Table 3.
Optimization results of MPCE-SSALS with different combinations of parameters INPD and IGS (with Wilcoxon test, α = 0.05).
| Fun | I NPD = 100, IGS = 40 | I NPD = 50, IGS = 40 | I NPD = 200, IGS = 40 | I NPD = 100, IGS = 20 | I NPD = 100, IGS = 80 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| f1 | 1.53E − 27 | = | 5.95E − 28 | = | 1.22E − 27 | = | 5.78E − 28 | = | 2.15E − 27 |
| f2 | 1.35E + 00 | = | 4.98E − 01 | = | 3.48E + 00 | = | 1.09E + 00 | = | 1.31E + 00 |
| f3 | 3.59E − 13 | > | 3.80E − 13 | = | 3.61E − 13 | = | 3.62E − 13 | = | 3.67E − 13 |
| f4 | 3.56E + 09 | = | 3.14E + 09 | > | 5.12E + 09 | = | 3.83E + 09 | = | 3.41E + 09 |
| f5 | 1.18E + 06 | > | 1.43E + 06 | = | 1.20E + 06 | = | 1.17E + 06 | > | 1.51E + 06 |
| f6 | 7.46E + 02 | > | 5.36E + 03 | < | 3.52E + 02 | = | 7.15E + 02 | > | 4.93E + 03 |
| f7 | 4.39E + 03 | = | 3.97E + 03 | > | 1.31E + 04 | = | 5.46E + 03 | = | 5.61E + 03 |
| f8 | 1.84E + 14 | = | 1.58E + 14 | = | 1.91E + 14 | = | 1.74E + 14 | = | 1.58E + 14 |
| f9 | 9.02E + 07 | > | 1.13E + 08 | = | 8.83E + 07 | = | 8.47E + 07 | > | 1.11E + 08 |
| f10 | 4.98E + 04 | > | 1.42E + 05 | < | 2.08E + 04 | = | 4.03E + 04 | = | 8.12E + 04 |
| f11 | 3.32E + 06 | = | 1.25E + 06 | > | 6.65E + 06 | = | 4.61E + 06 | = | 5.06E + 06 |
| f12 | 5.85E + 01 | < | 3.20E + 01 | > | 2.71E + 02 | > | 1.45E + 02 | = | 6.90E + 01 |
| f13 | 3.56E + 06 | = | 2.06E + 06 | > | 1.09E + 07 | = | 2.34E + 06 | = | 4.06E + 06 |
| f14 | 5.46E + 06 | = | 5.30E + 06 | > | 7.70E + 06 | = | 5.45E + 06 | = | 5.47E + 06 |
| f15 | 5.80E + 05 | = | 5.55E + 05 | > | 7.01E + 05 | > | 6.19E + 05 | = | 6.01E + 05 |
| w/t/l | — | 5/9/1 | 7/6/2 | 2/13/0 | 3/12/0 | ||||