Table 2.
Intention-to-treat analysis |
Per protocol analysis |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Malaria prevalence | aOR (95% CI)* | p value† | Malaria prevalence | aOR (95% CI)* | p value† | |
Pyrethroid-only group | ||||||
12 months | 350/1123 (31·2%) | 1 (ref) | .. | 203/676 (30·0%) | 1 (ref) | .. |
18 months | 642/1227 (52·3%) | 1 (ref) | .. | 330/651 (50·7%) | 1 (ref) | .. |
24 months | 549/1199 (45·8%) | 1 (ref) | .. | 250/569 (43·9%) | 1 (ref) | .. |
Pyriproxyfen group | ||||||
12 months | 232/1069 (21·7%) | 0·69 (0·48–1·04) | 0·0754 | 120/621 (19·3%) | 0·59 (0·37–0·95) | 0·0286 |
18 months | 583/1153 (50·6%) | 0·98 (0·67–1·44) | 0·9184 | 245/541 (45·3%) | 0·81 (0·52–1·27) | 0·3628 |
24 months | 472/1258 (37·5%) | 0·79 (0·54–1·17) | 0·2354 | 151/441 (34·2%) | 0·71 (0·45–1·13) | 0·1510 |
Chlorfenapyr group | ||||||
12 months | 176/1126 (15·6%) | 0·47 (0·31–0·71) | 0·0003 | 108/716 (15·1%) | 0·45 (0·28–0·72) | 0·0009 |
18 months | 509/1246 (40·9%) | 0·66 (0·45–0·97) | 0·0365 | 254/656 (38·7%) | 0·63 (0·40–0·97) | 0·0382 |
24 months | 326/1272 (25·6%) | 0·45 (0·30–0·67) | 0·0001 | 131/598 (21·9%) | 0·39 (0·25–0·63) | 0·0001 |
Piperonyl butoxide group | ||||||
12 months | 206/1071 (19·2%) | 0·65 (0·44–0·99) | 0·0421 | 128/627 (20·4%) | 0·77 (0·49–1·22) | 0·2697 |
18 months | 502/1160 (43·3%) | 0·76 (0·52–1·12) | 0·1699 | 192/469 (40·9%) | 0·71 (0·45–1·11) | 0·1334 |
24 months | 512/1259 (40·7%) | 0·99 (0·67–1·45) | 0·9607 | 139/356 (39·0%) | 0·97 (0·60–1·55) | 0·8891 |
Prevalence data are n/N (%). For time-by-study group interaction, pinteraction=0·0738 in intention-to-treat analysis and pinteraction=0·2267 in per protocol analysis. Each intervention group is compared against the pyrethroid-only group for the same timepoint. aOR=adjusted odds ratio.
Adjusted for baseline cluster-level variables used in restricted randomisation.
p<0·017 was considered statistically significant after Bonferroni correction.