% 96%
Yavuz A. (63) 2020 quantitative USE 81% 94% x
Jinru Y. (64) 2017 qualitative USE 90% 86% x
semi-quantitative USE 90% 93%
Yeon E.K. (65) 2020 quantitative USE 93% 30% x
Tuan P.A. (66) 2020 quantitative USE 74% 90% x
Hu L. (67) 2021 quantitative USE 77% 65% x
Cantisani V. (68) 2012 semi-quantitative USE 97% 92% x
Cantisani V. (69) 2013 semi-quantitative USE 93% 89% x
Sohail S. (70) 2020 quantitative USE 81% 92% x
Idrees A. (71) 2020 semi-quantitative USE 90% 90% x
Liao L.J. (72) 2019 qualitative USE 81% 70% x
quantitative USE 81% 65%
Fukuhara T. (73) 2018 qualitative USE 64% 66% x
quantitative USE 80% 86%
Wojtaszek-Nowicka M. (74) 2017 semi-quantitative USE 86% 88% x
Kim H. (75) 2013 quantitative USE 67% 72% x
Wang H. (76) 2013 qualitative USE 85% 78% x
semi-quantitative USE 81% 91%
Wang H.L. (77) 2012 qualitative USE 78% 80% x
semi-quantitative USE 88% 92%
Veyrieres J.B. (78) 2012 quantitative USE 80% 90% x
Ning C.P. (79) 2012 qualitative USE 81% 72% x
semi-quantitative USE 81% 84%
Cakir B. (80) 2011 qualitative USE 58% 71% x
Hakan B. (81) 2021 quantitative USE 96% 95% x
Chen M. (82) 2016 quantitative USE 85% 84% x
Liu B.X. (83) 2014 qualitative USE 79% 84% x
quantitative USE 68% 87%

USE, Ultrasound Elastography.