Table 3.
Typical advantages and disadvantages of different major actuation methods used in PMPs.
Actuation method | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|
Electrostatic | Fast response | High operating voltage |
Simple-to-control stroke | Small stroke | |
Low power consumption | Electrolysis (for polar working fluids) | |
Planar structure | ||
Small footprint and size | ||
Motor | Low operating voltage | Complex external mechanism for handling rotary motion |
Large stroke | Non-planar structure | |
Peristalsis-friendly | Relatively large | |
Flexibility to couple to various transmission mechanisms | ||
Piezoelectric | Large actuation force | High operating voltage |
Fast response | Small stroke | |
Simple structure | Complex and bulky driving circuit | |
Planar structure | ||
Pneumatic | Large stroke | Slow response |
Simple-to-control actuation force | Non-planar structure | |
Small footprint | External compressed air and control valves required | |
Soft-lithography-friendly | Not portable | |
Thermal (Thermopneumatic Phase-change Shape memory alloy Hydrogel) | Low operating voltage | Slow response |
Large stroke | High power consumption | |
Large actuation force | Temperature elevation in working fluid | |
Planar structure | ||
Small footprint and size | ||
Simple driving circuit |